The tendency to recreate ancestral CG dinucleotides in the human genome
© Li and Chen; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
Received: 1 July 2010
Accepted: 5 January 2011
Published: 5 January 2011
Skip to main content
© Li and Chen; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
Received: 1 July 2010
Accepted: 5 January 2011
Published: 5 January 2011
The CG dinucleotides are known to be deficient in the human genome, due to a high mutation rate from 5-methylated CG to TG and its complementary pair CA. Meanwhile, many cellular functions rely on these CG dinucleotides, such as gene expression controlled by cytosine methylation status. Thus, CG dinucleotides that provide essential functional substrates should be retained in genomes. How these two conflicting processes regarding the fate of CG dinucleotides - i.e., high mutation rate destroying CG dinucleotides, vs. functional processes that require their preservation remains an unsolved question.
By analyzing the mutation and frequency spectrum of newly derived alleles in the human genome, a tendency towards generating more CGs was observed, which was mainly contributed by an excess number of mutations from CA/TG to CG. Simultaneously, we found a fixation preference for CGs derived from TG/CA rather than CGs generated by other dinucleotides. These tendencies were observed both in intergenic and genic regions. An analysis of Integrated Extended Haplotype Homozygosity provided no evidence of selection for newly derived CGs.
Ancestral CG dinucleotides that were subsequently lost by mutation tend to be recreated in the human genome, as indicated by a biased mutation and fixation pattern favoring new CGs that derived from TG/CA.
DNA methylation is central to important biological processes, including X chromosome inactivation, genetic imprinting , gene-expression regulation [3–5], and the defense mechanisms against parasitic DNA and transposons [6, 7]. DNA methylation also plays an important role in pathological processes such as cancer , is closely related with histone modification and RNA-associated silencing , and may be involved in genomic instability .
DNA methylation in mammals is carried out by three methyltransferases (DNMT1, DNMT3A, DNMT3B) that target the cytosine in CG dinucleotides. A stochastic model for the maintenance of methylation during DNA replication has been proposed that allows accurate epigenetic inheritance[9, 11]. However, CG dinucleotides also experience a high mutation rate from cytosine to thymine through the deamination of 5-methylcytosine and a less-than-perfect repair mechanism for resulting G/T mismatches [12–14], which calls into question the stability of methylation of CG dinucleotides as an important epigenetic marker.
In the human genome, the number of CG dinucleotides is ~25% of that expected given observed base frequencies, which is due to a high mutation rate from 5-methylated CG to TG and its complementary pair CA. 15% of all CGs are clustered in so called "CpG islands", which are often located at the 5' end of genes and overlap with the promoter region, especially in housekeeping genes . Their methylation status is highly associated with gene expression , but despite this apparent functional constraint, loss of CpG islands has been observed as a common event in mammalian genomes [15, 17, 18].
Moreover, multiple pathways exist that preserve CG dinucleotides in the genome, including a lack of methylation of CGs in CpG islands and a strong correction bias towards C/G following T/G mismatches [14, 19, 20]. Two enzymes (TDG and MBD4) have been found to selectively remove the thymine from a T:G mismatch in the context of CpG dinucleotides [21, 22].
In our previous study , we observed a strong fixation bias in favor of derived C/G alleles at CG-related sites (dinucleotides that differ by one-step mutation from CG: CT, CA, CC, AG, TG, GG) compared with C/G alleles at CG-free sites (positions not preceded by C or followed by G). TG and CA, which are predominant at CG-related sites, were suspected to contribute this bias. Since a large fraction of TG/CA sites are originally derived from deamination of of methylated CGs , we hypothesize that recreating ancestral CGs may be the driving force behind this bias. Data released by the HapMap project and various genome projects afford us the opportunity to test this hypothesis.
By analyzing the mutation and frequency spectrum of different derived alleles, while taking the sequence context into account, a significant mutation and fixation preference towards transition-generated CGs (CG derived from CA or TG) was observed, while no such preference was observed for transversion-generated CGs (CG derived from CC, GG, CT, AG). This mutation and fixation preference enables the recreation of ancestral CG dinucleotides lost via hypermutation to CA/TG.
Human SNP data were retrieved from dbSNP (ftp://ftp.ncbi.nih.gov/snp/, Build 124), and curated by the method described elsewhere. Briefly, the following SNPs were selected: nonindel, biallelic, uniquely mapped to nonrepetitive sequences, validated, and with at least 100 nucleotides (nt) of flanking sequence available both upstream and downstream from the SNP.
Sequences and reads for multiple species were retrieved from the NCBI Nucleotide Databasehttp://www.ncbi.nih.gov/sites/entrez?db=nuccore and Traces Databasehttp://www.ncbi.nih.gov/Traces. Finally, the chimpanzee(Pan troglodytes, whole genome, 2.82G), gorilla(Gorilla, 9.54G, unassembled), orangutan (Pongo, 18.37G, unassembled), and Gibbon(Nomascus, 18.64G, unassembled) genome sequences were used as outgroups to infer the ancestral allele for the human SNP.
The allele frequencies at each SNP site were estimated from flat files downloaded from the International HapMap Project (http://hapmap.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/downloads/frequencies/, Build 23). The derived-allele frequency (DAF) for each SNP was estimated in three populations (unrelated individuals only): Yoruba(YRI), Utah residents with ancestry from northern and western Europe(CEU), Japanese and Chinese(ASN); only those SNPs successfully genotyped in all chromosomes (120, 120, 180 respectively) were kept for further analysis.
Inferring ancestral states using parsimony may be unreliable if the mutation or substitution rate is high. In mammalian genomes, CG dinucleotides have a very high mutation rate ; therefore, two methods were applied to ensure accurate inference of the ancestral state.
First, MegaBLAST was used to map the human SNPs and their flanking sequences(100 bp on each side) to the four outgroup sequences (chimpanzee, gorilla, orangutan, gibbon). We inferred the ancestral allele only when the chimpanzee, gorilla, orangutan and gibbon alleles were identical and matched one of the human SNP alleles. A PERL script was written to retrieve the human SNPs and their corresponding outgroup alleles from the MegaBLAST result.
Second, we also downloaded a dataset of 14.3 Mb of well curated human/chimpanzee/baboon DNA alignments (http://pbil.univ-lyon1.fr/datasets/MeunierDuret2004/data) and the corresponding human/rhesus sequences from http://genome.ucsc.edu. Blast was used to construct new alignments, and the final alignment length was shortened to 9.4 Mb. Human SNPs that map to the aligned chimp/baboon/rhesus sequences were retrieved and the ancestral state inferred as described above. Given the branch lengths estimated by Steiper and Young  for the primate phylogeny, reliable inference of the ancestral state can be obtained using these three outgroups even at CG related positions (Additional file 1).
For CpG islands, a single outgroup (chimpanzee) was used to infer the mutation direction to maximize the sample size, and the frequency spectrum was then corrected by Hernadez et al.'s method (Additional file 2) .
We identified 37,503 CpG islands in the human genome using the CGi130 program developed by Takai and Jones (http://cpgislands.usc.edu/)[31, 32]. The following search criteria, considered stringent according to the authors, were used: i) GC content ≥ 55%, ii) ObsCG/ExpCG ≥ 0.65, and iii) length ≥ 500 bp.
The gene annotation for each SNP in our study was retrieved from the ENSEMBL database (ftp://ftp.ensembl.org/pub/, version 45), and SNPs were classified as intergenic, intronic, coding, 5'UTR, 3'UTR, 5'upstream, or 3'downstream. Any SNP classified into more than one category was removed from the analysis. This left us with 915243 intergenic, 634809 intronic, 18333 coding, 2055 5'UTR, 11329 3'UTR, 38398 5'upstream and 40749 3'downstream SNPs.
A Long-Rang Haplotype test was utilized to detect recent positive selection. Specifically, the Integrated Haplotype Score (iHS) was calculated for each SNP, as described elsewhere. We used the suggested cut-off value, namely an extreme positive (iHS > 2) or negative (iHS < -2) iHS score (indicating a longer haplotype associated with the ancestral or the derived allele, respectively), as an indication of recent positive selection.
The locations of recombination hotspots and coldspots were obtained from a fine-scale genetic map estimated from patterns of genetic variation, which provides a kilobase-scale resolution of recombination rates [34, 35].
Following our previous observation of a strong fixation bias in favor of derived C/G alleles at CG-related sites, we re-examined the mutation and fixation pattern of CG dinucleotides on a genome-wide scale, while taking the sequence context into consideration. The CGs generated by a single mutation from other dinucleotides were classified into transition-generated CGs (Tsg, CG derived from CA/TG) and transversion-generated CGs (Tvg, CG derived from CC/CT/AG/GG). Correspondingly, the dinucleotides derived by mutations from CG are divided into transition-damaged CGs (Tsd, CA/TG derived from CG) and transversion-damaged CGs (Tvd, CC/CT/AG/GG derived from CG). For comparison, the same mutations located in other sequence contexts (not preceded by C or followed by G) were used as the control data for each of these mutation types. Analyses were also done separately for CpG islands and non-CpG islands, since they have very different mutation patterns and nucleotide composition.
Number of SNPs and average derived-allele frequency (DAF) for different mutation types in different annotation categories
Non-CpG island region
CpG island region
In the CpG island region, a different pattern was found: 559 CGs are generated by mutations from other dinucleotides while 881 CGs are destroyed by mutations; there is thus a trend toward decreasing the number of CGs. The trend is in accordance with that shown by the control data for CpG island regions (1003 Cs/Gs generated vs. 1748 Cs/Gs destroyed, P = 0.139, Fisher Exact test), but differs significantly from that in the non-CpG island region (26391 CGs generated vs. 9293 CGs destroyed, P < 2.2e-16, Fisher Exact test).
For CpG islands, the DAF for YRI is shown in Figure 1, and in Additional file 5 for CEU and Additional file 6 for ASN. Transition-generated CGs (Tsg) had a much higher DAF than transversion-generated CGs (Tvg)(0.379 vs. 0.326 for YRI, P = 0.023, Mann-Whitney U test). However, the control data showed the same trend (0.355 vs. 0.313, P = 0.0058, Mann-Whitney U test).
To investigate the influence of potential errors in assigning ancestral alleles on the above analyses, 9.4 Mb multiple sequence alignments of human/chimpanzee/baboon/rhesus were created by another method and analyzed. The same mutation and fixation patterns were observed (Additional file 7, Additional file 8).
To investigate if the above results might reflect selection on functional elements, the SNPs were classfied into four categories: intergenic non-CpG island; genic non-CpG island; intergenic CpG island; and genic CpG island (genic regions included the sites annotated as intronic, coding, 5'UTR, 3'UTR, 5'upstream, 3'downstream). Normally, intergenic, non-CpG island regions are regarded as neutral, so if selection is playing a role in the trends we observed, there should be differences between genic and intergenic patterns. However, we found similar patterns in genic and intergenic regions (Table 1).
Recent selection on the newly generated CG dinucleotides in different mutation categories
Control for transition-generated CG
Control for transversion-generated CG
Proportion indicating positive selection 1.
DAF of the positive selected CG 2.
general DAF 3.
Proportion indicating positive selection
DAF of the selected CG
negative selection 1.
DAF of the negative selected CG 2.
Proportion indicating negative selection
DAF of the selected CG
Recent selection on the backmutated CG dinucleotides
CAT- > CGT
CAT- > CGT
In the recombination hotspots, C/G derived from T/A had a much higher DAF than T/A that derived from C/G (0.347 vs. 0.304, P < 2.2e-16, Mann-Whitney U Test), which is in accordance with BGC effect. Meanwhile, the DAF was significantly greater for CG derived from CA/TG than for the control data (0.365 vs. 0.348, P < 2.2e-16, Mann-Whitney U Test), whereas the DAF of TG/CA derived from CG didn't differ significantly from the control data (0.296 vs. 0.304, P = 0.546, Mann-Whitney U Test). In the recombination coldspots, T/A derived from C/G had the same average DAF as that of C/G derived from T/A (0.316 vs. 0.320, P = 0.989, Mann-Whitney U Test), indicating that the fixation bias toward C/G disappeared in regions of low recombination, which is expected under BGC model. However, the DAF of CG derived from CA/TG is still higher than that of CA/TG derived from CG (0.343 vs. 0.290, P = 0.1717, Mann-Whitney U test), as well as that of the control data (0.343 vs. 0.320, P = 0.230, Mann-Whitney U test), but not statistically significant. Overall, these results indicate that the tendency observed in our study might be partially explained by recombination, further study is needed to address this question.
The observation that CG dinucleotides are under-represented in vertebrate genomes has received much attention. Much evidence suggests that the observed deficiency of CG dinucleotides is caused by hypermutable methylated cytosine, which mainly exists as the CG dinucleotide in vertebrate genomes. This is further supported by the observation that 90% of the mutations from CGs are transitions to CA/TG in our study, accompanied with the overrepresentation of TG/CA in the genome reported by others . More directly, when the CGs in CpG islands become methylated, CGs mutate to TG/CA at a comparatively high rate . It is estimated that the advent of heavily methylated genomes dates to approximately 450 million years ago, leading to a lower CG frequency [38, 39]. Meanwhile, CpG islands which were thought to lack methylation were also being lost [15, 17, 18].
Yet the methylated CG dinucleotide acts as an essential substrate for many regulatory reactions . This was believed to be a high fidelity process, until studies revealed the possibility of deleterious mutations induced by deamination of 5-methylcytosine [12–14]. The question then arose as to whether CG dinucleotides would vanish from the genome.
In our study, by analyzing the mutations involving CG dinucleotides in non-CpG island regions, a strong tendency toward increasing CG dinucleotides was observed, due to biased mutation and fixation patterns. Specifically, there are about three times as many mutations generating new CGs as mutations eliminating CGs, mainly due to the overwhelming number of mutations from CA/TG to CG. Furthermore, transition-generated CGs had a higher average DAF than transversion-generated CGs, and in comparison to control data, transition-generated CGs had a significantly higher DAF while transversion-generated CGs had a significantly lower DAF. Since most CA/TG dinucleotides are derived from deamination of 5-methylcytosine, many mutations from CA/TG to CG should be back-mutations after CG mutated to CA/TG. This scenario thereby recreates ancestral CGs in the genome while preventing novel CGs that derived from CC/CT/AG/GG.
By contrast, in CpG island regions, which are relatively abundant in CG dinucleotides, there seems to be a tendency toward reducing the number of CG dinucleotides. This may reflect evolution from a non-equilibrium GC content in such regions, as the equilibrium GC content in the human genome is estimated to be 33%-42%, which is much lower than the present GC content (> 55%).
Although the preference for transition-generated CGs was observed both in intergenic and genic regions, it could be driven by natural selection as many regulatory elements are located in intergenic regions [40–43]. The assumption of the selection test we applied is that, if the higher average DAF was caused by positive selection on these transition-generated CGs, a larger proportion of the CGs should exhibit signals of positive selection, compared with the control dataset. However, no difference between the CG and control data was observed, indicating that newly-generated CGs were not excessively subject to recent positive selection (Table 2). The analysis of inferred back-mutations similarly indicated that such back-mutations also were not significantly influenced by recent positive selection.
It should be noted that the failure to detect the signal of recent positive selection could also have other explanations. The present methods for detecting the signal of recent positive selection are mainly targeted at a region rather than a specific locus [33, 44], and identifying causal variants is quite challenging. Since positive signals may come from hitchhiking with the selected allele, applying such methods to isolated sites rather than a genomic region may lack sufficient power. Moreover, weak selection would be difficult to detect as well. Therefore, these results do not rule out some role for selection in producing the patterns observed in this study.
As an alternative to selection, the BGC model is a neutral process that increases the probability of fixation of mutations that increase GC content in the human genome [20, 45]. It is therefore of interest to investigate if our findings can be explained via an extension of the BGC model in the context of CG dinucleotides, in particular the fixation preference for recreating ancestral CGs, or if some other mechanism must be invoked.
Recombination was reported to be the cause of BGC [29, 46] and this is supported in our study, as the fixation preference for C/G rather than A/T exists in recombination hotspots, but not in the recombination coldspots. The fixation preference for transition-generated CGs we observed in our study might be partially driven by the recombination, as there were no significant difference between recombination hotspots and coldspots. However, more evidence is needed to address this question, as we have a rather small sample size in this analysis.
In this study, we identified a trend that could be responsible for generating new CG dinucleotides in non-CpG islands, which are otherwise deficient in the human genome; namely, an excess number of mutations from CA/TG to CG, which in turn recreates ancestral CG dinucleotides in the human genome that had been previously lost by mutation. It appears that neutral process, which might be partly associated with recombination, is responsible for this trend. By contrast, in CpG island regions, which are relatively abundant in CG dinucleotides, a tendency toward reducing the number of CG dinucleotides was observed. Overall, our results shed further light on the fate of CG dinucleotides in the genome.
We thank Marcos Antezana for helpful discussion and the guidance for part of the study, Matthew Webster, Cizhong Jiang, Shiheng Tao for providing valuable advice, Mark Stoneking for revising the manuscript as a native English speaker and helpful suggestions, and Ryan D. Hernandez for providing extra information about the method to correct the allele-frequency spectrum.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.