Skip to main content

Table 1 ANOVA results for variation in life history and physiological traits in Bicyclus anynana

From: Effects of adult temperature on gene expression in a butterfly: identifying pathways associated with thermal acclimation

Trait

Source

MS

DF

F

P

Adult mass

Temperature

<  0.001

1

0.6

0.439

 

Food

<  0.001

1

2.1

0.144

Sex

0.166

1

389.4

<  0.001

Temp. * Sex

0.002

1

4.2

0.040

Family (Random)

0.001

9

1.6

0.104

Error

<  0.001

431

  

Thorax mass

Temperature

<  0.001

1

6.4

0.012

 

Food

<  0.001

1

0.4

0.536

Sex

0.002

1

420.3

<  0.001

Family (Random)

<  0.001

9

10.9

<  0.001

Error

<  0.001

432

  

Abdomen mass

Temperature

0.001

1

6.9

0.009

 

Food

<  0.001

1

1.8

0.177

Sex

0.125

1

820.6

<  0.001

Temp. * Sex

0.002

1

11.0

0.001

Family (Random)

<  0.001

9

1.9

0.046

Error

<  0.001

335

  

Thorax /Abdomen

Temperature

0.30

1

6.7

0.010

 

Food

0.21

1

4.7

0.031

Sex

40.27

1

894.8

<  0.001

Family (Random)

0.05

9

1.2

0.309

Error

0.05

336

  

Fat content

Temperature

1201

1

21.6

<  0.001

 

Food

203

1

3.7

0.057

Sex

22,346

1

402.3

<  0.001

Temp. * Sex

1267

1

22.8

<  0.001

Family (Random)

193

9

3.5

<  0.001

Error

56

329

  

Lysozyme

Temperature

0.17

1

10.1

0.002

 

Food

0.20

1

11.9

0.001

Sex

1.27

1

77.6

<  0.001

Family (Random)

0.03

9

1.7

0.082

Error

0.02

417

  

ADH

Temperature

0.0002

1

2.6

0.106

 

Food

<  0.0001

1

<  0.1

0.885

Sex

0.0011

1

18.5

<  0.001

Family (Random)

0.0002

9

2.8

0.004

Error

0.0001

432

  

Protein

Temperature

0.0005

1

0.7

0.411

 

Food

<  0.0001

1

0.1

0.823

Sex

0.0001

1

0.2

0.687

Family (Random)

0.0005

9

0.7

0.723

Error

0.0007

423

  
  1. Shown are the effects of adult temperature, adult feeding treatment, sex (fixed factors), and family (random factor). Minimum adequate models were constructed by sequentially removing non-significant interaction terms. Significant P-values are given in bold