- Research article
- Open Access
Phylogeography of amphi-boreal fish: tracing the history of the Pacific herring Clupea pallasii in North-East European seas
© Laakkonen et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2013
- Received: 12 December 2012
- Accepted: 7 March 2013
- Published: 19 March 2013
The relationships between North Atlantic and North Pacific faunas through times have been controlled by the variation of hydrographic circumstances in the intervening Arctic Ocean and Bering Strait. We address the history of trans-Arctic connections in a clade of amphi-boreal pelagic fishes using genealogical information from mitochondrial DNA sequence data. The Pacific and Atlantic herrings (Clupea pallasii and C. harengus) have basically vicarious distributions in the two oceans since pre-Pleistocene times. However, remote populations of C. pallasii are also present in the border waters of the North-East Atlantic in Europe. These populations show considerable regional and life history differentiation and have been recognized in subspecies classification. The chronology of the inter-oceanic invasions and genetic basis of the phenotypic structuring however remain unclear.
The Atlantic and Pacific herrings both feature high mtDNA diversities (large long-term population sizes) in their native basins, but an ocean-wide homogeneity of C. harengus is contrasted by deep east-west Pacific subdivision within Pacific C. pallasii. The outpost populations of C. pallasii in NE Europe are identified as members of the western Pacific C. pallasii clade, with some retained inter-oceanic haplotype sharing. They have lost diversity in colonization bottlenecks, but have also thereafter accumulated abundant new variation. The data delineate three phylogeographic groups within the European C. pallasii: herring from the inner White Sea; herring from the Mezen and Chesha Bays; and a strongly bottlenecked peripheral population in Balsfjord of the Norwegian Sea.
The NE European outposts of C. pallasii are judged to be early post-glacial colonists from the NW Pacific. A strong regional substructure has evolved since that time, in contrast to the apparent broad-scale uniformity maintained by herrings in their native basins. The structure only partly matches the previous biological concepts based on seasonal breeding stocks or geographical subspecies designations. The trans-Arctic herring phylogeography is notably similar to those of the amphi-boreal mollusk taxa Macoma and Mytilus, suggesting similar histories of inter-oceanic connections. We also considered the time dependency of molecular rates, critical for interpreting timing of relatively recent biogeographical events, by comparing the estimates from coding and non-coding mitochondrial regions of presumably different mutation dynamics.
- Amphi-boreal fauna
- White Sea
- Trans-Arctic colonization
- Time-dependent rates
The boreal faunas of the North Atlantic and North Pacific oceans comprise many instances of closely related, vicariously distributed species pairs, reflecting a history of shared ancestry followed by inter-oceanic isolation through the Pleistocene and Holocene epochs. In most cases, this vicariance is thought to trace back to the Great Trans-Arctic Interchange approximately 3.5 Mya that followed the Pliocene opening of the Bering Strait, until which most of the lineages were restricted to a single ocean basin, and after which the Pleistocene conditions again restricted the dispersal (e.g. [1, 2]). Yet even since that time species could in principle have had several opportunities to disperse through the Arctic. The patterns of biotic exchange have been controlled by the history of climatic and hydrographical circumstances, but also by the thermal tolerance and dispersal characteristics of the taxa. Indeed, phylogeographical studies of amphi-boreal taxa have so far demonstrated a variety of inter-oceanic systematic affinities and more complex isolation/dispersal histories such as repeated trans-Arctic invasions, both in fishes (e.g. [3, 4]) and invertebrates [5, 6].
Among the most prominent pairs of amphi-boreal vicariant taxa are the Pacific and Atlantic herrings, Clupea pallasii Valenciennes, 1847 and Clupea harengus Linnaeus, 1758. They are pelagic planktivores occurring in massive schools and occupying both coasts of their respective oceans, from the temperate up to the subarctic zone. The inter-oceanic vicariance caused by the Arctic dispersal barrier is however not complete, but is broken by the presence of remote populations of C. pallasii in border waters of the NE Atlantic in Europe, particularly in the White and the south-eastern Barents seas. Also the Atlantic C. harengus penetrates these seas from the west, although does not spawn there [7, 8]. Moreover, isolated occurrences of C. pallasii even further west in some Norwegian Sea fjords are known .
The European populations of C. pallasii demonstrate remarkable heterogeneity of their life histories (e.g. ). In the White Sea Gulf of Kandalaksha, a fast-growing summer-spawning form similar to typical Pacific herring is distinguished from a more abundant slow-growing form, which uniquely breeds under the ice in the spring. There are also a number of other herring stocks in other parts of the White Sea and in the south-eastern Barents Sea, which differ in their growth rates and spawning seasons. The origins and status of the seasonal vs. geographical breeding stocks have been debated for decades, but genetic data so far have yielded contradicting results on these issues [11, 12]. At a broader regional scale in NE Europe, a subspecies-level division has generally been recognized, into the White Sea herring C. pallasii marisalbi Berg, 1923, and the Chesha–Pechora herring C. pallasii suworowi Rabinerson, 1927 in the south-eastern Barents Sea .
The timing and the geography of the origin of the European populations remain unexplored in phylogeographic terms, whereas allozyme and initial mitochondrial data have confirmed their Pacific species identity [8, 12, 13]. Based on paleogeographical facts, they have been thought to represent relict populations of a wider geographic distribution that existed along the Eurasian Arctic coast during warmer post-glacial times < 10 ky ago (e.g. ). The European outposts of a Pacific boreal taxon provide a platform to consider the dynamics of trans-Arctic connections in the context of climatic history, and should help to understand the biological consequences of the current climatic warming for integrity of biological diversity in the boreal and arctic seas (cf. [15, 16]).
Here we use the genealogical information in mitochondrial DNA sequence variation to assess the demographic histories and sub-structuring of the amphi-boreal species of herrings at various temporal and geographical scales, and particularly to trace the history and status of the NE European outpost populations of C. pallasii. Recent studies of C. pallasii within the Pacific have corroborated a pronounced intra-basin east–west subdivision, but raised discussion of interpreting the demography from mitochondrial control region data [17, 18]. No comparable broad-scale sequence data exist for the North Atlantic C. harengus, whereas it has appeared genetically relatively homogeneous on oceanic and regional scales in other genetic markers (e.g. [19–21], but see ). As a background, we first assess the mtDNA diversity of the two species in their native basins from comparable datasets. Then focusing on the inter-oceanic dispersal that should account for the presence of C. pallasii in Europe, three main hypotheses of invasion times are considered, i.e. pre-glacial (e.g. during Eemian interglacial period) approximately 120 kya, early post-glacial from the opening of the Bering Strait to the Holocene Thermal Maximum (12–5 kya), or a still more recent arrival or continued genetic exchange. We further assess the structure of the “invading” C. pallasii among and within the NE European seas, and document striking regional differences that contrast with the homogeneity of the herring stocks in their native basins. The data have implications on concepts of the systematics, breeding stocks and comparative genetics of C. pallasii itself, but are also of more general importance in the (comparative) framework of the history of boreal marine taxa with similar trans-Arctic distributions.
The dating of phylogeographical events on molecular grounds is a topic of contention due to the apparent time dependency of substitution rates (e.g. [23–25]), an issue that was also raised in previous herring work . We assess further the implications of the time dependency for the clupeid history and for inferences of trans-Arctic phylogeography more generally, by employing two sequence fragments of the mtDNA with potentially different mutation dynamics and biases (coding and non-coding).
Sample information for Clupea pallasii and Clupea harengus
Taxon, area, location
NW Pacific & Bering Sea
Sea of Japan
Sea of Okhotsk, Taui Bay
Bering Sea, Togiak Bay
Gulf of Alaska, Kodiak Bay
Chesha Bay, Yarnei River
Indiga Bay, near Svyatoi Nos
Mezen Bay, West Kanin
67.20 N, 43.49 E
Dvina Bay, Yandovaya Inlet
Onega Bay, Kolezhma Inlet
Onega Bay, Kii Island
Gulf of Kandalaksha, Chupa Inlet*
Gulf of Kandalaksha, Chupa Inlet
Gulf of Kandalaksha, Kolvitsa*
Gulf of Kandalaksha, Umba
European C. pallasii, Total
NW Atlantic, Canada
Baltic Sea, Bothnian Sea
Total C. harengus
Total, both species
Total genomic DNA was extracted either from muscle or fin tissue or from single spawned fertilized eggs using a salt precipitation method  or a silica binding procedure in a plate format . Two fragments of the mitochondrial genome were amplified and sequenced: the nearly complete cytochrome b gene (cyt-b, 1131 bp in final analysis), and the 5’-end of the control region (CR, 481 bp; details in Additional file 1). For both markers, sequence data were obtained from the same 528 fish altogether.
The data from the two gene regions were treated both separately and together as a concatenated data set. The diversity and genealogical relationships among mtDNA haplotypes were first illustrated with neighbor-joining trees, from pairwise distances between haplotypes estimated in PAUP* 4.0  under the GTR+I+Γ model of nucleotide substitution (model selection and parameters, see Additional file 1). Mean pairwise distances within and between the two species were calculated using MEGA 5.01 . For a subset of data, i.e. the mtDNA clade judged to have been involved in the trans-Arctic dispersal and subsequent connections, a 99% plausible parsimony network of haplotypes was constructed for the concatenated data set using the TCS 1.21 software .
Standard intrapopulation molecular diversity statistics were calculated using DnaSP v5 . Genetic differences among geographic regions and among populations within regions were assessed using the ΦST statistics of the analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) using the Arlequin software (version 18.104.22.168), for the concatenated data . Inter-population relationships were illustrated by metric multidimensional scaling (MDS) from the pairwise ΦST distance matrix, using NTSYS-pc software . Signals of past population expansions within population groups judged to represent historically coherent entities were illustrated in mismatch distributions separately for the two genes . Changes in effective population size (Ne) were further studied by coalescence simulations using Bayesian skyline plot analysis (BSL) with BEAST v1.5.3 software (; details in Additional file 1).
We also used a rough direct count approach to estimate invasion age from the number of new mutations that were inferred to have arisen within the European populations since a putative founding bottleneck and population expansion, as seen in the haplotype network.
Conventionally, divergence rates used for molecular dating have been based on "deep" reference dates of pre-Pleistocene age, but in reality, on the more recent time scales dealt with here, the apparent time dependency of molecular rates becomes a major issue disturbing the linear time relationship; applying deep calibrations will provide overestimates of the ages of more recent events (e.g. [23, 24]). Nevertheless, to facilitate description of the results, we will first use a tentative operational cyt-b rate of 1.5% My-1 (0.75% per lineage), in line with deep calibrations used for other fishes and with the basic trans-Arctic interchange/vicariance hypothesis (see Additional file 1).
Intra- and interspecies sequence diversity
Estimates of genetic diversity and coalescence times in two herring species and in selected population groups
Taxon / genetic group
GTR distance (%)
GTR distance (%)
GTR distance (%)
White Sea group (incl Pechora Indiga)
UPGMA basal distance
C. harengus vs.Pacific C. pallasii
In the text below, usually either the cyt-b or concatenated datasets are described, whereas comparisons between different datasets are considered in the demographic analyses (mismatch distributions and Bayesian skyline plots), in Table 2, and in Additional file 2: Figure S1 and Additional file 3: Table S1. The information contents of the cyt-b and CR data sets alone were similar to each other, but the evolution of cyt-b is thought to be more regular and more amenable to model corrections. The cyt-b vs. CR comparisons will be taken up in the Discussion while considering the effects of the apparent time-dependence of molecular rates.
Geographic structuring vs. homogeneity within ocean basins
In C. pallasii of the Pacific basin, the mtDNA variation was organized into three distinct clusters or lineages, in accord with previous CR data [17, 18]. The primary division was between a North West Pacific (NWP) lineage that included the Russian Pacific and Bering Sea samples versus a NE Pacific (NEP) lineage, composed of North American samples south of the Alaska Peninsula. The NEP lineage was further subdivided into two clusters which were however geographically intermixed between the samples from Washington and Gulf of Alaska (WAS, ALA) (Figure 2). The two NEP clusters appeared reciprocally monophyletic in the cyt-b data and in the two-gene concatenated dataset, which was not evident from the CR data alone (Additional file 4: Figure S2). There was no significant differentiation between the two NEP lineage samples in terms of AMOVA apportionment of nucleotide diversity (ΦST = −0.002 for the concatenated dataset), neither among the four samples of the Asian coast and the Bering Sea that made up the NWP lineage (ΦST = 0.005; Table 3). The basal distance (coalescence) between the two main Pacific lineages, from simple UPGMA averaging, was 1.54% in cyt-b (GTR+I+Γ), i.e. 33% of the interspecies distance.
In the material from C. harengus, no geographical structuring was seen at the level of nucleotide diversity (ΦST=-0.005 in AMOVA); haplotypes from the NW Atlantic, Norwegian Sea and Baltic Sea were mixed within the genealogy (Figure 2, Additional file 4: Figure S2). The basal cyt-b distance, 1.57%, was similar to that in the Pacific herring.
Relationships between the NE Atlantic and North Pacific Clupea pallasii
The C. pallasii haplotypes from all the European samples clustered within the NWP lineage elsewhere distributed in the Bering Sea and Asian coasts (A lineage in ). This shared lineage will henceforth be referred to as the “trans-Arctic group” (Figure 2). The European samples did not comprise a separate monophyletic cluster within this group. They however did show distinctly lower intra-population and regional nucleotide and haplotype diversities than the Pacific relatives (Table 2). The European diversity mainly comprised of three or four dominant haplotypes (A-D) associated with sets of unique satellite haplotypes, one or two mutations away from the dominant ones (Figure 3). The same dominant haplotypes were also found in the North-West Pacific, where they similarly made nodes for local star-phylogenies in the network and were among the most abundant haplotypes.
Diversity and differentiation within European C. pallasii
Estimates of the inter-population component of nucleotide diversity Φ ST in geographically and genetically defined population groups of two herring species, from the concatenated cyt-b + CR sequences
Taxon / genetic group
White Sea group (incl Pechora Indiga)
Signatures of demographic history
The BSL plots suggest the first signal of coalescence for both C. harengus and NEP C. pallasii at 0.69–0.74% cyt-b per-site mutation units ago, and subsequent episodes of population growth at 0.30–0.40%, in agreement with the mismatch analysis (Figure 5, Additional file 3: Table S1). The youngest growth signal in the NE Pacific plot is at 0.05%, not apparent from the mismatch distribution. In the White Sea and Mezen–Chesha C. pallasii, stark signals of expansion are seen at 0.03% cyt-b units, corresponding to the most recent (zero) peak of the mismatch distribution.
Estimates of ancestral population variability ( θ = N e μ ), splitting parameter s, post-splitting migration rates ( m 1 = migration to NWP, m 2 = migration to Europe) and parameter of time since divergence (t) obtained from coalescence-based IM model runs of the trans-Arctic clade
NW Pacific vs.
- White Sea groupa
- White Sea groupb
- Mezen–Chesha group
In an alternative and informal approach, the time since invasion was evaluated directly from the number of inferred new mutations, which are illustrated in the haplotype network where two European core haplotypes are associated with several satellite haplotypes each (Figure 3). Assuming a sudden expansion at time t (star-coalescence), per-gene mutation rate μ and no drift or migration since then, we would expect n = t·μ·N new mutations in a sample of N. From the network, we count 34 putative mutations among 198 White Sea group individuals in the cyt-b sequence, which, given μ = 0.75·10-8·1131 bp, would be expected in t = 34/(μ·198) ≈ 20 ky (a minimum estimate). Similarly for the Mezen–Chesha group t ≈ 26 ky (=10/(μ·45)).
Divergence and comparative intra-basin phylogeography of Pacific and Atlantic herrings
We estimated the inter-species sequence divergence between Atlantic and Pacific herring mtDNA lineages (C. harengus vs. C. pallasii) as 4.7% for the cytochrome b gene and 16.9% for the CR segment using appropriate substitution models, or 3.6% and 8.3% in terms of net distance, appropriate for assessing species divergence. These figures fit with the conventionally assumed vicariance history implied for taxa involved in the Pliocene Trans-Arctic Interchange [1, 2], and with the suggested fish molecular rates. They are also compatible with the tentative 0.75% My-1 per lineage cyt-b rate used for the technical basis of discussion here (see Additional file 1).
Our data corroborate a fundamental geographical subdivision of C. pallasii within the Pacific basin, into an Asian–Beringian NWP lineage and a North American NEP lineage, found south of the Alaska Peninsula [17, 18, 37, 38]. The NEP lineage is further subdivided into two clusters, but with no geographical structuring; it is controversial whether this reflects a cycle of refugial isolation and remixing  or just random mtDNA coalescence within a single panmictic, large and old population .
In contrast to the Pacific sister species, the Atlantic herring mtDNA data show no prominent signs of geographical subdivision even on a broad trans-oceanic scale. This is consistent with previous data on homogeneity in the bulk of other markers (e.g. [19–21]), whereas local differentiation at putatively selected loci have also been reported in recent genomic studies [22, 39]. The broad-scale homogeneity can reflect effective long-term connectedness through the range, but it could also result from a history where the species was regionally extirpated from one side of the Atlantic temporarily and was then re-established by post-glacial trans-Atlantic invaders (cf. ). A history of single-coast Atlantic survival has been suggested for several boreal benthic invertebrates , and genetically corroborated for some . The fish species capelin and cod in turn seem to have persisted through the LGM on both sides of the Atlantic [4, 42].
Both herring species show remarkably high levels of sequence diversity, and those in Atlantic herring (cyt-b π = 0.90–1.03%) are much higher than in other widespread boreal Atlantic fishes considered to represent similar Atlantic–Arctic ancestries (e.g. capelin cyt-b π = 0.30–0.50%, ; Atlantic cod CR π = 0.17–0.63%, ). Yet disregarding the geography, the overall patterns in the two herring species, as reflected e.g. in the mismatch distributions, appear notably similar. The deep diversity itself implies large long-term population sizes, and peaked mismatch distributions imply an ancient expansion at the base of the genealogy (not recoverable by the BSL approach alone). The corresponding mtDNA TMRCA (illustrated as the start of the BSL graph) within each species is about 30% of the interspecies mtDNA divergence. These basal expansion signals could plausibly represent events during the early Middle Pleistocene climatic cycles ≤1 Mya (the time-dependency of rates should not bias estimates too much at this deep level, e.g. ). Traces of further growth episodes are also visible similarly in both species (Figure 5). A difference in the patterns is noted in a final signal of post-glacial growth only recorded in the C. pallasii NWP clade (cf. ) .
In assessing Pacific C. pallasii demography, Grant et al.  noted that recent bottlenecks (e.g. LGM) would wipe out evidence of older events in the BSL plots. However, in our data pre-LGM expansion signals are prominent in the NWP and NEP groups and in C. harengus, not only in mismatch distributions but also in the BSL plots (Figure 5). The end point of the BSL graph (the basal coalescence) may also represent an expansion, depending on the shape of the genealogy (cf. the mismatch distribution expansion peak). Nevertheless, it is notable that no signs of population bottlenecks over the Pleistocene glacial cycles are evident in the oceanic populations.
Diversity and origin of the European C. pallasii
The European C. pallasii grouped tightly within the NWP lineage of the Pacific herring of the Bering Sea and the Asian Pacific coast (Figure 2), and the most common haplotypes were shared between the European and NWP stocks (Figure 3). The inter-oceanic connections have evidently been much younger than the intra-oceanic split of the NWP and NEP lineages discussed above.
A bottleneck history of European invaders
The European outposts show reduced mtDNA variation particularly in terms of haplotype diversity, with a strong dominance of 1–3 core haplotypes in each population (Table 2, Figure 3). Evidently only a small number of females effectively contributed to the colonization of Europe. A bottleneck signature is also seen in the IM results, suggesting founding population sizes 0.05–1% of the ancestral Pacific population (Table 4). The pattern of few dominant core haplotypes with closely associated satellites (new mutations) is a clear signature of demographic expansions following the invasion bottleneck , also reflected in the coalescence plots (Figure 5). More generally this bottleneck pattern corroborates the concept that the direction of colonization actually was from the Pacific towards Atlantic.
Estimating the trans-Arctic connections
Simulating the process of the split, divergence and accumulation of new mutations with the IM coalescence model, the age of the two-population split was estimated at approximately 0.5 cyt-b per-gene mutation units, corresponding to 50–70 ky under the operational 0.75% My-1 per site rate. The BSL analysis dated population expansions for European populations some 30 kya, whereas the direct count of inferred post-colonization mutations suggested dates between 20–26 kya, in accord with the mismatch estimates of 18–26 kya (Additional file 3: Table S1) from a similar reasoning.
While age estimates from the different approaches vary (18–70 kya, all based on the same cyt-b rate), they all inconveniently point to the Middle to Late Weichselian glacial times, and do not directly fit any of our a-priori dispersal time hypotheses. During this time the Bering Strait was effectively closed (e.g. ), and at any rate the paleoclimatic data indicate that conditions at these latitudes have been too cold for boreal species through Late Pleistocene interstadials . The abundance of new mutations in itself directly rules out a hypothesis of recent, historical-time relationships (< 1 kya). At the same time, the time dependency of molecular rate (see below) implies that dates in this age frame will generally be gross overestimates rather than underestimates, thus the hypothesis of an earlier, Eemian interglacial ancestry (120 kya) can be confidently rejected. Considering the biological and paleoclimatic evidence, and concept of time-dependent rates, the invasion of C. pallasii to Northern Europe can then reasonably only be attributed to the Holocene since the opening of the strait (<12 kya), including the “Thermal Maximum” (HTM 5–8 kya; e.g., ).
The differences between the various divergence estimates from same data may reflect the differences in model assumptions concerning post-colonization migration and population size. Yet while IM suggested practically unidirectional eastward gene flow, the biological significance of the estimates is not entirely clear. The estimated gene flow rate was similar to the effect of mutations (m 1 ~1–5; Table 4), which appears biologically unrealistic considering the assumed large population size of the recipient NWP–Bering Sea herring stock. At the same time, the presence of several unique non-core haplotypes in the European stocks could be seen as evidence of significant post-bottleneck immigration to the opposite direction. Evidently caution is needed when considering the IM migration estimates and other parameters given that they are based on coalescence simulation of a single locus.
Some support for continued trans-Arctic connections is however provided in records of herring populations found during the comparatively warm years of the 1930s-1940s at several Arctic Siberian sites (Figure 1: estuaries of the Ob, Enisei, Lena and Indigirka rivers; ). While the original invasion route for the European stocks itself remains uncertain, the source of those recent Siberian populations is of interest considering the direction and effects of potential long-term genetic exchange. Both the coastal currents  and the IM estimates support west-to-east gene flow. A biological hypothesis in line with this is that the European C. pallasii may be better adapted to Arctic conditions and thus more apt to disperse, since they descend from fish that successfully once crossed the Arctic; the Bering Sea fish in turn seem to make part of a widespread genetically uniform NW Pacific population including southern latitude stocks. Considering the potential effects of future climatic warming, such directionality would imply relatively minor genetic effects to the European stocks.
Systematics of C. pallasii
The C. pallasii mtDNA genealogy does not comply with the current subspecies division into a Pacific C. p. pallasii and two European taxa, C. p. marisalbi and C. p. suworowi. Rather, C. p. pallasii as currently defined is a paraphyletic unit, from which the putative European taxa arose; this is also evident in allozyme data . The basic genetic division of C. pallasii, in both mitochondrial and nuclear data, is into a biologically comparatively homogenous American lineage and a more heterogeneous Eurasian lineage. The latter comprises both the Asian Pacific Bering Sea populations and the European outposts, representing all the three conventional subspecies. This Eurasian lineage is identifiable with the nominate C. p. pallasii Valenciennes, 1847 (described from Kamchatka) whereas a classification reflecting biological and historical relationships would attribute the American herrings another name; at a subspecies level that would be C. p. mirabilis Girard, 1854, originally described from San Francisco as C. mirabilis (see ). The distributional limit and biological differences of these taxa have been repeatedly documented at the Aleutian chain [17, 37, 38].
Substructure among NE European populations
The estimates of inter-oceanic relationships above were based on contrasting the NWP “ancestors” with a genetically homogeneous subgroup of the European samples, mainly from the inner White Sea basin (Figures 1 and 3; red dots). We however found strong regional heterogeneity among the various NE European samples, which roughly fall into three genetic groups, characterized by successively lower levels of intra-population diversity (Table 2; Figure 4). This complex genetic structuring of the European C. pallasii is unusual in view of the relative genetic homogeneity of both herring species in their native ranges.
The distinction between the two major, geographically overlapping or interdigitated groups in the inner White Sea vs. Pechora Sea (Mezen–Chesha) is puzzling, and it is unclear at what stage the subdivision arose and how it is maintained. The simple ΦST divergence estimates give no suggestion that the White Sea group would have descended from the Pechora population through serial colonization (e.g. the Pechora stock is not situated between White Sea and Bering Sea in the MDS ordination, Figure 4). The IM and direct count approaches both suggest similar invasion times for the two groups if treated separately (see above). It seems reasonable to assume that the colonization of Mezen–Chesha and White Sea regions was a result of the same invasion from the NW Pacific in the early Holocene, and the current complex substructure arose during further regional refugial phases associated with post-glacial climatic fluctuations. Genetic drift and limited migration must have been the primary factors in generating the structure, while selection that restricts gene exchange between locally adapted stocks might also have contributed to its maintenance.
The main genetic subdivision in the North European data largely accords with the previously established biological division into the “White Sea herring” C. p. marisalbi and the “Chesha-Pechora herring” C. p. suworowi of the SE Barents Sea. The latter has been thought to encompass the Mezen Bay population at the White Sea entrance (e.g. [7, 50]), which is also supported by allozyme  and osteological data (D.L. Lajus, unpublished observations). The discrepancy arises with the Indiga sample (IND), geographically within the range of the Chesha–Pechora herring but genetically associated with the inner White Sea samples in our data (Figure 4). Fish in this sample were in spawning condition, and similar to other Chesha–Pechora herring in their characteristic growth rate, and probably represent true heterogeneity of the breeding stock in that area.
At a further level of biological structuring, the inner White Sea herring (C. p. marisalbi) are differentiated into several geographical and temporal spawning stocks, whose history and status have long been debated (see ). Significant chromosomal variations in Robertsonian polymorphisms between the major bays of the sea but not between sympatric seasonal breeding stocks suggested that geographical differences, probably reflecting local (post-glacial) adaptation, are more fundamental than those between seasonal stocks, which only would have arisen later [10, 11]. In contrast, allozyme data have shown stable differentiation between sympatric seasonal stocks in the Gulf of Kandalaksha: the spring spawners were closer to the Chesha-Pechora ("suworowi") than to the sympatric summer-spawning White Sea herring . Our White Sea mtDNA data covered samples from both the geographical and seasonal spawning ranges, but failed to demonstrate differences either between the main spawning regions in the inner White Sea (Kandalaksha, Onega and Dvina bays), or between the Kandalaksha spring- and summer-breeding cohorts – in contrast to the distinction of the three broader North European groups (Figure 4).
Balsfjord herring: outpost of an outpost
Balsfjord of the Norwegian Sea has a distinct breeding population of C. pallasii that returns to spawn at the same shallows of the fjord every year [51, 52]. This is one of but two recognized C. pallasii populations on the Norwegian coast. The diversity of the C. pallasii mtDNA lineage in Balsfjord shows extreme reduction from the putative ancestral variation of the trans-Arctic group (Figure 3). The Balsfjord haplotypes seem to be derived from a single surviving haplotype lineage, suggesting a scenario where very few females effectively participated in the Balsfjord colonization and no essential further input was received from the east since that. The basal haplotype A is one of the major ones in the White Sea–Pechora Sea region, and indeed the most dominant one in the White Sea basin: a serial colonization from those stocks following the initial European bottlenecks therefore seems plausible. Yet the frequency of inferred post-bottleneck mutations in Balsfjord (5 of 39 ~ 13% in cyt-b) is similar to those in the White Sea–Pechora Sea region, and the colonization events thus probably still represent the same time frame, i.e. early post-glacial. The Balsfjord herring has also acquired some new variation through introgression (data to be presented elsewhere), but this should not affect the inferences above about its ancestry based on the original mtDNA lineage.
Comparative trans-Arctic phylogeography
Two vicariant herring species of Atlantic and Pacific origin now meet secondarily in marginal seas of the North Atlantic, in NE Europe. Understanding the history of this contact is of broader importance, as it has several zoogeographical analogues, probably with similar histories. These occur e.g. among cods (Gadidae), which, as Clupea, are thought to have initially invaded the Pacific from the Atlantic in the Pliocene , but then, according to genetic data, returned back to the Atlantic on at least two occasions: The Pacific cod (Gadus macrocephalus) invaded the NW Atlantic and gave rise to the Greenland cod (G. ogac), while the Alaska pollock (Theragra (= Gadus) chalcogramma) invaded NE Atlantic, recorded there as “T. finnmarchica” [54, 55]. Both these taxa now co-occur with the Atlantic cod in the northern Atlantic. A recent Atlantic re-invasion from the Pacific has also been suspected for the circumpolar capelin (Mallotus villosus), with a western Pacific–Arctic lineage present in the Labrador Sea .
Non-linear rate and amending of time estimates
The effect of the apparent time-dependency of molecular rate to estimates of demographic events on phylogeographical time scales has been considered recently by several authors (e.g. [23–25]). As a general observation, molecular change on shorter time scales appears to occur at a faster rate than if averaged over phylogenetic scales. Conventional rate estimates are typically based on fossil or biogeographical “calibration” dates in a > 2 My time frame, and if directly applied to recent phylogeographic events will result in age estimates several-fold too high. Crandall et al. calibrated population expansion signals of several marine taxa to inferred post-LGM habitat expansion and obtained mtDNA rates ca. 7-fold higher than conventionally assumed, and Grant et al. specifically criticized conventional dating of “native” Pacific herring population history on similar grounds.
Notably, attempts to date trans-Arctic invasion events by external mtDNA rates and coalescence methods (including IM and BSL) now consistently result in estimates falling to the Middle Weichselian, i.e. to the most improbable time frame, midway between the current (< 12 kya) and previous (120 kya) interglacials, when trans-Arctic connections were closed: most estimates in each of Clupea, Mytilus and Macoma ranged 20–70 kya. A notion of e.g. 7-fold underestimate of recent rate would indeed bring all these conveniently close to the early-to-middle Holocene warm period 5–10 kya. While this is reassuring, the modified estimates evidently cannot have any accuracy, which further stresses the qualitative nature of the inference from the single-locus coalescence analyses. Yet, by a simple reasoning based on upper limits of u and the inferred (minimum) number of mutations from star-phylogeny components of the haplotype diagrams, we obtain minimum ages that reliably bracket out the most recent time frame affected by human activities.
The mechanisms underlying the time-dependent rate are not well understood (see ). The phenomenon entails the failure of the applied substitution models to linearize the evolutionary time scale. While the time-dependency has been recorded from studies of both coding and non-coding mtDNA, the substitution models could be expected to deal better with the coding gene evolution (mainly of silent sites) than that of the CR, often structurally constrained and involving mutation hotspots. To explore this expectation, we compared the biases resulting from the analysis of the coding vs. CR segments in the same mtDNA molecule genealogy in our herring data: the critique of herring time estimates by Grant et al. primarily concerned CR estimates.
While the demographic signals in the mismatch and BSL plots from the two markers appear broadly similar (Figure 5), the quantitative estimates (Additional file 3: Table S1) and a cyt-b vs. CR plot of selected diversity and divergence estimates (Additional file 2) indeed do show some consistent differences, which are not always in the expected direction. From a “calibration” fixed at the inter-species TMRCA, the modeled rate for CR is 3.6 times faster than of cyt-b (16.9% vs. 4.7% divergence; the substitution models adopted for the two regions were indeed quite similar). Applying these rates at shorter distances however yields consistently younger ages from CR than from cyt-b (Figure 5; Additional file 2). The models thus appear to do better in linearizing the CR than the cyt-b divergence scales. Actually, from the mismatch and BSL approaches, the “conventional” CR estimates for the European invasion/expansion would point very close to the post-glacial warm period (5–13 kya), whereas cyt-b estimates mostly fall to pre-LGM times > 20 kya, whereby it appears that there would be little if any bias in the CR data at these time frames. Grant et al. in turn still suggested a 3-fold acceleration in their Pacific herring CR data, reflecting the intra-basin expansion signal in the Pacific. In more concrete terms, it seems that the inferred post-glacial bursts of new haplotypes that manifest the accelerated rate are less extensive in North European CR than cyt-b data, but such inter-locus difference is not seen in the NWP populations even in our data (Figure 3). This would suggest even population-wise or regional differences in the (ir)regularity of the rate.
Patterns of mitochondrial diversity in the Pacific and Atlantic herrings C. pallasii and C. harengus reflect a vicarious history in the two ocean basins, with similarly large long-term effective sizes in both species but contrasting patterns of intra-basin subdivision. The long-term inter-oceanic vicariance of the two species is broken by a presence of outpost Pacific herring populations in NE Europe, which are inferred to represent early post-glacial colonizers derived entirely from the Asian-Beringian C. pallasii clade. The history of this secondary invasion has involved bottlenecks and has been followed by accumulation of new mtDNA variation. A strong regional substructure has evolved since that time in Europe, in stark contrast to the broad-scale uniformity maintained by herrings in their native basins. This structure only partly matches the previous biological concepts based on seasonal breeding stocks or geographical subspecies designations. The observed trans-Arctic herring phylogeography is notably similar to those of two amphi-boreal mollusk taxa, Macoma and Mytilus, suggesting similar histories of inter-oceanic connections, and plausibly similar responses to and genetic consequences from future changes in Arctic hydrography. We also considered the suggested time dependency of molecular rates, critical for interpreting timing of relatively recent biogeographical events, by directly comparing estimates from coding and non-coding mitochondrial regions of presumably different mutation dynamics.
Availability of supporting data
The data sets supporting the results of this article are available in the GenBank (accession numbers KC599333-KC599541 (cyt-b) and KC594362-KC594546 (CR)) and Dryad repository (doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.5061/dryad.q31f8). GenBank: sequence data. Dryad: list of individual samples with sample locations and Genbank accession numbers for both gene regions, Arlequin input files with population grouping, IM input files, pairwise interpopulation ΦST distance matrix for the MDS ordination.
We thank Elza Ivshina, Andrey Semushin, Andrey Smirnov, Tatyana Paneva, Jim Seeb and Gunnar Knapp for providing samples, and Michael Hardman for an introduction to molecular labwork. The study was funded by the Academy of Finland (project grant 127471).
- Vermeij GJ: Anatomy of an invasion - the trans-arctic interchange. Paleobiology. 1991, 17 (3): 281-307.Google Scholar
- Briggs JC: Global Biogeography. 1995, Amsterdam: ElsevierGoogle Scholar
- Taylor EB, Dodson JJ: A molecular analysis of relationships and biogeography within a species complex of Holarctic fish (genus Osmerus). Mol Ecol. 1994, 3 (3): 235-248. 10.1111/j.1365-294X.1994.tb00057.x.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dodson JJ, Tremblay S, Colombani F, Carscadden JE, Lecomte F: Trans-Arctic dispersals and the evolution of a circumpolar marine fish species complex, the capelin (Mallotus villosus). Mol Ecol. 2007, 16 (23): 5030-5043. 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2007.03559.x.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nikula R, Strelkov P, Väinölä R: Diversity and trans-Arctic invasion history of mitochondrial lineages in the North Atlantic Macoma balthica complex (Bivalvia: Tellinidae). Evolution. 2007, 61 (4): 928-941. 10.1111/j.1558-5646.2007.00066.x.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Rawson PD, Harper FM: Colonization of the northwest Atlantic by the blue mussel, Mytilus trossulus postdates the last glacial maximum. Mar Biol. 2009, 156 (9): 1857-1868. 10.1007/s00227-009-1218-x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Svetovidov AN: Seldevye (Clupeidae). Fauna SSSR. Ryby 2(1). 1952, Moscow and Leningrad: Zoologicheskii Institut Akademiya Nauk SSSRGoogle Scholar
- Jørstad KE: Evidence for two highly differentiated herring groups at Goose Bank in the Barents Sea and the genetic relationship to Pacific herring, Clupea pallasi. Environ Biol Fish. 2004, 69 (1–4): 211-221.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jørstad KE, Novikov GG, Stasenkova NJ, Røttingen I, Stasenkov VA, Wennevik V, Golubev AN, Paulsen OI, Karpov AK, Telitsina LA: Intermingling of herring stocks in the Barents Sea area. Herring: Expectations for a New Millennium. Edited by: Funk F, Balckburn J, Hay D, Paul AJ, Stephenson R, Toresen R, Witherell D. 2001, Fairbanks, Alaska: University of Alaska Sea Grant College Program, 629-633.Google Scholar
- Lajus DL: Long-term discussion on the stocks of the White Sea herring: historical perspective and present state. ICES Mar Sci Symp. 2002, 215: 321-328.Google Scholar
- Lajus DL: White Sea herring (Clupea pallasi marisalbi, Berg) population structure: interpopulation variation in frequency of chromosomal rearrangement. Cybium. 1996, 20: 279-294.Google Scholar
- Semenova AV, Andreeva AP, Karpov AK, Novikov GG: An analysis of allozyme variation in herring Clupea pallasii from the White and Barents Seas. J Ichthyology. 2009, 49 (4): 313-330. 10.1134/S0032945209040043.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gorbachev VV, Chernoivanova LA, Panfilova PN, Trofimov IK, Batanov RL, Chikilev VG, Bonk AA, Nekhaev IO, Solovenchuk LL, Vakatov AV: Phylogeography of Pacific herring Clupea pallasii from Eurasian seas. Russ J Genet. 2012, 48 (9): 933-938. 10.1134/S1022795412080042.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Grant WS: Biochemical genetic divergence between Atlantic, Clupea harengus, and Pacific, Clupea pallasi, herring. Copeia. 1986, 3: 714-719.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Vermeij GJ, Roopnarine PD: The coming Arctic invasion. Science. 2008, 321 (5890): 780-781. 10.1126/science.1160852.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Heide-Jorgensen MP, Laidre KL, Quakenbush LT, Citta JJ: The northwest passage opens for bowhead whales. Biol Lett. 2012, 8 (2): 270-273. 10.1098/rsbl.2011.0731.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Liu J-X, Tatarenkov A, Beacham TD, Gorbachev V, Wildes S, Avise JC: Effects of Pleistocene climatic fluctuations on the phylogeographic and demographic histories of Pacific herring (Clupea pallasii). Mol Ecol. 2011, 20 (18): 3879-3893. 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2011.05213.x.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Grant WS, Liu M, Gao T, Yanagimoto T: Limits of Bayesian skyline plot analysis of mtDNA sequences to infer historical demographies in Pacific herring (and other species). Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2012, 65 (1): 203-212. 10.1016/j.ympev.2012.06.006.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Grant WS: Biochemical population genetics of Atlantic herring, Clupea harengus. Copeia. 1984, 2: 357-364.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jørstad KE, King DPF, Naevdal G: Population structure of Atlantic herring, Clupea harengus L. J Fish Biol. 1991, 39 (Supplement A): 43-52.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Larsson LC, Laikre L, Palm S, Andre C, Carvalho GR, Ryman N: Concordance of allozyme and microsatellite differentiation in a marine fish, but evidence of selection at a microsatellite locus. Mol Ecol. 2007, 16 (6): 1135-1147.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lamichhaney S, Martinez Barrio A, Rafati N, Sundström G, Rubin CJ, Gilbert ER, Berglund J, Wetterbom A, Laikre L, Webster MT, Grabherr M, Ryman N, Andersson L: Population-scale sequencing reveals genetic differentiation due to local adaptation in Atlantic herring. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2012, 109 (47): 19345-19350. 10.1073/pnas.1216128109.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ho SYW, Phillips MJ, Cooper A, Drummond AJ: Time dependency of molecular rate estimates and systematic overestimation of recent divergence times. Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22 (7): 1561-1568. 10.1093/molbev/msi145.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Burridge CP, Craw D, Fletcher D, Waters JM: Geological dates and molecular rates: fish DNA sheds light on time dependency. Mol Biol Evol. 2008, 25 (4): 624-633. 10.1093/molbev/msm271.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Crandall ED, Sbrocco EJ, DeBoer TS, Barber PH, Carpenter KE: Expansion dating: calibrating molecular clocks in marine species from expansions onto the Sunda shelf following the last glacial maximum. Mol Biol Evol. 2012, 29 (2): 707-719. 10.1093/molbev/msr227.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Aljanabi SM, Martinez I: Universal and rapid salt-extraction of high quality genomic DNA for PCR-based techniques. Nucleic Acids Res. 1997, 25 (22): 4692-4693. 10.1093/nar/25.22.4692.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Elphinstone MS, Hinten GN, Anderson MJ, Nock CJ: An inexpensive and high-throughput procedure to extract and purify total genomic DNA for population studies. Mol Ecol Notes. 2003, 3 (2): 317-320. 10.1046/j.1471-8286.2003.00397.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Swofford DL: PAUP*. Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (*and Other Methods). Version 4. 2003, Sunderland, Massachusetts: Sinauer AssociatesGoogle Scholar
- Tamura K, Peterson D, Peterson N, Stecher G, Nei M, Kumar S: MEGA5: molecular evolutionary genetics analysis using maximum likelihood, evolutionary distance, and maximum parsimony methods. Mol Biol Evol. 2011, 28 (10): 2731-2739. 10.1093/molbev/msr121.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Clement M, Posada D, Crandall KA: TCS: a computer program to estimate gene genealogies. Mol Ecol. 2000, 9 (10): 1657-1659. 10.1046/j.1365-294x.2000.01020.x.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Librado P, Rozas J: DnaSP v5: a software for comprehensive analysis of DNA polymorphism data. Bioinformatics. 2009, 25 (11): 1451-1452. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btp187.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Excoffier L, Lischer HEL: Arlequin suite ver 3.5: a new series of programs to perform population genetics analyses under Linux and Windows. Mol Ecol Resour. 2010, 10 (3): 564-567. 10.1111/j.1755-0998.2010.02847.x.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Rohlf FJ: Numerical Taxonomy and Multivariate Analysis System NTSYS-pc. 1990, State University of New York: Department of Ecology and EvolutionGoogle Scholar
- Rogers AR, Harpending H: Population growth makes waves in the distribution of paiwise genetic differences. Mol Biol Evol. 1992, 9 (3): 552-569.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Drummond AJ, Suchard MA, Xie D, Rambaut A: Bayesian phylogenetics with BEAUti and the BEAST 1.7. Mol Biol Evol. 2012, 29 (8): 1969-1973. 10.1093/molbev/mss075.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hey J, Nielsen R: Multilocus methods for estimating population sizes, migration rates and divergence time, with applications to the divergence of Drosophila pseudoobscura and D. persimilis. Genetics. 2004, 167 (2): 747-760. 10.1534/genetics.103.024182.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Grant WS, Utter FM: Biochemical population genetics of Pacific herring (Clupea pallasi). Can J Fish Aquat Sci. 1984, 41 (6): 856-864. 10.1139/f84-102.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hay DE, Rose KA, Schweigert J, Megrey BA: Geographic variation in North Pacific herring populations: Pan-Pacific comparisons and implications for climate change impacts. Prog Oceanogr. 2008, 77 (2–3): 233-240.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Teacher AGF, André C, Merilä J, Wheat CW: Whole mitochondrial genome scan for population structure and selection in the Atlantic herring. BMC Evol Biol. 2012, 12: 2481-View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Vermeij GJ: From Europe to America: Pliocene to recent trans-Atlantic expansion of cold-water North Atlantic molluscs. Proc R Soc B. 2005, 272 (1580): 2545-2550. 10.1098/rspb.2005.3177.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wares JP, Cunningham CW: Phylogeography and historical ecology of the North Atlantic intertidal. Evolution. 2001, 55 (12): 2455-2469.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bigg GR, Cunningham CW, Ottersen G, Pogson GH, Wadley MR, Williamson P: Ice-age survival of Atlantic cod: agreement between palaeoecology models and genetics. Proc R Soc B. 2008, 275 (1631): 163-172. 10.1098/rspb.2007.1153.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Arnason E: Mitochondrial cytochrome b DNA variation in the high-fecundity Atlantic cod: trans-Atlantic clines and shallow gene genealogy. Genetics. 2004, 166 (4): 1871-1885. 10.1534/genetics.166.4.1871.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Slatkin M, Hudson RR: Pairwise comparisons of mitochondrial-DNA sequences in stable and exponentially growing populations. Genetics. 1991, 129 (2): 555-562.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hu A, Meehl GA, Han W, Timmermann A, Otto-Bliesner B, Liu Z, Washington WM, Large W, Abe-Ouchi A, Kimoto M: Role of the Bering Strait on the hysteresis of the ocean conveyor belt circulation and glacial climate stability. P Natl Acad Sci USA. 2012, 109 (17): 6417-6422. 10.1073/pnas.1116014109.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Harris SA: Thermal history of the Arctic Ocean environs adjacent to North America during the last 3.5 Ma and a possible mechanism for the cause of the cold events (major glaciations and permafrost events). Prog Phys Geog. 2005, 29 (2): 218-237. 10.1191/0309133305pp444ra.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Renssen H, Seppä H, Crosta X, Goosse H, Roche DM: Global characterization of the holocene thermal maximum. Quaternary Sci Rev. 2012, 48: 7-19.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jones EP: Circulation in the Arctic Ocean. Polar Res. 2001, 20 (2): 139-146. 10.1111/j.1751-8369.2001.tb00049.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Whitehead PJP, Nelson GJ, Wongratana T: FAO species catalogue. Clupeoid fishes of the world (suborder Clupeoidei). FAO Fisheries Synopsis 7. 1985, Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United NationsGoogle Scholar
- Novikov GG, Karpov AK, Andreeva AP, Semenova AV: Herring of the White Sea. Herring: Expectations for a New Millennium. Edited by: Funk F, Balckburn J, Hay D, Paul AJ, Stephenson R, Toresen R, Witherell D. 2001, Fairbanks, Alaska: University of Alaska Sea Grant College Program, 591-597.Google Scholar
- Kjørsvik EL, Lurås IJ, Hopkins CCE, Nilssen EM: On the intertidal spawning of Balsfjord herring (Clupea harengus L.). ICES CM. 1990, H:30-Google Scholar
- Jørstad KE, Dahle G, Paulsen OI: Genetic comparison between Pacific herring (Clupea pallasi) and a Norwegian fjord stock of Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus). Can J Fish Aquat Sci. 1994, 51: 233-239. 10.1139/f94-309.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Svetovidov AN: Treskoobraznye (Gadidae). Fauna SSSR. Ryby 9(4). 1948, Moscow and Leningrad: Zoologicheskii Institut Akademiya Nauk SSSRGoogle Scholar
- Coulson MW, Marshall HD, Pepin P, Carr SM: Mitochondrial genomics of gadine fishes: implications for taxonomy and biogeographic origins from whole-genome data sets. Genome. 2006, 49 (9): 1115-1130. 10.1139/g06-083.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ursvik A, Breines R, Christiansen JS, Fevolden S-E, Coucheron DH, Johansen SD: A mitogenomic approach to the taxonomy of pollocks: Theragra chalcogramma and T. finnmarchica represent one single species. BMC Evol Biol. 2007, 7: 86-10.1186/1471-2148-7-86.PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Strelkov P, Nikula R, Väinölä R: Macoma balthica in the White and Barents Seas: properties of a widespread marine hybrid swarm (Mollusca: Bivalvia). Mol Ecol. 2007, 16 (19): 4110-4127. 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2007.03463.x.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.