Skip to main content

Table 2 Ranking and statistical analyses of reference genes in oral and pharyngeal jaws across all of the haplochromine species from three East African lakes

From: Divergence in larval jaw gene expression reflects differential trophic adaptation in haplochromine cichlids prior to foraging

 

Oral jaw

Pharyngeal jaw

BestKeeper

geNorm

NormFinder

BestKeeper

geNorm

NormFinder

Ranks

SD

Ranks

M

Ranks

SV

Ranks

SD

Ranks

M

Ranks

SV

1

rpl18

0.581

ssrp1

0.605

rpl18

0.272

rpl18

0.654

abcf1

0.619

rpl18

0.321

2

tmem59

0.639

rpl18

0.615

ube2l3

0.324

tmem59

0.813

rpl18

0.631

ube2l3

0.322

3

pdia6

0.640

abcf1

0.632

abcf1

0.376

actb1

0.984

ube2l3

0.633

ssrp1

0.331

4

ube2l3

0.649

pdia6

0.678

pdia6

0.398

twf1

1.016

actb1

0.672

actb1

0.412

5

actb1

0.663

twf1

0.683

twf1

0.424

rps18

1.026

pdia6

0.710

pdia6

0.442

6

twf1

0.688

rps18

0.687

actb1

0.448

pdia6

1.101

rps18

0.717

abce1

0.472

7

ssrp1

0.695

actb1

0.691

rps18

0.467

ssrp1

1.106

twf1

0.755

twf1

0.477

8

rps18

0.700

abce1

0.767

ssrp1

0.478

abcf1

1.106

ssrp1

0.764

abcf1

0.480

9

abcf1

0.717

ube2l3

0.773

abce1

0.513

ube2l3

1.150

abce1

0.769

rps18

0.517

10

abce1

0.720

tmem59

0.806

tmem59

0.587

abce1

1.151

tmem59

0.785

tmem59

0.577

11

tbp

1.031

tbp

0.900

tbp

0.639

tbp

1.328

tbp

0.896

tbp

0.665

12

elf1a

1.717

elf1a

1.579

elf1a

1.324

elf1a

2.162

elf1a

1.558

elf1a

1.257

  1. SD indicates a ranking calculation based on standard deviation generated by BestKeeper, whereas SV, stability value, and M, mean expression stability value, are calculated by geNorm and NormFinder, respectively. In all of the ranking methods lower values represent more stably expressed reference genes