Disparity in the timing of vertebrate diversification events between the northern and southern hemispheres
© Tingley and Dubey; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2012
Received: 18 July 2012
Accepted: 12 December 2012
Published: 15 December 2012
Climatic oscillations throughout the Quaternary had profound effects on temperate biodiversity, but the extent of Quaternary climate change was more severe in temperate regions of the northern hemisphere than in the southern hemisphere. We sought to determine whether this geographic disparity differentially influenced the timing of intraspecific diversification events within ectothermic and endothermic vertebrate species. Using published phylogenetic hypotheses, we gathered data on the oldest intraspecific diversification event within mammal, bird, freshwater fish, amphibian, and reptile species from temperate-zone areas. We then tested whether the timing of diversification events differed between hemispheres.
Our analyses provide strong evidence that vertebrates from temperate regions of the northern hemisphere are younger than those from the southern hemisphere. However, we find little evidence to suggest that this relationship differs between endotherms versus ectotherms, or that it varies widely across the five classes of vertebrates that we considered. In addition, we find that on average, endothermic species are much younger than ectothermic species.
Our findings suggest that geographic variation in the magnitude of climatic oscillations during the Quaternary led to substantial disparity in the timing of intraspecific diversification events between northern and southern hemisphere vertebrates, and that the magnitude of this divergence is largely congruent across vertebrate taxa.
KeywordsClimate change Dispersal Ectotherm Endotherm Genetic diversity Glaciation Intraspecific diversification Quaternary
Recent meta-analyses based on molecular dating [12, 13] have revealed significant differences in the timing of the oldest intraspecific diversification event within amphibian and reptile species from the northern and southern hemispheres. In both groups, northern hemisphere species were found to be younger than southern hemisphere species. Similarly, splits between sister species occurred more recently in the northern hemisphere than in southern hemisphere .
A fundamental question is whether this pattern is widespread in vertebrates, or whether it is a pattern that is specific to ectothermic taxa. Ectothermic vertebrates depend on abiotic conditions to thermoregulate, and thus are extremely vulnerable to climatic fluctuations [14, 15]. For example, temperature-dependent sex determination is widespread in reptiles such as lizards, turtles, and crocodiles, making these taxa particularly sensitive to abrupt variations in ambient temperature . This thermal sensitivity means that populations of ectotherms may be more likely to survive (and thus exhibit greater genetic differentiation) in regions with stable climatic conditions. In addition, ectothermic vertebrates such as amphibians, reptiles, and freshwater fish generally have poor dispersal abilities in comparison to similarly-sized endotherms such as mammals and birds, which could expose ectotherms to more severe climates at a given location. Overall, we therefore might expect the ages of ectothermic vertebrates to show a greater degree of disparity between hemispheres than we would for endotherms .
In the present study, we sought to determine whether geographic disparity in Quaternary climatic oscillations between the northern and southern hemispheres differentially influenced the timing of intraspecific diversification events within vertebrate species. We then tested whether the relationship between hemisphere of origin and the timing of intraspecific diversification differed between ectotherms versus endotherms.
Effects of hemisphere of origin (northern versus southern) and taxonomic class (Mammalia, Aves, Amphibia, Reptilia, Actinopterygii) on intraspecific estimates of species ages from temperate-regions across the globe
Likelihood ratio (D)
(a) Complete dataset
D = 14.2
D = 28.8
Hemisphere * Taxonomic class
D = 1.72
(b) High-latitude species
D = 10.5
D = 15.0
Hemisphere * Taxonomic class
D = 2.14
(c) Low-latitude species
D = 9.62
D = 63.5
Hemisphere * Taxonomic class
D = 7.17
When each class was analyzed separately, only the mean ages of reptiles (likelihood ratio test between models including and excluding hemisphere effect: D = 8.22, P = 0.00410) and mammals (D = 4.040, P = 0.0443) differed between hemispheres. There were no significant effects of hemisphere of origin on the mean ages of birds (D = 1.33, P = 0.248), fishes (D = 0.903, P = 0.342), or amphibians (D = 1.79, P = 0.181). Nevertheless, on average, fishes and amphibians from the southern hemisphere were older than those from the northern hemisphere (Figure 2). Furthermore, our finding that diversification events occurred more recently in the southern hemisphere in birds (Figure 2) was highly dependent on the inclusion of a single northern hemisphere species (Alcippe morrisonia) with highly divergent populations (9.86 million years). When this species was excluded from our analyses, bird species from the southern hemisphere were older (mean ± SE 0.814 ± 0.187) than those from the northern hemisphere (0.736 ± 0.0999), although differences between hemispheres remained non-significant (D = 1.78, P = 0.182). Interestingly, our analysis also revealed strong differences between the mean ages of the five vertebrate classes (Figure 2; Table 1).
Effects of hemisphere (northern versus southern) and thermoregulatory strategy (endotherm versus ectotherm) on intraspecific estimates of species ages from temperate-regions across the globe
Likelihood ratio (D)
(a) Complete dataset
D = 14.1
D = 16.1
Hemisphere * Thermoregulatory strategy
D = 0.844
(b) High-latitude species
D = 13.2
D = 7.35
Hemisphere * Thermoregulatory strategy
D = 0.521
(c) Low-latitude species
D = 8.98
D = 60.7
Hemisphere * Thermoregulatory strategy
D = 0.652
Our analysis of molecular phylogenies provides compelling evidence that vertebrate diversification events occurred much more recently in the northern hemisphere than in the southern hemisphere. This pattern was remarkably consistent across different latitudinal subsets of species, suggesting that the geographic variation in species’ ages that we observed here was not substantially influenced by the exclusion of species that were distributed solely at low or high latitudes.
Why are vertebrates from the northern hemisphere younger than those from the southern hemisphere? One plausible explanation, as outlined in the Introduction, is that the observed disparity in diversification histories reflects geographic differences in the extent of climatically-driven extinction events that occurred throughout the Quaternary. Some regions of the southern hemisphere (e.g., inland Australia) were also severely affected by dry conditions during the Quaternary , but palynological data indicate that forested and partially forested areas still persisted in coastal regions, even during the Last Glacial Maximum . Although lineages of some of the species used in our analyses diverged prior to the Quaternary, this does not mean that climatic oscillations during the Quaternary could not be responsible for the observed patterns. Many species lost genetic lineages during the Quaternary , and thus a species may have (randomly) lost its oldest lineage while undergoing range contraction in response to Quaternary climate change. For example, a species that had similar levels of genetic differentiation in both hemispheres prior to the Quaternary would have had a higher probability of losing its oldest genetic lineage in the northern hemisphere because the magnitude of Quaternary climate change was greater there.
Our findings accord with the results of previous analyses that focused exclusively on amphibians and reptiles [12, 13], and thus demonstrate that the patterns revealed by these earlier studies apply to vertebrates as a whole. Indeed, we found no evidence for an interaction between taxonomic class and hemisphere of origin, suggesting that the relationship between geographic origin and species age was broadly consistent across the five classes of vertebrates included in our analyses. Although differences between hemispheres were only statistically significant for mammals and reptiles when each taxonomic group was analyzed separately, partitioning our dataset by taxonomic group entailed a considerable loss of statistical power. In addition, the regression coefficients describing the effects of hemisphere of origin were in the same direction for four out of five taxa, the exception being birds. Nevertheless, similar results were obtained for birds when a single northern hemisphere species that had exceptionally divergent populations was removed from our analyses.
At first glance, this consistency in the effects of geographic location on diversification histories is somewhat surprising given the marked differences in dispersal abilities between the taxa included in our analyses [17, 18]. One potential reason for this seemingly counterintuitive result is that differences in dispersal abilities between taxa are trivial in comparison to the disparity in Quaternary climate changes between the northern and southern hemispheres. However, it should be noted that the mean age of birds, a group that has the greatest dispersal abilities of the taxonomic classes that we considered, showed the least disparity between hemispheres.
Interestingly, studies of antbirds and passerines have revealed greater genetic distances (based on allozymes) within neotropical species than in species from the Nearctic [19, 20]. Similar patterns have also been documented in a suite of birds and mammals from the New World , as well as in plants  and vertebrates  distributed across the globe. Collectively, the results of these studies suggest greater intraspecific genetic variation in regions that have experienced stable long-term climatic conditions. Thus, our finding that diversification events occurred earlier in the southern hemisphere, where climatic oscillations have also been less severe in the past, is in broad accordance with earlier studies on a wide range of taxa.
We also found that the relationship between hemisphere of origin and species age did not differ between ectotherms and endotherms, and this pattern was also evident when we considered each of these two groups in isolation. Future research could usefully explore whether species-level traits that do not show a strong taxonomic signal (e.g., habitat-use) explain additional geographic variation in species ages .
However, we cannot dismiss the possibility that our findings may be an artifact of differing levels of taxonomic knowledge about the vertebrate faunas of the northern and southern hemispheres [13, 20]. Species from the southern hemisphere have generally been less intensively studied than species from the northern hemisphere, and thus some southern hemisphere ‘species’ included in our analyses may actually represent composite taxa. This taxonomic ignorance would, in turn, result in over-estimations of species’ ages in the southern hemisphere. Dubey & Shine  demonstrated that geographic disparity in taxonomic ignorance is a relatively poor explanation for differences in the ages of amphibian species between hemispheres, but that this mechanism could potentially explain the different diversification histories of the two hemispheres for reptiles. However, we consider this interpretation less likely than climatically-driven extinction events given that our findings were relatively consistent across such broadly divergent taxa (see above). We further consider it unlikely that our results are an artifact of using intraspecific rather than interspecific divergence times, given that Dubey & Shine  found very similar geographic patterns in species ages regardless of whether the analysis was performed with intraspecific divergences (across orders and suborders) or with the cladogenic events responsible for species formation . Thus, the same parameters appear to influence these two types of measures . Our finding that diversification events occurred earlier in the southern hemisphere may also have been influenced by the restricted distributions of some taxonomic groups throughout the globe. Some taxa are strictly or more widely represented in one hemisphere, which could impact species age estimations (considering that each taxa exhibits different life-history traits and characteristics).
The differences we observed between endothermic and ectothermic vertebrates could have been due to differences in the dispersal abilities of these groups. Endothermic vertebrates are typically capable of dispersing greater distances than ectothermic vertebrates (e.g., [17, 18, 24]), and taxa that are capable of dispersing greater distances generally have more homogeneous population structures compared to less vagile taxa. Such homogenization would result in fewer divergent lineages within endothermic vertebrates, and ultimately more recent intraspecific diversification events.
Alternatively, the observed differences between endothermic and ectothermic vertebrates could have been due to differences in energetic demands during hibernation. When abiotic conditions become unfavorable, ectothermic vertebrates are capable of lowering their rates of resource consumption to a far greater degree than are endothermic vertebrates [25–27], and thus ectotherms may have been less adversely affected by harsh winter conditions during the Pleistocene. In addition, many ectothermic vertebrates possess efficient mechanisms to deal with sub-zero temperatures (e.g., freeze-avoidance or freeze tolerance strategies: [28–30]). Hence, ectothermic vertebrates may have been more likely to survive climatic fluctuations during the Quaternary compared to endotherms, at least in locations where the minimum temperature required for ectotherm activity was reached during part of the year.
Finally, differences in the timing of intraspecific diversification events between groups may have been caused by variation in life-history traits. For example, reproductive isolation is faster in particular groups such as mammals (compared to birds and amphibians) due to a higher possible rate of regulatory evolution, causing higher probabilities of developmental incompatibilities between mammal species . Consequently, for the same level of genetic divergence, two lineages could be considered sister species in mammals, and intraspecific lineages in birds or amphibians. The vertebrate classes we examined also differ markedly in a wide array of additional traits (e.g., body size), and such traits are known to impact rates of molecular evolution [32–34].
We have shown that there is substantial geographic variation in the timing of intraspecific diversification events within temperate-zone vertebrates. Vertebrate diversification events occurred much more recently in the northern than in the southern hemisphere, plausibly reflecting geographic disparity in the magnitude of climatic oscillations that occurred throughout the Quaternary. Importantly, the relationship between diversification history and geographic location did not differ between endotherms versus ectotherms, or across different classes of vertebrates, suggesting that highly divergent taxa responded similarly to past climate change. However, our analyses did reveal considerable variation in the age of the oldest intraspecific diversification event between taxonomic classes, and between ectotherms and endotherms. Thus, diversification histories within vertebrates appear to not only be influenced by abiotic factors such as climatic fluctuations, but also by taxon-specific parameters (e.g., particular life-history traits). Future studies should seek to clarify the roles of such traits in determining spatial and temporal variation in intraspecific diversification events.
We gathered data on the oldest intraspecific diversification event within temperate-zone mammal (n = 113), bird (n = 99), amphibian (n = 46), fish (n = 53), and reptile (n = 161) species from published phylogenetic articles using searches within Scopus and ISI Web of Knowledge (see online Additional file 1: Appendix S1; as in [12, 35]). The oldest intraspecific diversification event is an estimate of the amount of time since extant populations last shared a common ancestor (i.e. the split between the most basal lineage and the remaining lineages of a given species), and is highly correlated with interspecific estimates of species age . Only data from comprehensive phylogeographic and phylogenetic studies were included in our analyses. Because rates of molecular evolution can vary across taxa , we did not convert sequence divergence values provided in original articles into diversification dates using a standard molecular clock (e.g., 2%; ). Instead, we included only those studies which explicitly provided a diversification date (although estimated dates were sometimes based on substitution rates from closely related taxa). Within amphibians, urodeles (salamanders and newts) were excluded from our analyses, because no urodele species occupy temperate regions in the southern hemisphere. We also excluded non-monophyletic species (based on recent molecular phylogenetic studies) in order to avoid inaccurate species age estimations.
To test for differences in the timing of diversification events between the northern and southern hemispheres, we used linear mixed effects models with species age (Box-Cox transformed to achieve normality) as the dependent variable, and hemisphere of origin and either taxonomic class or thermoregulatory strategy (ectothermy versus endothermy) as fixed effects. Because the timing of diversification events may not be independent across taxa, we also tested for taxonomic autocorrelation by including taxonomic order as a random effect. Insufficient replication at lower taxonomic levels prohibited us from accounting for finer-scale taxonomic autocorrelation. In cases where variances differed between hemispheres or taxonomic groups (heteroscedasticity), a constant variance structure was used to allow for different spread per stratum. The final structure of each model was determined using likelihood ratio tests (α = 0.05). When taxonomic random effects were non-significant, models were refit using generalized least squares. These analyses were then repeated for each taxonomic group and thermoregulatory strategy separately.
We also examined the consistency of our results by analyzing latitudinal subsets of the broader dataset. Specifically, we tested for a latitudinal bias in the differences in species ages between northern and southern hemispheres by repeating the above analyses on (i) low-latitude species only (distributed between the tropics and |40°|), and (ii) high-latitude species only (distributed above |40°|). Amphibians were not represented among high-latitude species in the southern hemisphere, and thus were removed from the latter of these analyses. It is also important to note that for the southern hemisphere, data for species distributed above 40°S are strictly restricted to Oceania (New Zealand and Tasmania) and South America, as the southern tip of Africa is situated at ~35°S. For birds, we only included species that have breeding ranges exclusively above or below |40°| latitude, rather than using an area-weighted centroid. All statistical analyses were conducted in R© 2.13.0 using the nlme library (R Development Core Team, 2011).
RT was funded by a NSERC Postgraduate Scholarship, an Endeavour International Postgraduate Research Scholarship, and a University of Sydney International Postgraduate Award. SD was funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation.
- Markgraf V, McGlone M, Hope G: Neogene paleoenvironmental and paleoclimatic change in southern temperate ecosystems – a southern perspective. Trends Ecol Evol. 1995, 10: 143-147. 10.1016/S0169-5347(00)89023-0.PubMedView Article
- Byrne M: Evidence for multiple refugia at different time scales during Pleistocene climatic oscillations in southern Australia inferred from phylogeography. Quaternary Sci Rev. 2008, 27: 2576-2585. 10.1016/j.quascirev.2008.08.032.View Article
- Avise JC, Walker D, Johns GC: Speciation durations and Pleistocene effects on vertebrate phylogeography. Proc R Soc B. 1998, 265: 1707-1712. 10.1098/rspb.1998.0492.PubMedPubMed CentralView Article
- Jansson R: Global patterns in endemism explained by past climatic change. Proc R Soc B. 2003, 270: 583-590. 10.1098/rspb.2002.2283.PubMedPubMed CentralView Article
- Dubey S, Shine R: Evolutionary diversification of the lizard genus Bassiana (Scincidae) across southern Australia. PLoS One. 2010, 5: e12982-10.1371/journal.pone.0012982.PubMedPubMed CentralView Article
- Hewitt GM: Genetic consequences of climatic oscillations in the Quaternary. Phil T R Soc B. 2004, 359: 183-195. 10.1098/rstb.2003.1388.View Article
- Hewitt GM: The genetic legacy of the Quaternary ice ages. Nature. 2000, 405: 907-913. 10.1038/35016000.PubMedView Article
- Hewitt GM: Ice ages: their impact on species distributions and evolution. Evolution on Planet Earth. Edited by: Rothschild LJ, Lister AM. 2003, New York, NY: Academic Press, 339-361.View Article
- Hewitt GM: Genetic consequences of climatic changes in the Quaternary. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B. 2004, 359: 183-195. 10.1098/rstb.2003.1388.View Article
- Braconnot P, Otto-Bliesner B, Harrison S, Joussaume S, Peterschmitt JY, Abe-Ouchi A, Crucifix M, Driesschaert E, Fichefet T, Hewitt CD, Kageyama M, Kitoh A, Laîné A, Loutre MF, Marti O, Merkel U, Ramstein G, Valdes P, Weber SL, Yu Y, Zhao Y: Results of PMIP2 coupled simulations of the Mid-Holocene and Last Glacial Maximum - Part 1: experiments and large-scale features. Clim Past. 2007, 3: 261-277. 10.5194/cp-3-261-2007.View Article
- Byrne M, Yeates DK, Joseph L, Bowler J, Cooper S, Donnellan SC, Kearney M, Keogh JS, Leijs R, Melville J, Murphy D, Porch N, Williams MA, Wyrwoll KH: Birth of a biome: synthesizing environmental and molecular studies of the assembly and maintenance of the Australian arid zone biota. Mol Ecol. 2008, 17: 4398-4417. 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2008.03899.x.PubMedView Article
- Dubey S, Shine R: Geographic variation in the age of temperate-zone reptile and amphibian species: southern Hemisphere species are older. Biol Letters. 2011, 7: 96-97. 10.1098/rsbl.2010.0557.View Article
- Dubey S, Shine R: Are reptile and amphibian species younger in the Northern Hemisphere than the Southern Hemisphere?. J Evol Biol. 2012, 25: 220-226. 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2011.02417.x.PubMedView Article
- Telemeco RS, Elphick M, Shine R: Nesting lizards (Bassiana duperreyi) compensate partly, but not completely, for climate change. Ecology. 2009, 90: 17-22. 10.1890/08-1452.1.PubMedView Article
- Dubey S, Shine R: Predicting the effects of climate change on an endangered montane lizard, Eulamprus leuraensis (Scincidae). Clim Chang. 2011, 107: 531-547. 10.1007/s10584-010-9963-x.View Article
- Sarre SD, Ezaz T, Georges A: Transitions between sex-determining systems in reptiles and amphibians. Annu Rev Genom Hum G. 2011, 12: 391-406. 10.1146/annurev-genom-082410-101518.View Article
- Dobrovolski R, Melo AS, Cassemiro FAS, Diniz-Filho JAF: Climatic history and dispersal ability explain the relative importance of turnover and nestedness components of beta diversity. Glob Ecol Biogeogr. 2012, 21: 191-197. 10.1111/j.1466-8238.2011.00671.x.View Article
- Gillespie RG, Baldwin BG, Waters JM, Fraser CI, Nikula R, Roderick GK: Long-distance dispersal: a framework for hypothesis testing. Trends Ecol Evol. 2011, 27: 47-56.PubMedView Article
- Hackett SJ, Rosenberg KV: Comparison of phenotypic and genetic differentiation south American antwrens (Formicariidae). Auk. 1990, 107: 473-489.
- Chek AA, Austin JD, Lougheed SC: Why is there a tropical–temperate disparity in the genetic diversity and taxonomy of species?. Evol Ecol Res. 2003, 5: 69-77.
- Weir JT, Schluter D: The latitudinal gradient in recent speciation and extinction rates of birds and mammals. Science. 2007, 315: 1574-1576. 10.1126/science.1135590.PubMedView Article
- Eo SH, Wares JP, Carroll P: Population divergence in plant species reflects latitudinal biodiversity gradients. Biol Lett. 2008, 4: 382-384. 10.1098/rsbl.2008.0109.PubMedPubMed CentralView Article
- Martin PR, Mackay JK: Latitudinal variation in genetic divergence of populations and the potential for future speciation. Evolution. 2004, 58: 938-945.PubMedView Article
- Dubey S, Shine R: Restricted dispersal and genetic diversity in populations of an endangered montane lizard (Eulamprus leuraensis, Scincidae). Mol Ecol. 2010, 19: 886-897. 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2010.04539.x.PubMedView Article
- McNab BK: The physiological ecology of vertebrates: a view from energetics. 2002, Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press
- Gienger CM, Beck DD: Northern Pacific Rattlesnakes (Crotalus oreganus) use thermal and structural cues to choose overwintering hibernacula. Can J Zool. 2011, 89: 1084-1090. 10.1139/z11-086.View Article
- Lovegrove BG: The evolution of endothermy in Cenozoic smammals: a plesiomorphic-apomorphic continuum. Biol Review. 2012, 87: 128-162. 10.1111/j.1469-185X.2011.00188.x.View Article
- Storey KB, Storey JM: Freeze tolerance and intolerance as strategies of winter survival in terrestrially-hibernating amphibians. Comp Biochem Phys A. 1986, 83: 613-617.View Article
- Packard GC, Packard MJ: The overwintering strategy of hatchling painted turtles, or how to survive in the cold without freezing. Bioscience. 2001, 51: 199-207. 10.1641/0006-3568(2001)051[0199:TOSOHP]2.0.CO;2.View Article
- Voituron Y, Eugene M, Barre H: Survival and metabolic responses to freezing by the water frog (Rana ridibunda). J Exp Zool Part A. 2003, 299: 118-126.View Article
- Fitzpatrick BM: Rates of evolution of hybrid inviability in birds and mammals. Evolution. 2004, 58: 1865-1870.PubMedView Article
- Eo SH, Doyle JM, DeWoody JA: Genetic diversity in birds is associated with body mass and habitat type. J Zool. 2011, 283: 220-226. 10.1111/j.1469-7998.2010.00773.x.View Article
- Bromham L: Molecular clocks in reptiles: life history influences rate of molecular evolution. Mol Biol Evol. 2002, 19: 302-309. 10.1093/oxfordjournals.molbev.a004083.PubMedView Article
- Wright SD, Gillman LN, Ross HA, Keeling DJ: Energy and the tempo of evolution in amphibians. Glob Ecol Biogeogr. 2010, 19: 733-740.
- Pizzato L, Dubey S: Colour-polymorphic snake species are older. Biol J Linn Soc. 2012, 107: 210-218. 10.1111/j.1095-8312.2012.01936.x.View Article
- Weir JT, Schluter D: Calibrating the avian molecular clock. Mol Ecol. 2008, 17: 2321-2328. 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2008.03742.x.PubMedView Article
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.