- Research article
- Open Access
Adaptive evolution of the symbiotic gene NORK is not correlated with shifts of rhizobial specificity in the genus Medicago
© De Mita et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2007
- Received: 26 April 2007
- Accepted: 06 November 2007
- Published: 06 November 2007
The NODULATION RECEPTOR KINASE (NORK) gene encodes a Leucine-Rich Repeat (LRR)-containing receptor-like protein and controls the infection by symbiotic rhizobia and endomycorrhizal fungi in Legumes. The occurrence of numerous amino acid changes driven by directional selection has been reported in this gene, using a limited number of messenger RNA sequences, but the functional reason of these changes remains obscure. The Medicago genus, where changes in rhizobial associations have been previously examined, is a good model to test whether the evolution of NORK is influenced by rhizobial interactions.
We sequenced a region of 3610 nucleotides (encoding a 392 amino acid-long region of the NORK protein) in 32 Medicago species. We confirm that positive selection in NORK has occurred within the Medicago genus and find that the amino acid positions targeted by selection occur in sites outside of solvent-exposed regions in LRRs, and other sites in the N-terminal region of the protein. We tested if branches of the Medicago phylogeny where changes of rhizobial symbionts occurred displayed accelerated rates of amino acid substitutions. Only one branch out of five tested, leading to M. noeana, displays such a pattern. Among other branches, the most likely for having undergone positive selection is not associated with documented shift of rhizobial specificity.
Adaptive changes in the sequence of the NORK receptor have involved the LRRs, but targeted different sites than in most previous studies of LRR proteins evolution. The fact that positive selection in NORK tends not to be associated to changes in rhizobial specificity indicates that this gene was probably not involved in evolving rhizobial preferences. Other explanations (e.g. coevolutionary arms race) must be tested to explain the adaptive evolution of NORK.
- Candidate Site
- Root Hair Growth
- Rhizobial Symbiosis
- Vesicular Arbuscular Mycorrhizae
- Medicago Species
Many plants allow intracellular accommodation of symbiotic microorganisms in order to improve nutrient uptake. The most ubiquitous example is vesicular arbuscular mycorrhizae (VAM) which are specific organs contributed by plant roots and fungi . VAM are probably as old as the common ancestor of all land plants  and most of them are described as generalist (i.e. many distantly related fungi can associate with a given plant). In contrast, only plants of the Fabaceae family (legumes), plus the Ulmaceae Parasponia, harbor nitrogen-fixing bacteria in specific root organs (nodules). A polyphyletic group of symbiotic bacteria collectively named rhizobia are able to trigger nodule organogenesis . The legume-rhizobium symbiosis is characterized by host-symbiont specificity controlled by stringent partner recognition. As a result, only a limited range of bacteria can nodulate a given legume species. Despite their differences in levels of specificity, VAM and rhizobial symbioses exhibit the same identical host cellular responses at early stages of the interaction. It is possible that VAM have served as a pre-adaptation to the rhizobial symbiosis . The specificity in legume-rhizobium symbiosis is mediated by signaling molecules released by both partners, among which rhizobial Nod factors are thought to be the most important . Recently, VAM fungi have also been shown to release signaling molecules as well . There is mounting evidence that the same genes are activated during the establishment of both rhizobial and fungal symbioses .
The gene NORK (NODULATION RECEPTOR KINASE) of Medicago truncatula  controls a common signaling pathway required for some of the earliest stages of Nod factor signaling, but also mycorrhizal signaling. NORK encodes a transmembrane protein with structural analogy to receptor kinases involved in signaling or disease resistance. Its extracellular region contains a large N-terminal which has not yet been functionally characterized. The C-terminal region of the extracellular domain (closer to the transmembrane domain in the predicted primary structure) contains three Leucine-Rich Repeats (LRRs) which are motifs involved in ligand binding. LRRs appear in many proteins involved in disease resistance or cellular signaling. LRRs are expected to conform as aligned β sheets in which solvent-exposed (non-Leucine) residues control ligand specificity .
Current hypotheses regarding its functional role propose that NORK is involved in a complex Nod factor receptor  or that it plays an intermediary part and connects the activity of Nod factor (and mycorrhizal) receptors to subsequent steps . However, no functional experiments testing these hypotheses have been reported yet. We previously examined patterns of within- and between-species nucleotide variation in NORK and found footprints of positive selection in the phylogeny of six legume species from five different genera but no evidence of positive selection in the polymorphism of Medicago truncatula . The finding of positive selection was based on messenger RNA (mRNA) sequences spanning the entire coding region of the gene but available for only a few species. Signatures of positive selection were clearly located in the region encoding the LRRs. Even if NORK is a key component of the Nod factor signaling pathway, it is not obvious that the legume-rhizobium symbiosis is the only explanation for the selective pressures found in that gene. We aimed to investigate whether NORK evolution can be linked specifically to the evolution of rhizobial symbiosis, focusing on shifts in host specificity.
The Medicago genus is the only available fine-scale case study of the patterns of rhizobia specificity . Most Medicago species are associated to two sister species, Sinorhizobium medicae and S. meliloti. However, basal species are associated to more specific, Near-East strains (making the identification of the ancestral state impossible). Two non-basal Medicago species (M. noeana and M. rigiduloides) seem to have reverted to this preference for Near-East strains. Two sister species M. laciniata and M. sauvagei are associated to the specific group of S. meliloti bv. medicaginis , and M. monspeliaca is associated to another group. This pattern suggests several important transitions of symbiotic preference along the Medicago phylogeny.
Here we present a detailed analysis of the evolution of NORK using an intensive sampling of species from the genus Medicago and focusing on the LRR region. Species included in our sample were selected to encompass evolutionary transitions that occurred during the evolution of the genus Medicago. We examined a region of 3610 nucleotides coding for the extracellular domain of NORK. We sequenced 32 Medicago species and used 6 mRNA sequences from other genera. A widely used indicator of selective constraint is the ratio of non-synonymous to synonymous substitution rates . This parameter is referred to as ω and can be estimated from aligned coding sequence data using a maximum-likelihood method  which allows testing various hypotheses. The data exhibit strong evidence that NORK has undergone positive selection in the history of the Medicago genus. We present an estimation of the proportion of sites under selection and their position in the gene. We test whether branches of the Medicago phylogeny which are associated to changes in rhizobial preferences exhibit evidence of positive selection. We find that there is no obvious such influence whereas at least one branch associated to no known transition in symbiotic specificity has almost certainly undergone positive selection.
A region of 3610 nucleotides was sequenced in 32 Medicago species (pairwise identity: minimum 0.908, maximum 0.996, mean 0.942). Positions of exons were determined by homology with M. truncatula. A protein-coding region of 1178 nucleotides was extracted and aligned with mRNA sequences of 6 species from other genera (pairwise identity: minimum 0.811, maximum 0.996, mean 0.932). This alignment was translated in an alignment of 392 amino acids (pairwise identity: minimum 0.730, maximum 0.997, mean 0.900). The NORK protein has undergone a few insertion and deletion events. They are restricted to a short track of the extracellular domain (not in the LRRs). Within Medicago (and using mRNA sequences of Lotus and Sesbania as outgroups) we observe two short deletions (positions 200 and 221, numbered with respect to the M. truncatula protein sequence CAD10809) and one short insertion (two residues between 240 and 241). Outside Medicago there are only two additional short insertion/deletion events: a two-residue insertion at positions 214–215 common to all Medicago and a single amino acid insertion/deletion at position 373 (the only insertion occurring outside the 200–241 range). Hence NORK has undergone relatively few rearrangement events within the Hologalegina clade .
Significant excess of non-synonymous substitutions in NORK between Medicago species
Codon based tests of positive selection assuming site variation of ω
Positive selection model
Model name [35, 36]
Parameter p in Beta
Parameter q in Beta
Frequency of additional class
0.19 (i.e. 76 sites)
0.10 (i.e. 38 sites)
ω of additional class (ωs)
Number of free parameters
P < 10-12
Identification of candidate sites targeted by positive selection
The amount of data at each site of an alignment is considered to be insufficient to allow an independent estimation of ω for individual sites. The so-called Bayes empirical Bayes procedure  overcomes this problem by using the parameters of the M8 model as a prior distribution of ω. The Bayes empirical Bayes procedure allows estimating (i) the probability that a given site belongs to each ω category in the model and (ii) a per-site prediction of ω along with a confidence interval. Sites displaying a high probability (> 0.95) of belonging to the free ω category of model M8 (ω = 2.37) are candidate targets of positive selection. Our analysis suggests nine candidate sites with probability > 0.95: 214 (R), 228 (F), 275 (H), 284 (R), 421 (A), 444 (M), 445 (L), 466 (S) and 468 (W). Site numbering and amino acids given are these of M. truncatula (GenBank: CAD10809).
Positive selection did not occur preferentially in branches where shifts in rhizobial specificity took place
Tests of positive selection in specific branches
Branch with free ω
Test ω1 > 1
None (null model)
1 (M. monspeliaca)
2 (main group)
3 (M. laciniata, sauvagei)
4 (M. noeana)
P > 0.50
5 (M. rigidula)
6 (group a posteriori)
P > 0.10
Most branches where changes in rhizobial specificity occurred don't display any increase in the rate of non-synonymous substitutions. The only one that shows such increase is the branch leading to M. noeana (branch 4). Conversely, at least one other branch (branch 6) displays an even larger increase (ω1 = 1.90 for branch 6 to be compared to ω1 = 1.13 for M. noeana). Branch 6 is not associated with the pattern of rhizobial specificity in extant species. These results indicate that positive selection in NORK is very unlikely to be connected to changes in rhizobial specificity in the Medicago genus.
We have examined the pattern of nucleotide divergence in the coding sequence of NORK between species of the genus Medicago. We found signatures of positive selection suggesting episodes of molecular adaptation of NORK in the history of this genus, but with no evidence of correlation with shifts of rhizobial specificity. Below we first examine one methodological issue that might put into question the finding of positive selection, and then discuss its possible interpretations.
Are our results robust to tree misspecification?
We used a phylogeny of Medicago species previously published, and determined using a different locus than the one used for testing positive selection. The phylogeny built from NORK sequences (not shown) is indeed severely conflicting with the one we used. Using a tree inconsistent with the data may restrain the validity of the test for positive selection . To confirm our finding of positive selection, we evaluated the robustness of our results to several tree topologies (including the phylogeny reconstructed with amino acid sequences, which by definition tends to minimize the number of non-synonymous changes). Overall we find that the evidence for positive selection is not as strong but still highly significant [see Additional file 1]. The estimated number of candidate sites tends to drop, but the estimated ωs is still close to 2 and the positions of candidate sites are qualitatively conserved (at last five of the nine candidate sites are conserved, two in the N-terminal region and one in each LRR).
Positions of candidate sites in the protein
No candidate site has been identified in the solvent-exposed β sheets of the LRRs. This result contrasts with many previous studies of LRR-containing resistance gene families where positive selection mostly targeted these solvent-exposed sites (e. g. [24, 25]). However, Caicedo and Shaal  noted that a majority of sites under positive selection fell outside of solvent-exposed regions in a study of positive selection in a LRR resistance gene of a Solanum,. Therefore the operating mode of positive selection in the evolution of LRRs might vary between genes, presumably resulting from different spatial interactions between LRR proteins and their ligand or ligands.
Four of the nine candidate sites are in the N-terminal region of NORK which consists of a currently undetermined structural domain. Resistance proteins containing LRRs often include TIR and NBS domains at a similar position. Their role in determining ligand specificity  as well as the presence of positively selected sites in these domains [24, 25] have been demonstrated. It is therefore possible that the unknown N-terminal domain of NORK has a role in controlling interactions with other proteins. The position of sites where positive selection occurred might be relevant for the inference of the spatial structure of NORK.
NORK does not seem to control partner choice between Sinorhizobium strains in Medicago
The occurrence of positive selection in NORK being demonstrated, we sought for a hypothesis to explain it. The product of this gene is involved in both rhizobial and endomycorrhizal symbioses . Furthermore, NORK may have additional roles. It is possible that it intervenes also in the control of root hair growth . In this context it is difficult to infer which selective constraints have driven the numerous amino acid substitutions we detected. A phylogeny of the genus Medicago was previously reconstructed using internal and external spacers of the nuclear ribosomal DNA . This phylogeny allowed to identify five putative events of changes in rhizobial specificity within the genus Medicago .
Here we tested whether amino acid substitutions of NORK have played a role in these changes of specificity, by testing whether more substitutions occurred in branches where these changes occurred. The branches corresponding to the association with a large range of Sinorhizobium meliloti and medicae strains (branch 2), and to specializations to limited ranges of strains (branches 1 and 3) show very small and non-significant variations of ω. M. noeana and M. rigiduloides are closely related (but not sister) species which seem to have both reverted to an ancestral state. However their branches exhibit contrasted pattern of non-synonymous and synonymous evolution. The branch 4 (leading to M. noeana) has an ω of 1.13 significantly larger than in the rest of the tree but not significantly larger than one. The branch 5 (leading to M. rigiduloides) has a significantly lower, virtually null ω. The result for branch 4 is ambiguous because it is not possible to positively discriminate between positive selection and relaxed purifying constraints, since ω is not significantly greater than one. Furthermore, the statistical properties of branch-specific ω, such as sampling errors, as well as their behavior with varying branch length, have been poorly described. Even if positive selection indeed occurred in the branch leading to M. noeana, it must have occurred also in other branches not connected to changes in rhizobial specificity. First, because our initial study having detected positive selection did not use this species . Second, because the branch 6 is an even more likely candidate than branch 4 (albeit not significant either). Therefore it is obvious from the results described in Table 2 that there is no general increase in ω in branches associated to changes in rhizobial specificity. Evolving preferences between several groups of Sinorhizobium are not a good candidate for explaining the high rates of amino acid replacements in NORK in Medicago.
The exact role of NORK in Nod factor signaling is currently unclear [7, 10, 11], as well as the way it is involved in its other putative functions (mycorrhizal signaling and control of root hair growth). It is not excluded that the NORK protein interacts directly with Nod factors, putative mycorrhizal signaling molecules, or any kind of ligand. It is therefore difficult to formulate any precise hypothesis for explaining positive selection in NORK. Below we only enumerate a few general hypotheses.
The hypothesis tested in this article is that NORK evolution has been driven by changes of rhizobial specificity (i.e. acquisition of a new partner, or co-speciation of partners). This form of evolution can be detected because former states are conserved in unchanged descendants of ancestral species. Another possibility is a coevolutionary arms race between Medicago and Sinorhizobium, a process where both partners evolve in response to each other's innovations . This may not be easily detectable because the changes don't occur at speciations and the ancestral states do not persist. This suggestion assumes that NORK interacts directly with a rhizobial product, and that the symbiosis generates antagonist-like pressures of selection (through conflicts of interest or episodic parasitism).
As a putative receptor for vesicular arbuscular endomycorrhizae (VAM) signaling, NORK might as well be under selective pressures caused by the interaction with mycorrhizal fungi. At first glance, VAM are not expected to be able to require molecular adaptation because of a typical absence of specificity (any change would disrupt the interaction). However hidden specificity caused by specific life history , and also possible conflicts of interest in VAM, can be taken on consideration as potential sources of selective pressure.
Genes can be recruited as resistance genes while having an initial different function (e.g. ). As a regulator of common plant symbioses, NORK may be used as an entry route for parasites using nodule/VAM development pathway to infect root tissues. In that case, this gene is likely to behave as a resistance gene. There is some clue that the Lotus japonicus homologue of NORK is required for parasitic infection by root parasites  but this result has not been confirmed in Medicago.
Eventually, functional studies of protein interactions in which NORKis involved will help identifying the putative selective pressures it undergoes and consequently narrow down these hypotheses.
We confirm the occurrence of positive selection in the symbiotic gene NORK. We show that positive selection was probably not induced by changes in rhizobial specificity during the evolution of the Medicago genus. Positions of amino acid sites exhibiting an excess of substitutions indicate that selection did not target solvent-exposed residues of the LRRs, but other sites, inside and outside the LRRs. These results confirm that NORK has undergone crucial selective pressures at least in the Medicago genus, but raise questions relative to their origin.
Taxa included in the analysis
We used the mRNA sequences of NORK orthologs in six non-Medicago legume species available in the GenBank database: Astragalus sinicus, Lotus japonicus (SYMRK), Melilotus alba, Pisum sativum, Sesbania rotata and Vicia hirsuta (AY946203, AJ430101, AJ498991, AJ438375, AY751547 and AJ428990, respectively). We selected 32 Medicago species for sequencing. Some of them can be considered as models: M. sativa and its relatives M. coerulea and M. falcata are important crops. M. truncatula is a model in several respects. M. noeana, M. laciniata and M. monspeliaca possess specific rhizobial symbionts that are not associated with other species. We sampled species to represent different symbiotic groups defined on the basis of rhizobial specificity documented in the genus Medicago . The material used in this study is listed in Additional file 2, along with the accession numbers of sequences that have been produced.
One or two genotypes were selected for each Medicago species [see Additional file 1]. Total DNA was extracted from 100 mg of frozen leaves according to DNeasy Plant Mini Kit (Qiagen) with the following modification: 1% of Polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP 40,000) was added to buffer AP1. A region of NORK located in the extracellular domain of the protein was amplified and sequenced. Sequence and genic localization of primers are displayed in Additional file 3. For all species, amplification and sequencing were performed as previously reported . For species exhibiting a signal of sequence heterozygosity, sequence data were obtained after cloning. In this case, PCR amplifications were performed using a proofreading DNA polymerase (Expand High Fidelity PCR System, Roche). The PCR products were cloned using the pGEMT-easy cloning kit (Promega) according to the manufacturer protocol. One positive clone per individual was sequenced in both directions with universal SP6 and T7 primers using a fluorescent sequencing system (BigDye Terminator version 3.1 Cycle Sequencing Kit, Applera) and analyzed on an ABI PRISM 3100 semi automated sequencer (Applera). Sequences were assembled and aligned using programs of the Staden package release 1.6.0 beta 4 .
Tests of positive selection
Coding sequences were analyzed with the codeml software from the PAML package version 3.15  under a family of codon substitution models allowing for variation in the non-synonymous to synonymous rate ratio (ω) among sites  or among branches . We used subsequent modifications of some of these models to ensure adequate hypothesis testing [35, 36]. We performed three different tests. The first one compares two models allowing for variation of ω between sites but not between branches (M8A and M8) and allows for testing for the presence of sites under positive selection. The second one compares a fixed-ω (M1ω) model to a two-ω (M2ω) model where ω is allowed to vary in a given pre-defined branch. We used branches 1–5 in Figure 1A which correspond to putative ancestral changes in rhizobial specificity, and branch 6 which was noticed for having an unexpected length. This test only allows verifying that the two ω are different. The third test compared any two-ω model (where ω varies in one given branch) to a version where ω in the tested branch is constrained to one (M2ω A). This test allowed testing whether ω in branches 4 and 6 was significantly greater than one. The statistical tests of M8 vs. M8A, M2ω vs. M1ω and M2ω vs. M1ω A were all performed with likelihood ratio tests with one degree of freedom (each couple of models differs by one free parameter).
Pascal Joly, Magalie Delalande and Denis Tauzin grew samples in greenhouse. We thank Jean-Marie Prosperi for resolving problems of taxonomy. Christine Tollon participated to the molecular analysis. Gabriella Endre provided DNA material of M. sativa hybrid MH2 homozygote in the NORK region. Thanks to Nathalie Chantret, Gilles Béna and Marc-André Selosse for helpful discussion and to two anonymous reviewers for comments on a previous version of this manuscript.
- Smith SE, Read DJ: Mycorrhizal symbiosis. 1997, London, UK: Academic Press, 2Google Scholar
- Remy W, Taylor TN, Hass H, Kerp H: Four hundred-million-year-old vesicular arbuscular mycorrhizae. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1994, 91: 11841-11843. 10.1073/pnas.91.25.11841.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chen W-M, Moulin L, Bontemps C, Gillis M, Vandamme P, Béna G, Boivin-Masson C: Legume symbiotic nitrogen fixation by β-proteobacteria is widespread in nature. J Bact. 2004, 185: 7266-7272. 10.1128/JB.185.24.7266-7272.2003.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kistner C, Parniske M: Evolution of signal transduction in intracellular symbiosis. Trends Plant Sci. 2002, 7: 511-518. 10.1016/S1360-1385(02)02356-7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Perret X, Staehelin C, Broughton WJ: Molecular basis of symbiotic promiscuity. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev. 2000, 64: 180-201. 10.1128/MMBR.64.1.180-201.2000.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kosuta S, Chabaud M, Lougnon G, Gough C, Dénarié J, Barker DG, Bécard G: A diffusible factor from arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi induces symbiosis-specific MtENOD11 expression in roots of Medicago truncatula. Plant Physiol. 2003, 131: 952-962. 10.1104/pp.011882.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Geurts R, Fedorova E, Bisseling T: Nod factor signaling genes and their function in the early stages of Rhizobium infection . Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2005, 8: 346-352. 10.1016/j.pbi.2005.05.013.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Endre G, Kereszt A, Kevei Z, Mihacea S, Kalò P, Kiss GB: A receptor kinase gene regulating symbiotic nodule development. Nature. 2002, 417: 962-966. 10.1038/nature00842.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jones DA, Jones JDG: The role of Leucine-Rich Repeat proteins in plant defences. Adv Bot Res Adv Plant Pathol. 1997, 24: 89-167.Google Scholar
- Hogg BV, Cullimore JV, Ranjeva R, Bono JJ: The DMI1 and DMI2 early symbiotic genes of Medicago truncatula are required for a high-affinity nodulation factor-binding site associated to a particulate fraction of roots. Plant Physiol. 2006, 140: 365-373. 10.1104/pp.105.068981.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Riely BK, Ané J-M, Penmetsa RV, Cook DR: Genetic and genomic analysis in model legumes bring Nod-factor signaling to center stage. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2004, 7: 408-413. 10.1016/j.pbi.2004.04.005.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- De Mita S, Santoni S, Hochu I, Ronfort J, Bataillon T: Molecular evolution and positive selection of the symbiotic gene NORK in Medicago truncatula. J Mol Evol. 2006, 62: 234-244. 10.1007/s00239-004-0367-2.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Béna G, Lyet A, Huguet T, Olivieri I: Medicago – Sinorhizobium symbiotic specificity evolution and the geographic expansion of Medicago. J Evol Biol. 2005, 18: 1547-1558.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Villegas MD, Rome S, Maure L, Domergue O, Gardan L, Bailly X, Cleyet-Marel JC, Brunel B: Nitrogen-fixing sinorhizobia with Medicago laciniata constitute a novel biovar (bv. medicaginis) of S. meliloti. Syst App Microbiol. 2006, 29: 526-538. 10.1016/j.syapm.2005.12.008.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Goldman N, Yang Z: A codon-based model of nucleotide substitution for protein-coding DNA sequences. Mol Biol Evol. 1994, 11: 725-736.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Bielawski JP: Statistical methods for detecting molecular adaptation. Trends Ecol Evol. 2000, 15: 496-503. 10.1016/S0169-5347(00)01994-7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lewis GP, Schrire BD, Mackinder BA, Lock M, (eds.): Legumes of the world. 2005, Kew, UK: Royal Botanic GardensGoogle Scholar
- Béna G: Molecular phylogeny supports the morphologically based taxonomic transfer of the "medicagoid" Trigonella species into the genus Medicago L. Plant Syst Evol. 2001, 229: 217-236. 10.1007/s006060170012.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Nielsen R, Goldman N, Pedersen A-MK: Codon-substitution models for heterogeneous selection pressure at amino acid sites. Genetics. 2000, 155: 431-449.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Wong WSW, Nielsen R: Bayes empirical Bayes inference of amino acid sites under positive selection. Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22: 1107-1118. 10.1093/molbev/msi097.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kobe B, Deisenhofer J: Crystal-structure of Porcine Ribonuclease Inhibitor, a protein with Leucine-Rich Repeats. Nature. 1993, 366: 751-756. 10.1038/366751a0.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z: Likelihood ratio tests for detecting positive selection and application to primate lysozyme evolution. Mol Biol Evol. 1998, 15: 568-573.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Anisimova M, Nielsen R, Yang Z: Effect of recombination on the accuraty of the likelihood method for detecting positive selection at amino acid sites. Genetics. 2003, 164: 1229-1236.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mondragon-Palomino M, Gaut BS: Gene conversion and the evolution of three Leucine-Rich-Repeat gene families in Arabidopsis thaliana . Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22: 2444-2456. 10.1093/molbev/msi241.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sun XL, Cao YL, Wang SP: Point mutations with positive selection were a major force during the evolution of a receptor-kinase resistance gene family of rice. Plant Physiology. 2006, 140: 998-1008. 10.1104/pp.105.073080.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Caicedo AL, Schaal BA: Heterogeneous evolutionary processes affect R gene diversity in natural populations of Solanum pimpinellifolium . Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2004, 101: 17444-17449. 10.1073/pnas.0407899101.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Luck JE, Lawrence GJ, Dodds PN, Shepherd KW, Ellis JG: Regions outside of the Leucine-Rich Repeats of flax rust resistance proteins play a role in specificity determination. Plant Cell. 2000, 12: 1367-1377. 10.1105/tpc.12.8.1367.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Esseling JJ, Lhuissier FGP, Emons AMC: A nonsymbiotic root hair tip growth phenotype in NORK -mutated legumes: implications for nodulation factor-induced signaling and formation of a multifaceted root hair pocket for bacteria. Plant Cell. 2004, 16: 933-944. 10.1105/tpc.019653.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Thompson JN: Rapid evolution as an ecological process. Trends Ecol Evol. 1998, 13: 329-332. 10.1016/S0169-5347(98)01378-0.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Selosse M-A, Richard F, He X, Simard SW: Mycorrhizal networks: des liaisons dangereuses?. Trends Ecol Evol. 2006, 21: 621-628. 10.1016/j.tree.2006.07.003.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ruffel S, Dussault M-H, Palloix B, Bendahmane A, Robaglia C, Caranta C: A natural recessive resistance gene against potato virus Y in pepper corresponds to the eukaryotic initiation factor 4E (eIF4E). Plant J. 2002, 32: 1067-1075. 10.1046/j.1365-313X.2002.01499.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Weerasinghe RR, Bird DM, Allen NS: Root-knot nematodes and bacterial Nod factors elicit common signal transduction events in Lotus japonicus . Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2005, 102: 3147-3152. 10.1073/pnas.0407926102.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Staden R: The Staden sequence analysis package. Mol Biotechnol. 1996, 5: 233-241.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z: PAML : a program package for phylogenetic analysis by maximum likelihood. Comput Appl Biosci. 1997, 13: 555-556.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Swanson WJ, Nielsen R, Yang Q: Pervasive adaptive evolution in mammalian fertilization proteins. Mol Biol Evol. 2003, 20: 18-20.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wong WSW, Yang Z, Goldman N, Nielsen R: Accuracy and power of statistical methods for detecting adaptive evolution in protein coding sequences and for identifying positively selected sites. Genetics. 2004, 168: 1041-1051. 10.1534/genetics.104.031153.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.