- Research article
- Open Access
Evolution under strong balancing selection: how many codons determine specificity at the female self-incompatibility gene SRK in Brassicaceae?
© Castric and Vekemans; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2007
- Received: 27 November 2006
- Accepted: 06 August 2007
- Published: 06 August 2007
Molecular lock-and-key systems are common among reproductive proteins, yet their evolution remains a major puzzle in evolutionary biology. In the Brassicaceae, the genes encoding self-incompatibility have been identified, but technical challenges currently prevent detailed analyses of the molecular interaction between the male and female components. In the present study, we investigate sequence polymorphism in the female specificity determinant SRK of Arabidopsis halleri from throughout Europe. Using a comparative approach based on published SRK sequences in A. lyrata and Brassica, we track the signature of frequency-dependent selection acting on these genes at the codon level. Using simulations, we evaluate power and accuracy of our approach and estimate the proportion of codon sites involved in the molecular interaction.
We identified several members of the S-gene family, together with 22 putative S-haplotypes. Linkage to the S-locus and the presence of a kinase domain were formally demonstrated for four and six of these haplotypes, respectively, and sequence polymorphism was extremely high. Twenty-five codons showed signs of positive selection in at least one species, and clustered significantly (but not exclusively) within hypervariable regions. We checked that this clustering was not an artifact due to variation in evolution rate at synonymous sites. Simulations revealed that the analysis was highly accurate, thus providing a reliable set of candidates for future functional analyses, but with an overall power not higher than 60 %. Assuming similar power, we infer from our results that about 23% of all codons in the S-domain may actually be involved in recognition. Interestingly, while simulations demonstrated that this comparison remained reliable even at very high levels of divergence, codons identified in Brassica had higher posterior rates of non-synonymous to synonymous substitutions than codons identified in A. halleri or A. lyrata, possibly suggesting more intense selection in Brassica.
The signature of balancing selection can be identified reliably at the codon level even in cases of very high sequence divergence, provided that a sufficiently large set of sequences are analyzed. Altogether, our results indicate that a large proportion of codons may be involved in recognition and confirm the particular importance of hypervariable regions. The more intense signature of positive selection detected in Brassica suggests that allelic diversification in this genus was very recent, possibly following a recent demographic bottleneck.
- Kinase Domain
- Hypervariable Region
- Codon Site
- High Sequence Divergence
Molecular lock-and-key systems are common among reproductive proteins and receptor-hormone complexes . Because the lock and the key must match in such systems, any evolutionary novelty at one component must be accompanied by a matching novelty at the other. This coevolution constraint has made the generation of new combinations a major -and as yet unsolved- puzzle in evolutionary biology [2–4]. Understanding molecular details of the interaction can give important insight into the evolutionary dynamics of these systems . In particular, the proportion of sites involved in recognition and potentially able to alter the interaction is crucial.
Self-incompatibility (SI) systems are fascinating molecular lock-and-key mechanisms preventing selfing in species from over half of all angiosperm families . In the Brassicaceae, the lock and the key are encoded by SRK and SCR respectively, two highly polymorphic and closely linked genes. SCR encodes a small protein expressed in anthers and deposited in the pollen exine layer, while SRK encodes a transmembrane serine/threonine kinase with allele-specific affinity for SCR proteins.
SRK is an integral component of the plasma membrane of the stigma epidermis and is displayed with its glycosylated N-terminal S-domain external to the cell. When activated by binding to its cognate SCR protein [7, 8], it prevents selfing by triggering a downstream regulatory pathway that ultimately inhibits pollen tube germination.
Although the recognition between SCR and SRK has been demonstrated at the molecular level, the regions of these molecules important for specificity recognition have remained elusive. In SCR, a domain swapping experiment in Brassica between allele SCR6 and allele SCR13 resulted in a switch from SCR6 to SCR13 specificity, but failed to switch specificity when the reverse swapping (SCR13 domains to a SCR6 backbone) was performed . These results suggest the intriguing possibility that functionally important sites may not be the same in the two alleles investigated.
Clearly, the analysis of more alleles will now be required to confirm the role of these domains (see also [10–12]). A second experimental approach in SCR relied on the functional comparison between pairs of closely related alleles in Brassica rapa and B. oleracea.  demonstrated that pollen specificity was partly and completely altered between SCR copies differing by four and eight amino-acid differences respectively, thus providing strong candidates for functionally important codons. In SRK, technical challenges associated with crystallizing trans-membrane proteins have hampered the resolution of the three-dimensional structure of the protein, such that sites involved in binding SCR (and thus determining specificity) are currently unknown. Hence, specificity-determining nucleotides along the SRK sequence have mainly been inferred from the observation that stretches of nucleotides have unusually elevated replacement site polymorphism as compared to the rest of the S-domain. Such hyper-variable (HV) regions have been observed in Brassica [14–16], Raphanus sativus  and Arabidopsis lyrata .  and  demonstrated that these regions are particularly conserved among functionally equivalent allelic copies of BoSRK02 and BoSRK13 in B. oleracea, and  further showed that pairs of closely related alleles in B. rapa and B. oleraceae with identical recognition specificity typically exhibit very few differences in HV regions. More recently,  provided further support for a functional role of these regions by reporting that alleles in A. halleri, A. lyrata and A. thaliana that were probably inherited from a common ancestor have fewer amino acid differences in these regions than in the rest of the gene.
A limit to this "direct comparison" approach to pinpoint functionally important sites is that it typically relies on a low number of naturally occurring variants and does not integrate over evolutionary times. An alternative approach is based on the assumption that sites involved in the interaction evolve under specific selective pressures. In particular, while purifying selection at a codon site is expected to decrease the rate of non-synonymous to synonymous evolution (dN/dS ratio, hereafter ω), positive and balancing selections are expected to increase this ratio. Tracking the signature of natural selection at the codon level can thus reveal functionally important sites along a sequence (see e.g. ). As initially demonstrated by Wright , loci governing SI are expected to experience negative frequency-dependent selection, a form of strong balancing selection whereby low frequency SCR-SRK combinations enjoy a selective advantage over alleles present at higher frequency because they encounter their cognate allele only rarely. Consequently, substitutions affecting allelic specificity are expected to enter a population more often than substitutions not affecting specificity, leading to a higher rate of non-synonymous than synonymous substitution at codons functionally determining specificity. In line with this expectation,  found higher dN/dS in Brassica HV regions than in the rest of the protein (1.37 within vs. 0.41 outside HV regions), thus providing further support for their role in specificity.
Similarly,  showed that HV regions in Brassica are enriched in sites with elevated dN/dS ratios as compared to the rest of the protein.
A recent paper estimated in Brassica that 27 of the c.a. 423 codon sites (= 6.38%) of the S-domain of SRK (precise length varies) are likely to evolve under recurrent positive selection events . However, the very long expected time to coalescence of alleles at SRK translates into very high levels of diversity, which can saturate the signal of divergence. This may bring uncertainty into the phylogeny of SRK alleles, causing potential bias and lowering the power of the detection method. As shown by , the power of the analysis indeed decreases with sequence divergence. The possibility thus exists that these codons represent a very small proportion of sites involved in specificity. Moreover, SRK diversity in Brassica is unusual among the Brassicaceae in that alleles at this locus cluster into two very distinct and highly divergent allelic classes. Brassica thus only shows a subset of the total molecular diversity found at this gene in the related A. lyrata , and we recently reported at least two deeply divergent SRK alleles in the closely related A. halleri . There has currently been no evaluation of how the particular allelic topology in Brassica may affect the power and accuracy of the method. As reported in , increasing the number of lineages (e.g. by including widely divergent lineages from Arabidopsis species) is one of the most efficient ways to increase the statistical power of the method.
In the present paper, we aim at estimating the number of codons determining allelic specificity at the pistil gene involved in self-incompatibility in the Brassicaceae, and at testing whether these codons cluster specifically within the well-known hypervariable regions of the S-domain, through an analysis of a large data set of sequences belonging to three taxa. We report nucleotide sequences for 22 new SRK alleles in A. halleri, including about half of the S-domain for all alleles and the kinase domain for six alleles. We provide evidence for some of these sequences that they do indeed belong to SRK and compare sequence polymorphism between A. halleri, A. lyrata and Brassica. We use a maximum likelihood method to identify codons along the gene that evolved under positive selection and compare the number, location and rate of evolution of such sites in the three taxa. Through simulations we demonstrate that the analysis is highly accurate, and estimate that the power approaches 60%. Since 25 codons exhibit signs of positive selection in at least one species, we estimate that almost a quarter of the sites in the sequence (23%) could be involved in recognition. Our analysis also provides additional support for a functional role of hypervariable regions along the gene, and suggests that the high diversity observed in the kinase domain is due to tight linkage to the S-domain rather than to direct exposure to positive selection.
Sampling locations of individuals analyzed in this study and inventory of the sequences identified from the S-locus and from separate loci belonging to the Brassicaceae S gene family.
Number of plants analyzed
Other S gene family sequences
AhSRK01, 02, 03, 04, 12
Aly13-2, Aly13-7, Aly7, Aly8, Aly9, Aly10.1
AhSRK01, 05, 11
Characteristics of the A. halleri alleles.
Demonstrated presence of a kinase domain (length of intron 1)
Existence of a closely related A. lyrata allele
Evidence for linkage to incompatibility phenotype (P)
Group (according to Prigoda, Nassuth, and Mable 2005)
Yes (504 bp)
Yes (255 bp)
Yes (588 bp)
Yes (678 bp)
Yes (411 bp)
Yes (788 bp)
Co-segregation of four putative SRK alleles and linkage to incompatibility phenotype
Offspring from a controlled interspecific cross between an A. lyrata plant with genotype AlSRK14/AlSRK21 and an A. halleri pollen donor with genotype AhSRK15/AhSRK21 demonstrated strict co-segregation of the two pairs of putative SRK alleles, although with segregation ratios substantially different from the expected 1:1 ratio: AlSRK14/AlSRK21 with a ratio 39:14 and AhSRK15/AhSRK21 with a ratio 43:17. Segregation bias among S-alleles has already been reported in .
Incompatibility reactions were tested for ten progeny plants from the interspecific cross, including 2 or more of each of the four SRK genotypes. 108 pollinations involved plants whose putative genotypes predict compatibility (no shared SRK sequences), and for these fruit set was 90.7%. 104 pollinations involved plants whose putative genotypes predict cross-incompatibility, and the mean fruit set was 3.8%. These results provided direct evidence that AhSRK15 and AhSRK21 are functional SRK alleles in A. halleri, and confirmed that AlSRK14 and AlSRK21 are functional SRK alleles in A. lyrata.
Diversity estimates for the coding sequence of SRK in A. halleri
Sites under positive selection
Analysis of the subset of longer sequences in A. halleri including both the S- and the kinase domains using model M8 revealed that eight of the 323 codons analyzed (273S, 274D, 276Y, 287I, 299I, 345I, 415E, 421Y) belonged to the maximum likelihood "positively selected" category. Consistent with , all of these codons were from the S-domain, and none of them were from the kinase domain. Since only six kinase domain sequences were available in A. halleri, the analysis had low power and none of these sites had a posterior BEB probability of belonging to the ω > 1 category above 0.95.
These results were robust to both model specifications (number of categories allowed for non-positively selected sites) and uncertainties in phylogenetic reconstruction. One, 7, and 8 sites were retrieved by M8 (10 categories for non-positively selected sites) but were not retrieved by M2a (a single category) in Brassica, A. halleri and A. lyrata, respectively, while sites retrieved by M2a were in all three taxa subsets of those retrieved by M8. Thus, in all three taxa, both models returned very similar sets of sites, except that M2a returned a lower number of sites, presumably due to lower power. Results were also robust to uncertainties in the phylogenetic reconstruction. The 95% credible set of trees was of different size in the three taxa, with 5, 93 and 903 trees in A. halleri, Brassica and A. lyrata, respectively. In A. halleri, the maximum likelihood "positively selected" category was very similar across the five credible topologies, with only minor differences apparent in the posterior BEB probabilities (one topology identified 13 sites and two identified 14 sites versus 12 sites in the ML-tree). In Brassica, the analysis of ten trees randomly chosen from the 93 credible set consistently recovered 11 of the twelve sites identified by the BEB procedure using the ML-tree. The higher uncertainty in the phylogenetic reconstruction in A. lyrata (903 trees in the 95% credible set of trees) apparently led to a higher level of uncertainty in the identification of sites, since only eight of the 13 sites were consistently identified using ten randomly chosen trees from the credible set.
As shown on Fig. 3, a single site (274D) was consistently identified as evolving under positive selection in all three species, while most sites were only identified in a single species or in two different species. Of the 12 sites identified in A. halleri, only 2 (16.7%) were also identified in Brassica. Similarly, of the 13 sites identified in A. lyrata, only 3 (23.1%) were also identified in Brassica. Although the concordance between A. halleri and A. lyrata was higher (64.1%), this may still be considered very low given the close phylogenetic proximity of these two species. Interestingly, posterior ω estimates for these sites also differed greatly among taxa. Codon sites in Brassica with a high (>0.95) probability of belonging to the ω > 1 category had a BEB posterior ω of 2.985 (average across the 12 sites). In sharp contrast, the BEB posterior ω s were 1.444 and 1.486 in A. halleri and A. lyrata, respectively, i.e. about two times smaller (2.038 times smaller on average).
Simulations in EVOLVER revealed that this low level of concordance was indeed expected given the method's low power and the large divergence among SRK sequences. All sequences from the three species (65 sequences in total) were used to obtain the phylogeny shown on Fig. 1B. The maximum likelihood analysis with CODEML identified that 11.8% of the 161 sites (i.e. 19 codons) were evolving under ω = 1.754 >1. These values, along with the estimated codon equilibrium frequency, ω distribution (p = 0.530, q = 0.758 for the β distribution), tree length (23.47 substitutions per codon site) and transition/transversion ratio (κ = 1.9375), were used to simulate 100 replicates of the evolution of 65 sequences. These simulations first confirmed that the method was highly accurate at this high level of divergence. Analysing simulations run with no site in the ω > 1 category (model M7), we found that accuracy was indeed consistently high (0.97, 0.93 and 0.95 in Brassica, A. halleri and A. lyrata, respectively), suggesting that sites classified with high probability (>0.95) into the ω > 1 category were unlikely to be false positives. However, the power of the analysis was apparently low when analyzing a single taxon at a time, since only 14.8%, 34.2 and 38.5% of sites simulated as positively selected were effectively detected in Brassica, A. halleri, and A. lyrata respectively. In contrast, the multi-species screen had substantially higher power. On average, collectively considering all sites detected by at least one of the three taxa allowed us to effectively identify 59.2% of all positively selected sites. This increased power of the multi-species screen was accompanied by a slight decrease of accuracy to 0.86, still suggesting that the identification of sites in the ω > 1 category was reliable.
Twenty-two SRK sequences in A. halleri
Combining results from this study with those from , a total of twenty-two S-alleles have been identified and sequenced in A. halleri, together with several other members of the S-gene family previously identified in A. lyrata. Co-segregation and linkage to the incompatibility phenotype has been demonstrated for the eight S-alleles tested (AhSRK01, AhSRK04, AhSRK12 and AhSRK21 in ; AhSRK15, AhSRK21, AlSRK14 and AlSRK21 in this study). By tracing recombinants in a backcross involving a F1 hybrid between A. halleri and A. lyrata with genotype AhSRK01/AlSRK21,  also demonstrated that the functional S-locus is localized at a position analogous to the ψSRK position in A. thaliana . These observations are particularly important because  showed that SRK sequences in A. lyrata do not show 100% monophyly, as two unlinked sequences (Aly13-2 and Aly13-7) were found to be nested within the SRK cluster. Our results confirm that these two sequences seem to be exceptions, since all other putative SRK sequences that have been identified and tested have proven to be linked to self-incompatibility (see e.g. ). Consistent with these sequences belonging to SRK, and thus evolving under strong balancing selection causing long coalescence times , we found that 12 of the 22 putative S-alleles in A. halleri form trans-specific pairs with high similarity with S-alleles sequences from A. lyrata. Overall, the level of diversity among putative S-alleles in A. halleri is comparable to that reported for SRK haplotypes in A. lyrata .
Indeed, this level of diversity is the highest ever-reported in A. halleri, both in terms of the number of different haplotypes (20 sequences here plus 2 sequences previously reported in  = 22 different sequences in a total of 36 individuals) and in terms of sequence polymorphism. The most exhaustive study of sequence polymorphism to date in A. halleri reported a mean silent nucleotide diversity π S = 0.015 (range [0.0025–0.0569], ) across eight independent genes, while we observed π S = 0.819 in exon 1 of SRK, i.e. a 54 fold increase in diversity. Analyzing the pattern of variation across the whole gene, we see no clear relationship between synonymous nucleotide diversity and distance from the S-domain, as noted already by  in A. lyrata. As we also showed that positively selected sites are only occurring in exon 1, this suggests that the high diversity observed in exons 2 to 6 is due to genetic hitchhiking and also that intragenic recombination is very low.
How many sites evolve under positive selection?
The PAML approach has been extremely successful in revealing protein evolution in a variety of situations. Our study empirically demonstrates the limits but still usefulness of this approach in a case of extreme sequence divergence. Although the power of the analysis was low in any of the three taxa, the accuracy remained very high. This observation is consistent with results of a simulation study by , who revealed that the accuracy remained high and that increasing the number of lineages was the best way to increase statistical power, even at high levels of divergence. Our approach, combining sets of sites revealed by at least one taxon (25 codons revealed) was apparently more powerful than defining the set of sites from a single dataset containing all three taxa (19 codons revealed), so we conclude that 25 codon sites over 180 (13.9%) are identified as evolving under positive selection. Because of limited statistical power of the analysis, however, this represents only a fraction of all sites truly evolving under positive selection. Our simulations allowed us to estimate that the power of this multi-species screen was 59.8%. By extrapolation, we thus estimate that 25/0.598 = 41.8 of the 180 codon sites have evolved under positive selection, i.e. almost a quarter of the sites in the sequence could be involved in recognition. This proportion is higher than that reported in  in Brassica (6.38% of sites) and also higher than those recently reported in the gametophytic self-incompatibility pollen SFB gene in Prunus spinosa (23 out of 315 sites = 7.3%, ) and the gametophytic self-incompatibility pistil S-RNase gene in Lycium parishii (7 out of 130 sites = 5.4%, ). As we showed here, a possible explanation for this difference is that the screens used in these studies may also have had low power. Collectively, these results thus indicate that a large proportion of sites in self-incompatibility genes are probably involved in the molecular interaction determining compatibility.
Location of sites under positive selection
Because of the low level of false positives revealed by our simulations, sites belonging to the ω > 1 category should be considered as reliable candidates for further functional analyses. These codons were strongly clustered in hypervariable regions, and we checked that this observation was not an artifact due to variation in evolution rate at synonymous sites. Our results thus support previous claims of the functional importance of hypervariable regions [14–21, 25]. Interestingly, however, their distribution across HV2, HV3 and CVR differed strongly among the three taxa, with HV3 containing most sites detected in Brassica, while this region contained a very low number of positively selected sites in A. halleri and A. lyrata. In line with , this raises the intriguing possibility that functionally important parts of the proteins may differ along different allelic lineages. However, although our simulation approach demonstrated that the number of false positives remained very low, it also demonstrated that such a poor concordance among sites identified in different taxa is consistent with the analysis of highly divergent sequences.
More intense selection in Brassica ?
Our study also revealed that the observed higher posterior ω estimate in Brassica as compared to A. halleri and A. lyrata was outside the expected range of random variation computed from simulations, possibly suggesting more intense selection in Brassica. How should higher posterior ω in Brassica as compared to A. halleri and A. lyrata be interpreted biologically? All three taxa most probably inherited a common set of alleles from their ancestor. Although the number of alleles is comparably high in the three taxa, Brassica alleles cluster in two main lineages, whereas all A. halleri and A. lyrata alleles are highly divergent from one another. A possible explanation for this difference is that the genus Brassica went through a severe bottleneck that drastically reduced the number of alleles. As noted by , the intensity of balancing selection on an S-locus is inversely related to the number of alleles in a population. Thus, balancing selection may have been very intense, leading to strong selection for allelic diversification shortly after the putative bottleneck. How strong a bottleneck can generate such a difference in posterior ω remains to be determined.
Balancing vs. positive selection: exploring the limits of PAML
Although phylogenetic methods to detect natural selection on protein coding sequences have initially been developed for between-species comparisons, there is an increasing interest in adapting these methods to the analysis of intraspecific polymorphism. Our data can be used to evaluate some limits of this approach.
A first limit is that our simulation procedure assumed a constant ω for each codon across the whole phylogeny. This is unlikely to be true, since frequency-dependent selection implies that an allele's selection regime varies together with its frequency. Indeed, a newly arisen allele initially experiences positive selection as long as it remains below its equilibrium frequency. Once equilibrium has been reached, the allele is then actively maintained by balancing selection, not positive selection anymore. ω values are thus expected to change along each branch of the phylogeny, such that their precise interpretation is unclear in the context of frequency-dependent selection.
A second limit is that our approach assumes no recombination. Simulations by  have shown that the presence of recombination affects the power to detect selection because PAML assumes a single tree for the whole protein, whereas recombination leads to different gene genealogies in different regions of the gene. Currently available methods to estimate jointly recombination and selective pressures along the gene (e.g. ) rely on explicit population genetics models, while we obtained a single sequence for each SRK haplotype in the whole species. Accurate allele frequency data are thus not available, currently preventing us from taking recombination formally into account. Although we acknowledge that this will be important once appropriate data are available, we think that recombination is probably not causing bias in the analyses for the following reasons. As shown by , PAML is indeed relatively tolerant for a certain range in the recombination rate, especially with models M7 and M8. In addition, the existence of separate genes for the pollen and pistil recognition functions apparently causes suppressed recombination to maintain coadapted sets of the two different loci. Accordingly, comparison between physical and genetic maps of the chromosome carrying the S-locus indeed showed reduced recombination in the SI region in A. lyrata . In line with , reduced recombination is compatible with our observation of no significant decrease of LD across the S-domain as well as with a strong hitchhiking effect on synonymous nucleotide variation throughout the kinase domain of SRK.
A third limit of the parametric bootstrap approach used to investigate power and accuracy is that it relies on parameters estimated from the data. Given the important divergence observed among sequences, saturation is likely to occur and divergence is probably the most poorly estimated parameter of our analysis. In particular, the length of the long internal branches of the tree used to simulate sequence evolution is probably poorly estimated. In addition, the three taxa analyzed have very contrasted allelic phylogenies. Brassica has a single long internal branch separating the two dominance classes, while A. lyrata and A. halleri have numerous long branches, so the number of non-synonymous substitutions may be underestimated more severely in A. lyrata and A. halleri than in Brassica, thus providing a potential explanation for the lower ω in A. halleri or A. lyrata than in Brassica. Could uncertainty in branch length estimation have affected our conclusions? Our simulations revealed that power declined with sequence divergence more quickly than accuracy of the posterior ω estimation. Thus, the signal of positive selection was lost before any bias in the BEB posterior ω estimation could be detected. Our simulation approach mimics the generation of real datasets, such that any bias due to saturation would be present in both real and simulated datasets, making the comparison robust to such effects.
This is the first report of sequence polymorphism at the female specificity determinant gene SRK in the self-incompatible Arabidopsis halleri. Sequence polymorphism was extremely high, and twenty-five codons showed signs of positive selection in either A. halleri, A. lyrata or Brassica. Using simulations, we demonstrate that the signature of balancing selection can be identified reliably at the codon level and estimate that over 20% of all codons in the S-domain may actually be involved in recognition. Brassica had higher posterior rates of non-synonymous to synonymous substitutions than either A. halleri or A. lyrata, possibly suggesting that allelic diversification in this genus was both more recent and more intense than in either A. halleri or A. lyrata.
A total of 36 A. halleri individuals was screened for SRK polymorphism. Individuals were collected from 17 widely distributed European populations (Table 1). A single individual was analyzed per population, except in Auby, where 16 individuals were analyzed and in AL08 and TC05, where two individuals were analyzed (Table 1). Fresh leaves were dried overnight at 55°C and DNA was extracted using the extraction kit Dneasy® from Qiagen®.
In line with the notation proposed by , AhSRKx, AlSRKx, BoSRKx and BrSRKx refer to haplotype x in A. halleri, A. lyrata, B. oleraceae and B. rapa, respectively. Nearly full-length sequences for AhSRK04 and AhSRK10 were taken from . A. lyrata sequences (n = 24) were taken from  and Brassica sequences (n = 19) from . SRK polymorphism in A. halleri was first screened using the S-domain only.
Because of the lack of fully conserved regions along the S-domain, several primer pairs were used in an attempt to identify the largest possible set of different alleles (primer sequences and amplification conditions in ). 13SEQ2F and SLGR were used as forward and reverse primers, respectively, for all individuals, and 13SEQ1F and SLGF were used as forward primers in combination with SLGR for a subset of individuals where either a single or no allele was identified with 13SEQ2F-SLGR. Amplification products were ligated into plasmids and transformed into chemically competent bacteria using the TOPO TA cloning kit (Invitrogen Corporation) according to the manufacturer's protocol. An average of 8 positive clones per individual (1–45) were sequenced using the vector's M13 forward and reverse sequencing primers and BigDye3.1 (Appplied Biosystems) sequencing kit on an ABI3100 capillary sequencer. Sequences were edited using MEGA3  and searched with BLASTN against a local library of sequences containing all published sequences of the S-family in A. lyrata [22, 33, 34, 44]. Sequences whose closest match was one of the A. lyrata alleles demonstrated to be linked to the SI phenotype were provisionally considered to also be SRK alleles in A. halleri. Among those, sequences with a maximum divergence of 8.1% (average A. halleri-A. lyrata divergence across 10 unlinked genes; ) were considered as "matching alleles" of either ancestral origin or introgression. Sequences whose closest match was a member of the gene family in A. lyrata were considered as paralogues. Since Aly13-2 and Aly13-7 in A. lyrata were found to be independent from the SI phenotype , matches to these sequences were excluded. To correct for PCR errors, positive clones were then screened further until at least three replicates were obtained for each of these sequences. Majority-rule consensus sequences were obtained by manual correction.
Evidence for the presence of a kinase domain linked to the S-domain was then searched in several of the putative S-alleles using allele-specific forward primers designed from the S-domain sequence in conjunction with general degenerate reverse primers from the kinase domain : R4997 : CACCKYGARTCTTKGTGAAG or R4694 : AVATTTTCCAAGTAYTCRTA designed from an alignment of the published SRK kinase domain sequences in A. lyrata. The PCR products obtained were sequenced directly as reported above, using intermediate internal sequencing primers to tile the sequences entirely.
We tested for co-segregation of two pairs of putative SRK haplotypes among offspring obtained from an interspecific cross between A. halleri (pollen donor) and A. lyrata (pollen receiver). Seeds were allowed to germinate in small pots and seedlings were harvested, dried and DNA was extracted as described above. Offspring were genotyped using primers specific to each of the four SRK haplotypes of the parents (V. Castric, unpublished results). To test for an association between putative SRK genotypes and incompatibility phenotypes, we performed controlled pollinations among offspring of this cross and estimated compatibility of the genotypes through measurements of fruit-set.
Structural and diversity analysis
Nucleotide sequences were trimmed to the shortest and translated into amino acid sequences in MEGA3.1. To preserve the amino acid numbering of the sequence, A. halleri and A. lyrata amino acid sequences were all aligned to the alignment profile used in , kindly provided by R. Sainudiin) using CLUSTALX  followed by manual adjustments in the alignment editor in MEGA3.1. In accordance with , codon positions in the alignment were numbered from the ATG codon of BoSRK60. N-linked glycosylation sites along the amino acid sequences [46, 47] were identified using N-GLYCOSITE [48, 49]. Variation of amino acid diversity was investigated along the sequence by sliding a 5 amino acids window with a step of 1 amino acid. We tested for recombination by comparing the relationship between a measure of linkage disequilibrium (r2) and the distance between polymorphic sites, as implemented in the software package LDHAT 2.0 . Significance of the correlation was determined from 1,000 permutations of the variable sites.
Sites under positive selection
Sites evolving under positive selection were searched for using the codon-based model implemented in CODEML in the PAML analysis package  using the "complete deletion" option, i.e. only sites with no indel in any of the sequences were included in the analysis. Briefly, a maximum-likelihood phylogenetic tree was constructed using DNA-ML from the PHYLIP package  for sequences of each taxon separately, as well as for combined datasets including all three taxa. Given this topology, the log-likelihood of models M7, M8a and M8 of  were compared using a likelihood ratio test (LRT). Models M7 and M8a allow the different codon sites along the sequence to evolve under a range of beta-distributed ω ratios (0 <ω < 1 for M7 and 0 <ω ≤ 1 for M8a), thus simulating a range of constraints by purifying -but not positive- selection. M8 includes all these features, but has an additional category for sites with ω > 1, thus allowing for positively selected sites. Given the proposed tree topology, CODEML uses Felsenstein's pruning algorithm to sum over all possible ancestral states and maximize the overall likelihood of model M8 for the observed sequences. This procedure thus provides maximum likelihood estimates for the codon substitution model, the transition/transversion ratio κ, the overall number of nucleotide substitutions per codon (tree length) and the distribution of replacement vs. silent substitutions dN/dS = ω. Since model M7 is nested within model M8, a LRT with two degrees of freedom was used to determine whether M8 provides a comparatively better fit than M8, and thus whether positively selected sites occur along the sequence. A LRT with one degree of freedom was used to compare M8a with M8 . The Bayes Empirical Bayes (BEB) procedure  was then used to estimate at each site the probability that it belongs to the ω > 1 category. Sites having a probability >0.95 of belonging to this category were referred to as "positively selected" sites. We compared the strength of selection between hypervariable regions and the rest of the protein using two approaches. We first used the hypergeometric distribution to determine whether these sites clustered within hypervariable regions. We then used HYPHY V.0.99  to compare the likelihood of a model allowing different ω for HV regions and the rest of the protein with that of a model constraining them to be equal (the "fixed-sites" approach described in , LRT with one degree of freedom). We also used HYPHY to test for differences in rate of synonymous substitutions between HV regions and the rest of the protein, as such differences could lead to misidentification of sites as positively selected . The locations of positively selected sites in A. halleri and A. lyrata were compared with those obtained from the analysis in Brassica. The level of pairwise concordance was determined as the average proportion of sites retrieved in a taxon that were also retrieved in the other taxon. For each taxon, posterior ω were averaged over all positively selected sites. As advocated in , robustness to the exact model specification was assessed by comparing sites retrieved by M8 with those retrieved by M2a, a simpler model where all sites evolving under purifying selection belong to a single category. The sensitivity of the method to the exact tree topology was assessed by running M8 under a subset of trees of the 95% credible set of trees obtained in MRBAYES version 3.1 , implementing a general reversible time 4×4 nucleotides transition model with equal rates across sites. Two independent MCMC chains were run for 1,000,000 iterations and trees were sampled every 100 iterations after discarding the first 2,500 for burn-in.
The following parametric bootstrap approach was then used to determine whether the observed concordance between sites retrieved by all three taxa was indeed expected given the observed phylogeny. The program EVOLVER in the PAML package was used to simulate 100 replicates of sequence evolution with a fixed proportion of sites evolving under positive selection. All parameters used for these simulations, including the number of codons evolving under positive selection, were assigned their maximum likelihood estimates under model M8 obtained using the whole dataset that included all three taxa (22, 24 and 19 sequences in A. halleri, A. lyrata and Brassica, respectively, i.e. 65 sequences total). The simulated sequences obtained were then separated into three subgroups corresponding to the three taxa and were analyzed separately with the same CODEML procedure as described above. Given that sites evolving under positive selection in the simulations were identical across all three taxa, we expected that the analysis in each taxon should consistently retrieve the same sites. Thus, the level of pairwise concordance of each simulated dataset was compared to that of the real data. In addition, since sites evolving under positive selection were known in the simulations, these simulations enabled us to quantify the statistical power of the BEB procedure when model M8 was analyzed with sequences from a single taxon. Following , power was defined as the proportion of sites actually evolving under positive selection that the analysis was able to detect. Accuracy was defined as 1 minus the rate of false positives and assessed by analyzing with model M8 100 replicate simulations where no site evolved under positive selection (model M7). Power and accuracy were also investigated using all sites detected by any of the taxa, i.e. on the combined set of sites across all three taxa independently. Because the results revealed large differences among taxa in posterior BEB ω estimations (averaged across sites classified in the ω > 1 category), the simulated sequences used to assess power were also used to determine whether such differences were compatible with a null model where all sequences evolved according to the same ω distribution.
We then investigated the effect of decreasing or increasing sequence divergence on power, accuracy and the posterior ω estimate. We simulated different levels of sequence divergence by varying the overall number of nucleotide substitutions per codon (tree length 5–150 nucleotide substitutions per codon), thus simulating evolution for shorter or longer periods of time. Simulations were run along the fixed ML-topology including all three taxa, and datasets were analyzed separately for each taxon. Five and 150 nucleotide substitutions per codon site distributed over the whole 65-sequences phylogeny were chosen to represent realistically low and high extremes of sequence divergence, respectively. Power, accuracy and posterior ω estimate results were determined and averaged over five independent replicates for each level of divergence.
We thank M. H. Schierup, D. Charlesworth and J. Bechsgaard for numerous discussions. We also thank D. Charlesworth and three anonymous reviewers for detailed comments and constructive criticisms on earlier versions of the manuscript. V. Ruggiero, V. Llaurens, P. Saumitou-Laprade and G. Willems shared plant material as well as unpublished data and R. Sainudiin kindly shared his alignment of Brassica sequences. Adeline Courseaux, Eric Schmitt and Claire Feutrie provided excellent technical help in the lab and in the greenhouse. VC was supported by a CDD post-doc grant from CNRS. This study was funded by an ATIP grant from CNRS-Life Science Department, a FEDER fund from the E.U., an ARCIR grant from the Région Nord-Pas de Calais and PPF Bioinformatics from USTL.
- Clark NL, Aagaard JE, Swanson WJ: Evolution of reproductive proteins from animals and plants. Reproduction. 2006, 131: 11-22. 10.1530/rep.1.00357.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Charlesworth D: How can two-gene models of self-incompatibility generate new specificities?. Plant Cell. 2000, 12: 309-310. 10.1105/tpc.12.3.309.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Uyenoyama MK, Newbigin E: Evolutionary dynamics of dual-specificity self-incompatibility alleles. Plant Cell. 2000, 12: 310-311. 10.1105/tpc.12.3.310.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Uyenoyama MK, Zhang Y, Newbigin E: On the origin of self-incompatibility haplotypes: Transition through self-compatible intermediates. Genetics. 2001, 157: 1805-1817.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bridgham JT, Carroll SM, Thornton JW: Evolution of hormone-receptor complexity by molecular exploitation. Science. 2006, 312: 97-101. 10.1126/science.1123348.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- De Nettancourt D: Incompatibility and incongruity in wild and cultivated plants. 2000, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 2Google Scholar
- Kachroo A, Schopfer CR, Nasrallah ME, Nasrallah JB: Allele-specific receptor-ligand interactions in Brassica self-incompatibility. Science. 2001, 293: 1824-1826. 10.1126/science.1062509.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Takayama S, Shimamoto H, Shiba H, Funato M, Che FS, Watanabe M, Iwano M, Isogai A: Direct ligand-receptor complex interaction controls Brassica self-incompatibility. Nature. 2001, 413: 535-538. 10.1038/35097104.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chookajorn T, Kachroo A, Ripoll DR, Clark AG, Nasrallah JB: Specificity determinants and diversification of the Brassica self-incompatibility pollen ligand. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA. 2003, 101: 911-917. 10.1073/pnas.2637116100.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sato Y, Okamoto S, Nishio T: Diversification and alteration of recognition specificity of the pollen ligand SP11 /SCR in self-incompatibility of Brassica and Raphanus. The Plant Cell. 2004, 16: 3230-3241. 10.1105/tpc.104.027029.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Matton DP, Maes O, Laublin G, Xike Q, Bertrand C, Morse D, Cappadocia M: Hypervariable domains of self-incompatibility RNases mediate allele-specific pollen recognition. The Plant Cell. 1997, 9: 1757-1766. 10.2307/3870522.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Verica JA, McCubbin AG, Kao TH: Are the hyper-variable regions of S RNases sufficient for allele-specific recognition of pollen?. The Plant Cell. 1998, 10: 314-316. 10.2307/3870590.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sato Y, Sato K, Nishio T: Interspecific pairs of class II S haplotypes having different recognition specificities between Brassica oleracea and Brassica rapa. Plant Cell Physiol. 2006, 47: 340-345. 10.1093/pcp/pci250.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nasrallah JB, Kao TH, Chen CH, Goldberg ML, Nasrallah ME: Amino-acid sequence of glycoproteins encoded by three alleles of the S locus of Brassica oleracea. Nature. 1987, 326: 617-619. 10.1038/326617a0.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kusaba M, Nishio T, Satta Y, Hinata K, Ockendon D: Striking sequence similarity in inter- and intra-specific comparisons of class I SLG alleles from Brassica oleracea and Brassica campestris: implications for the evolution and recognition mechanism. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA. 1997, 94: 7673-7678. 10.1073/pnas.94.14.7673.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sato K, Nishio T, Kimura R, Kusaba M, Suzuki T, Hatakeyama K, Ockendon DJ, Satta Y: Coevolution of the S-Locus Genes SRK, SLG and SP11/SCR in Brassica oleracea and B rapa. Genetics. 2002, 162: 931-940.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Okamoto S, Sato Y, Sakamoto K, Nishio T: Distribution of similar self-incompatibility (S) haplotypes in different genera, Raphanus and Brassica. Sex Plant Reprod. 2004, 17: 33-39. 10.1007/s00497-004-0211-2.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Schierup MH, Mable BK, Awadalla P, Charlesworth D: Identification and characterization of a polymorphic receptor kinase gene linked to the self-incompatibility locus of Arabidopsis lyrata. Genetics. 2001, 158: 387-399.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kusaba M, Matsushita M, Okazaki K, Satta Y, Nishio T: Sequence and structural diversity of the S locus genes from different lines with the same self-recognition specificities in Brassica oleracea. Genetics. 2000, 154: 413-420.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Miege C, Ruffio-Châble V, Schierup MH, Cabrillac D, Dumas C, Gaude T, Cock JM: Intrahaplotype polymorphism at the Brassica S-locus. Genetics. 2001, 159: 811-822.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kusaba M, Nishio T: Comparative analysis of S haplotypes with very similar SLG alleles in Brassica rapa and B. oleracea. Plant J. 1999, 17: 83-92. 10.1046/j.1365-313X.1999.00355.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bechsgaard JS, Castric V, Charlesworth D, Vekemans X, Schierup MH: The transition to self-compatibility in Arabidopsis thaliana and evolution within S-haplotypes over 10 Myr. Mol Biol Evol. 2006, 23: 1741-1750. 10.1093/molbev/msl042.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sawyer SL, Wu LI, Emerman M, Malik HS: Positive selection of primate TRIM5α identifies a criticalspecies-specific retroviral restriction domain. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA. 2005, 102: 2832-2837. 10.1073/pnas.0409853102.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wright S: The distribution of self-sterility alleles in populations. Genetics. 1939, 24: 538-552.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Takebayashi N, Brewer PB, Newbigin E, Uyenoyama MK: Patterns of variation within self-incompatibility loci. Mol Biol Evol. 2003, 20: 1778-1794. 10.1093/molbev/msg209.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sainudiin R, Wong WSW, Yogeeswaran K, Nasrallah JB, Yang Z, Nielsen R: Detecting site-specific physicochemical selective pressures: applications to the class-I HLA of the human major histocompatibility complex and the SRK of the plant sporophytic self-incompatibility system. J Mol Evol. 2005, 60: 315-326. 10.1007/s00239-004-0153-1.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Anisimova M, Bielawski JP, Yang Z: Accuracy and power of Bayes prediction of amino acid sites under positive selection. Mol Biol Evol. 2002, 19: 950-958.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Charlesworth D, Mable BK, Schierup MH, Bartolomé C, Awadalla P: Diversity and linkage of genes in the self-incompatibility gene family in Arabidopsis lyrata. Genetics. 2003, 164: 1519-1535.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bechsgaard J, Bataillon T, Schierup MH: Uneven segregation of sporophytic self-incompatibility alleles in Arabidopsis lyrata . J Evol Biol. 2004, 17: 554-561. 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2004.00699.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nishio T, Kusaba M: Sequence diversity of SLG and SRK in Brassica oleracea L. Annals of Botany. 2000, 85: 141-146. 10.1006/anbo.1999.1041.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Willems G, Godé C, Dräger DB, Courbot M, Verbruggen N, Saumitou-Laprade P: The genetic basis of zinc tolerance in the metallophyte Arabidopsis halleri ssp. halleri (Brassicaceae): an analysis of quantitative trait loci. Genetics. 2007,Google Scholar
- Kusaba M, Dwyer K, Hendershot J, Vrebalov J, Nasrallah JB, Nasrallah ME: Self-incompatibility in the genus Arabidopsis : characterization of the S-locus in the outcrossing A lyrata and its autogamous relative A thaliana. The Plant Cell. 2001, 13: 627-643. 10.2307/3871411.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Prigoda NL, Nassuth A, Mable BK: Phenotypic and genotypic expression of self-incompatibility haplotypes in Arabidopsis lyrata suggests unique origin of alleles in different dominance classes. Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22: 1609-1620. 10.1093/molbev/msi153.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Takahata N: A simple genealogical structure of strongly balanced allelic lines and trans-species evolution of polymorphism. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA. 1990, 87: 2419-2423. 10.1073/pnas.87.7.2419.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Charlesworth D, Bartolome C, Schierup MH, Mable BK: Haplotype structure of the stigmatic self-incompatibility gene in natural populations of Arabidopsis lyrata. Mol Biol Evol. 2003, 20: 1741-1753. 10.1093/molbev/msg170.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ramos-Onsins SE, Stranger BE, Mitchell-Olds T, Aguadé M: Multilocus analysis of variation and speciation in the closely related species Arabidopsis halleri and A lyrata. Genetics. 2004, 166: 373-388. 10.1534/genetics.166.1.373.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nunes MDS, Santos RAM, Ferreira SM, Vieira J, Vieira CP: Variability patterns and positively selected sites at the gametophytic self-incompatibility pollen SFB gene in a wild self-incompatible Prunus spinosa (Rosaceae) population. New Phytologist. 2006, 172: 577-587. 10.1111/j.1469-8137.2006.01838.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Savage AE, Miller JS: Gametophytic self-incompatibility in Lycium parishii (Solanaceae): allelic diversity, genealogical structure, and patterns of molecular evolution at the S-RNase locus. Heredity. 2006, 96: 434-444. 10.1038/sj.hdy.6800818.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Clark AG: Evolutionary inferences from molecular characterization of self-incompatiblity alleles. Mechanisms of molecular evolution. Edited by: Takahata N, Clark AG. 1993, Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates, 79-108.Google Scholar
- Anisimova M, Nielsen R, Yang Z: Effect of recombination on the accuracy of the likelihood method for detecting positive selection at amino acid sites. Genetics. 2003, 164: 1229-1236.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wilson DJ, McVean G: Estimating diversifying selection and functional constraint in the presence of recombination. Genetics. 2006, 172: 1411-1425. 10.1534/genetics.105.044917.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kawabe A, Hansson B, Forrest A, Hagenblad J, Charlesworth D: Comparative gene mapping in Arabidopsis lyrata chromosomes 6 and 7 and A thaliana chromosome IV : evolutionary history, rearrangements and local recombination rates. Genet Res Camb. 2006, 88 (1): 45-56.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kumar S, Tamura K, Nei M: MEGA3: Integrated software for molecular evolutionary genetics analysis and sequence alignment. Briefings in Bioinformatics. 2004, 5: 150-163. 10.1093/bib/5.2.150.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Charlesworth D, Awadalla P, Mable BK, Schierup MH: Population-level studies of multiallelic self-incompatibility loci, with particular reference to Brassicaceae. Annals of Botany. 2000, 85: 227-239. 10.1006/anbo.1999.1015.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Thompson JD, Gibson TJ, Plewniak F, Jeanmougin F, Higgins DG: The ClustalX windows interface: flexible strategies for multiple sequence alignment aided by quality analysis tools. Nucleic Acids Research. 1997, 24: 4876-4882. 10.1093/nar/25.24.4876.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Stein JC, Howlett B, Boyes DC, Nasrallah ME, Nasrallah JB: Molecular cloning of a putative receptor protein kinase gene encoded at the self-incompatibility locus of Brassica oleracea. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA. 1991, 88: 8816-8820. 10.1073/pnas.88.19.8816.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yamakawa S, Shiba H, Watanabe M, Shiozawa H, Takayama S, Hinata K, Isogai A, Suzuki A: The sequences of S-glycoproteins involved in self-incompatibility of Brassica campestris and their distribution among Brassicaceae. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem. 1994, 58: 921-925.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zhang M, Gaschen B, Blay W, Foley B, Haigwood N, Kuiken C, Korber B: Tracking global patterns of N-linked glycosylation site variation in highly variable viral glycoproteins: HIV, SIV, and HCV envelopes and influenza hemagglutinin. Glycobiology. 2004, 14: 1229-1246. 10.1093/glycob/cwh106.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z: PAML: a program package for phylogenetic analysis by maximum likelihood. Computer Applications in BioSciences. 1997, 13 (5): 555-556.Google Scholar
- Felsenstein J: PHYLIP (Phylogeny Inference Package) version 3.6. Distributed by the author. 2005, Department of Genome Sciences, University of Washington, SeattleGoogle Scholar
- Nielsen R, Yang Z: Likelihood models for detecting positively selected amino acid sites and applications to the HIV-1 envelope gene. Genetics. 1998, 148: 929-936.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wong WSW, Yang Z, Goldman N, Nielsen R: Accuracy and power of statistical methods for detecting adaptive evolution in protein coding sequences and for identifying positively selected sites. Genetics. 2004, 168: 1041-1051. 10.1534/genetics.104.031153.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Wong WSW, Nielsen R: Bayes empirical bayes inference of amino acid sites under positive selection. Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22: 1107-1118. 10.1093/molbev/msi097.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kosakovsky Pond SL, Frost SDW, Muse SV: HyPhy: hypothesis testing using phylogenies. Bioinformatics. 2005, 21: 676-679. 10.1093/bioinformatics/bti079.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Swanson WJ: Codon-substitution models to detect adaptive evolution that account for heterogeneous selective pressures among site classes. Mol Biol Evol. 2002, 19: 49-57.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kosakovsky Pond SL, Muse SV: Site-to-site variation of synonymous substitution rates. Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22: 2375-2385. 10.1093/molbev/msi232.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ronquist F, Huelsenbeck JP: MRBAYES 3: Bayesian phylogenetic inference under mixed models. Bioinformatics. 2003, 19: 1572-1574. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btg180.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.