Skip to main content

Table 1 Predicted and observed Rhynchosporium commune diversity estimates under the contrasting host diversities and pathogen census population size

From: Weeds, as ancillary hosts, pose disproportionate risk for virulent pathogen transfer to crops

 

Barley

Barley grass

 

Large pathogen pop size

Genetically uniform host

 

Small pathogen population size

Genetically diverse host

 

R. commune diversity

Predicted

Predicted

Observed

Predicted

Predicted

Observed

Neutral genetic diversity:

      

 No. of SSR alleles

Many

Few

Many

Few

Many

Few

  Ne

Large

Small

Large

Small

Large

Small

 No. of MLGs

Many

Few

Many

Few

Many

Few

 Mode of reproduction/linkage disequilibrium

-

More asexual/high linkage disequilibrium

More sexual/lower linkage disequilibrium

-

More sexual/low linkage disequilibrium

More asexual/higher linkage disequilibrium

 Migration

More from barley to barley grass

More from barley grass to barley

More from barley grass to barley

More from barley to barley grass

More from barley grass to barley

More from barley grass to barley

Diversity under selection:

      

 No. of effector alleles

-

Few

Few

-

Many

Many

 No. of pathotypes

-

Few

Few

-

Many

Many

 Aggressiveness

-

Less

Less

-

More

More

  1. Host dynamics (taken as a given based on literature) for barley is a large acreage/population size with small N e (few cultivars used), inbred monocultures, assumed few resistance genes/alleles and higher disease (R. commune) incidence (large pathogen census population size). Barley grass is a weedy annual which may have a smaller population size than barley (on average less plants), is genetically diverse and thus has a large Ne, outcrossing, assumed to have many resistance genes/alleles and has lower disease (R. commune) incidence (small pathogen census population size). Observed pathogen genetic diversity and effective population sizes are as observed at neutral loci (SSRs) and traits that may be under selection (effector locus Nip1, pathogenicity). Predictions and observations in bold indicate when results confirmed predictions