- Research article
- Open Access
A new Late Devonian genus with seed plant affinities
© Wang and Liu; licensee BioMed Central. 2015
- Received: 13 August 2014
- Accepted: 16 January 2015
- Published: 26 February 2015
Many ovules of Late Devonian (Famennian) seed plants have been well studied. However, because few taxa occur with anatomically preserved stems and/or petioles, the vascular system of these earliest spermatophytes is little understood and available data come mostly from Euramerica. There remains great controversy over the anatomical differentiation of Late Devonian and Carboniferous seed plant groups of Buteoxylonales, Calamopityales and Lyginopteridales. Protostele evolution of these early spermatophytes needs more research.
A new taxon Yiduxylon trilobum gen. et sp. nov. with seed plant affinities has been discovered in the Upper Devonian (Famennian) Tizikou Formation of Hubei Province, China. It is represented by stems, helically arranged and bifurcate fronds with two orders of pinnae and planate pinnules. Both secondary pinnae and pinnules are borne alternately. Stems contain a small protostele with three primary xylem ribs possessing a single peripheral protoxylem strand. Thick secondary xylem displays multiseriate bordered pitting on the tangential and radial walls of the tracheids, and has biseriate to multiseriate and high rays. A narrow cortex consists of inner cortex without sclerotic nests and sparganum-type outer cortex with peripheral bands of vertically aligned sclerenchyma cells. Two leaf traces successively arise tangentially from each primary xylem rib and they divide once to produce four circular-oval traces in the stem cortex. Four vascular bundles occur in two C-shaped groups at each petiole base with ground tissue and peripheral bands of sclerenchyma cells.
Yiduxylon justifies the assignment to a new genus mainly because of the protostele with protoxylem strands only near the periphery of primary xylem ribs, leaf trace origination and petiolar vascular supply structure. It shares many definitive characters with Calamopityales and Lyginopteridales, further underscoring the anatomical similarities among early seed plants. The primary vascular system, pycnoxylic-manoxylic secondary xylem with bordered pits on both tangential and radial walls of a tracheid and leaf trace divergence of Yiduxylon suggest transitional features between the early spermatophytes and ancestral aneurophyte progymnosperms.
- Early seed plant
- Late devonian
- Leaf trace
- Tizikou formation
- Yiduxylon trilobum
Seed plants (spermatophytes) began to diversify in the Famennian (374–359 million years ago) of the Late Devonian and many fossils have been documented since the Carboniferous . Till now, about twenty Famennian genera with ovules and/or pollen organs have been studied in detail . Most of these earliest seed plants were collected from Laurussia (Europe and North America) and only two genera from China, i.e., Kongshania  and Cosmosperma . However, few plants have been recognized on the basis of stem and/or petiole anatomy. In contrast, there are more than forty Early Carboniferous stem morphotaxa throughout Euramerica . Such taxa may be the primary line of evidence for phylogenetic analyses of early spermatophytes .
Famennian seed plants known for their stem vascular system include Buteoxylon , Kerryoxylon , Laceya [8,9], Tristichia  and cf. Tetrastichia bupatides  from Ireland, and Elkinsia from USA . They are (tentatively) attributed to the Buteoxylonales (Buteoxylon), Elkinsiales (Elkinsia) and Lyginopteridales (Kerryoxylon, Laceya, Tristichia and Tetrastichia). Anatomically preserved spermatophytes from the New Albany Shale of USA have raised great controversy over their Latest Devonian or earliest Carboniferous age [11-19].
Buteoxylonales, Calamopityales and Lyginopteridales (or Buteoxylonaceae, Calamopityaceae and Lyginopteridaceae) are represented by numerous stem morphotaxa and/or fertile organs from the Late Devonian and especially Carboniferous. However, as noted by many workers such as [4,20], the definition and relationship of these three orders need reinterpretation because of shared characters and the lack of whole plant knowledge. These early spermatophytes have been interpreted as lianas or upright plants [20,21], and their possession of sclerotic nests in the stem inner cortex has been interpreted as a response to insect infections [15,20]. The derivation of the early spermatophyte eustele from protostele has been widely accepted [1,22,23], but the evolution of the spermatophyte protostele from the ancestral aneurophyte progymnosperm protostele is poorly understood.
South China was an isolated plate in the Late Devonian and showed great diversification of many plant lineages excluding seed plants. This paper now reports a new genus with seed plant affinities, Yiduxylon trilobum gen. et sp. nov., having both vegetative morphology and stelar structure including petiolar vascular supply preserved from the Upper Devonian (Famennian) Tizikou Formation of Hubei Province, South China. The age of this formation is determined mainly by the stratigraphic sequence and comparisons of the spore assemblages. Based on morphological and anatomical studies of stem/frond as well as on detailed comparisons, this paper discusses the taxonomy and growth habit of Yiduxylon, and the evolution of seed plant protostelic architecture during the Late Devonian and earliest Carboniferous. The stelar feature and leaf trace production of Yiduxylon indicate transitional anatomical traits in the evolution of the seed plants from the Middle to Late Devonian aneurophytes, although the latter group is currently unknown in South China.
Fossils were collected from the Upper Devonian Xiejingsi (Hsiehchingssu) Formation sensu lato, on a hill named Tizikou, which is to the south of Maohutang village, Wangjiafan Town, Yidu City, western Hubei Province, China. In the Three Gorges area of the Yangtze River including western Hubei, the Upper Devonian strata are referred to the Huangjiadeng Formation and overlying Xiejingsi Formation sensu lato (see summary in ). The latter formation includes the Frasnian-Famennian Xiejingsi Formation sensu stricto, Famennian Tizikou Formation and Changyang Formation in ascending order . The Changyang Formation containing marine invertebrates is Famennian [25,26] or Lower Carboniferous (basal Tournaisian) [27,28]. The present plant occurs together with a lycopsid Sublepidodendron songziense. The latter species has been discovered and studied in detail from the Famennian Tizikou Formation of Songzi City, western Hubei and from the Famennian Wutong (Wutung) Formation of Chaohu City, Anhui Province [24,29]. Miospore assemblages indicate that the Tizikou Formation in western Hubei and northwestern Hunan is similar in age to the Famennian (Fa2d-Tn1a) Xikuangshan Formation (upper part) and Shaodong Formation (lower part) in central Hunan, the Zhewang Formation and Gelaohe Formation (lower part) in southeastern Guizhou, Wutong Formation (upper part: Leigutai Member) in the lower reaches of the Yangtze River, and the Wangjiadian Formation in southern Gansu [30-33]. Some spores in the PN assemblage, e.g., Vallatisporites pusillites, Aneurospora greggsii and Rugospora flexuosa occur only in Famennian deposits . These data suggest that the Tizikou Formation is middle to late Famennian but not latest Famennian.
At the Tizikou section, the Tizikou Formation is about 20 m thick and characterized by black-gray mudstone and siltstone, and gray or gray-white fine sandstone . There are some lycopsids and the sphenopsids Hamatophyton verticillatum and H. yiduense in the mid-lower part of this formation . H. verticillatum and H. yiduense have been emended as Rotafolia songziensis , which was later anatomically studied . Near the horizon of R. songziensis, Yiduxylon trilobum gen. et sp. nov. occurs as impressions and compressions in black-gray silty mudstone.
The poorly preserved stems, branches and leaves show little contrast with the rock matrix. Under a microscope, clastic material was removed by steel needles to expose the plant morphology. Coalified material of Yiduxylon trilobum has been well preserved, which was embedded, sectioned and ground to show the anatomy. Altogether nine stems were transversely sectioned to produce 62 slides, and six stems were longitudinally sectioned to produce 16 slides. These sections were observed with light microscope (LM). Some stems were examined with a scanning electron microscope (SEM).
We have not carried out our field works in private areas, since in China all the land belongs to the country. And we have not caused any destruction to National Nature Reserves during fossil excavation. All the fossil collecting works have been done obeying the Chinese fossil collection and mining laws, and have been allowed by local government.
The part and counterpart of a specimen display an axis with lateral branches bearing planate pinnules (Figure 1c, d, Additional file 1: Figure S1a, b). This axis is about 85 mm long and 4.8-5.2 mm in diameter, and possesses longitudinal ridges (Figure 1d, arrow, e). The diameter and striations suggest that this axis may represent the upper part of a frond rachis after initial bifurcation. In this case, there are two orders of pinnae within the frond. Since plant shows little contrast with the rock matrix, the configuration of the pinnules is very difficult to recognize. However, narrow longitudinal ridges are visible on the rachises of the primary pinnae. The rachises of two primary pinnae are 1.8-2.6 mm in diameter, and attached separately at 70° and 30° to the frond rachis. One primary pinna is only basally preserved, whereas another is 76 mm long and bears four secondary pinnae. The rachises of secondary pinnae, up to 60 mm long and 0.8-1.3 mm in width, are alternately arranged. Except for the basal one, the other three secondary pinnae depart at about 90°. The distance between the attachment of two neighboring secondary pinnae is 16–21 mm. Nonlaminate pinnules are borne at 45-90° and alternately on the secondary pinna rachis, and are planate and highly dissected. A pinna rachis possesses at least seven pinnules. The distance between two adjacent pinnules is 4.6-13 mm. Pinnules are up to 21.7 mm long and about 19.4 mm wide. Each pinnule unequally dichotomizes to produce four or more units. These units, which are up to 11 mm long and about 12 mm wide, arise at 20-90°, and divide unequally twice or thrice to form narrow segments which are 0.5-1.2 mm wide (Figure 1f, Additional file 1: Figure S1).
Arising close to the stelar center, the secondary xylem extends outward up to a distance of 2.7 mm (Figure 2a, b, Additional file 2: Figure S2a-d). In transverse section, the secondary xylem tracheids are of various shapes (circular, oval, square, rectangular and irregular) as in the metaxylem tracheids, and are 12–75 μm in diameter and arranged in radial files. Multiseriate pits of circular and oval shape occur on both tangential (Figure 4c, e) and radial (Figure 4d, f-i) walls of secondary xylem tracheids. These pits are bordered (Figure 4j, k) and 3.0-13 μm in diameter. Rays occur between every two to about ten rows of secondary xylem tracheids (Figures 2a, b, 3a, g and 4e). Rays are usually 2 and sometimes up to 6 cells wide (Figure 4e, Additional file 3: Figure S3a, arrow), and more than 120 cells high (Figure 4e, f). Ray parenchyma cells are 65–128 μm in radial and 10–32 μm in tangential dimensions, and 22–48 μm high (Figures 3a and 4d, arrow, e-i).
The cortex sometimes appears to have been compressed to present a wing-like outline (Figure 2b, Additional file 2: Figure S2a, b). It is 0.8-1.1 mm thick (Figure 2b, Additional file 2: Figure S2a-d) and lacks sclerotic nests (Figure 3b, c). The inner cortex consists of circular and oval parenchyma cells which are 25–160 μm in diameter. Longitudinal sections show that these cells are up to 180 μm high (Figure 4a, b). Sparganum-type outer cortex contains many radial bands of sclerenchyma cells with thick walls (Figures 2a, b and 3b, c, g). These bands at the periphery of the cortex are 300–700 μm in radial and 100–520 μm in tangential dimensions, and the circular to square sclerenchyma cells range from 14–68 μm in diameter. In longitudinal sections, the sclerenchyma cells are continuous, up to 1.0 mm high and do not anastomose (Figure 4a, lowermost arrow, b, arrow). Intervening parenchyma cells are tangentially elongate between two adjacent bands with intervals of 130–270 μm.
Individual leaf traces are circular and slightly oval in outline, and their diameter is 0.3-0.4 mm near the tip of the primary xylem rib (Additional file 2: Figure S2i, k and Additional file 5: Figure S5d), but becomes 0.4-0.5 mm in the secondary xylem (Additional file 2: Figure S2c, right arrow, d, lower arrow, h, j and S5a-f), and reaches 0.3-0.7 mm in the inner cortex of the stem (Figures 2a, arrows 1–4, b, arrows 1–3, c-f and 3d-f, g, arrows, h-k, Additional file 2: Figure S2a, arrow, c, left arrow, d, upper arrow, e-g). The tracheids of the leaf traces are up to 56 μm in diameter.
Serial transverse sections of a stem indicate that each rib of the primary xylem successively initiates two leaf traces. The first trace is located at the periphery of the inner cortex (Additional file 2: Figure S2a, arrow, e and Additional file 6: Figure S6h). The tip of a xylem rib obliquely and radially expands to form a protoxylem strand representing the incipience of another leaf trace (Additional file 3: Figure S3a, arrow 3, b, d, right arrow). Then, this trace appears to tangentially diverge from the rib tip (Additional file 2: Figure S2i) and afterwards becomes detached within the secondary xylem (Additional file 2: Figure S2c, right arrow, h and Additional file 6: Figure S6i). More distally, a leaf trace diverges from the tip of another rib with protoxylem strand (Additional file 2: Figure S2k, arrow) and is then surrounded by the secondary xylem (Additional file 2: Figure S2d, lower arrow, j). This trace contains two protoxylem strands (Additional file 2: Figure S2j, arrows, k). Another trace thought to depart from the same rib tip is however invisible. It is suggested that two traces may subsequently diverge from the tip of the third rib, thus indicating a 1/3 phyllotaxy.
Serial transverse sections of another stem clearly show the successive origination of two leaf traces. One trace in the secondary xylem has been tangentially produced from a tip of the primary xylem rib (Additional file 5: Figure S5a and Additional file 6: Figure S6a), then gradually moves toward (Additional file 5: Figure S5b, c and Additional file 6: Figure S6b, c) and reaches the periphery of the inner cortex (Additional file 5: Figure S5d-g and Additional file 6: Figure S6d-g). Here (Additional file 5: Figure S5g, arrow) the trace with two protoxylem strands is tangentially elongate (Additional file 5: Figure S5i, arrows), thus indicating further division. The same rib tip obliquely and radially expands to produce a protoxylem strand representing the incipience of another trace (Additional file 5: Figure S5a-c and Additional file 6: S6a-c), which radially diverges, then passes through the secondary xylem (Additional file 5: Figure S5d-f and Additional file 6: Figure S6d-f) and reaches the inner cortex (Additional file 5: Figure S5g and Additional file 6: S6g). Because of the irregular configuration of ribbed primary xylem, the apparent radial emission of this leaf trace may result from preservation and distortion of the specimen due to compression. This trace in the secondary xylem (Additional file 5: Figure S5f, arrow) displays one protoxylem strand (Additional file 5: Figure S5h, arrow).
In the inner cortex of one stem, two leaf traces derived from a primary xylem rib begin to tangentially divide once (Figure 3g, arrows). The subsequent gradual divisions result in four traces (Figure 3h-k). Four leaf traces from a primary xylem rib occur in the inner cortex of the second stem (Figure 2a, arrows 1–3, c-e), with two traces having just tangentially separated (Figure 2a, arrow 1, c). Four leaf traces from a primary xylem rib are present in the inner cortex of the third stem (Figures 2b, arrows 1–3 and 3d-f), with two traces beginning to separate (Figures 2b, arrow 1 and 3d). Leaf traces in the cortex of these three stems have mesarch primary xylem (two protoxylem strands, see Figures 2f and 3e, k, Additional file 2: Figure S2e).
Frond base with trace
? Class Spermatopsida
Order Incertae sedis
Genus Yiduxylon Wang et Liu gen. nov.
Stems with fronds borne helically in a 1/3 phyllotaxy. Frond rachises bifurcate proximally. Two orders of pinnae with alternately arranged secondary pinna rachises bearing alternate pinnules which are planate and highly dissected. Stems protostelic with small three-ribbed primary xylem, broad secondary xylem, and narrow cortex. Primary xylem mesarch with each rib possessing a single peripheral protoxylem strand. Secondary xylem intermediate between manoxylic and pycnoxylic types. Multiseriate bordered pits on tangential and radial walls of secondary xylem tracheids. Rays usually biseriate and very high. Cortex consisting of an outer sparganum zone and an inner parenchymatous ground tissue. Two leaf traces successively derived tangentially from tip of each primary xylem rib and once divided to produce four traces in stem cortex. Leaf traces possessing mesarch primary xylem. Petiole base containing vascular supply of four bundles in two C-shaped groups (each group with concave surface facing stem center and protoxylem strands on abaxial surface), peripheral and parallel bands of sclerenchyma cells, and ground tissue of parenchyma cells.
Type species Yiduxylon trilobum Wang et Liu sp. nov.
As in generic diagnosis. Stems 7.2-20 mm in diameter and attached by fronds at 45-60°. Frond rachises 5.2-10 mm and 4.8-6.3 mm in diameter before and after proximal bifurcation at about 60°, respectively. Narrow and longitudinally parallel superficial ridges and grooves alternating on stems and rachises of fronds and primary pinnae. Primary pinna rachises 1.8-2.6 mm in diameter. Secondary pinna borne at about 90°, with rachises 0.8-1.3 mm in diameter, and bearing pinnules at 45-90°. Pinnules up to 21.7 mm long and about 19.4 mm wide, with each unequally dividing into four or more units that are anisotomous twice or thrice. Ratio of primary xylem diameter to stem diameter 1/5. Stem primary xylem 1.8-2.0 mm in diameter, with three undivided ribs varying in length and becoming narrower towards stelar center. Secondary xylem up to 5.2 mm thick. Rays 2–6 cells wide and more than 120 cells high. Cortex 0.8-1.1 mm thick and inner cortex lacking sclerotic clusters. Individual leaf traces circular or slightly oval with two protoxylem strands. At petiole base, each C-shaped group of two vascular bundles asymmetrical with inner bundle tending to divide into three portions.
Holotype designated here
Paratypes designated here
Specimens PKUB14401 (Figure 1a), PKUB14403 (Figure 1b), PKUB14402a (Figure 1c), PKUB14402b (Figure 1d, e); Slides HBY-04 (Additional file 2: Figure S2c, f, h), HY3-4 (Figures 2b, 3d-f, Additional file 3: Figure S3g), HY9-2 (Figure 4e), 4–6 (Figure 5b, d-f).
Generic name from Yidu (where the plant was discovered) and the Greek xylon (xylem). Specific epithet from the Greek treis (tri) and lobos (lobes), meaning three-lobed shape of stem primary vascular system in transverse section.
Locality and horizon
Tizikou, Maohutang village, Wangjiafan Town, Yidu City, Hubei Province, China; Upper Devonian (Famennian) Tizikou Formation.
All specimens and slides are housed in the Department of Geology, Peking University, Beijing, China.
Although the aneurophyte progymnosperms possess protostele with ribbed primary xylem of mesarch maturation, and secondary xylem with bordered pits on all walls of tracheids , they are distinct from Yiduxylon mainly in the geological age, other stelar architectures and vegetative morphology. Aneurophytes existed in the Middle Devonian-Late Devonian (Frasnian) and was characterized by protoxylem strands near the tips and along the midplanes of the primary xylem ribs and in the stelar center, pycnoxylic secondary xylem and radial divergence of branch traces [1,36,37]. Furthermore, except for Triloboxylon ashlandicum and Proteokalon petryi [38,39], the aneurophytes lack planation of the lateral axes (alternate or opposite arrangement) and vegetative ultimate appendages (planate leaves); a decussate pattern occurs in Tetraxylopteris with most orders of branches containing a four-ribbed primary vascular system . Protoxylem strands along the midplanes of the rib of the Aneurophytes and Stenokoleales usually accompany and probably have been derived from a single strand at the stelar center [36,40,41]. Concerning Yiduxylon, the primary xylem is poorly preserved, but many sections indicate the absence of protoxylem strands along stelar ribs and two sections perhaps lack a central protoxylem strand (Additional file 4: Figure S4a, b). The secondary xylem is intermediate between pycnoxylic and manoxylic type (see below). Two leaf traces depart successively from the tip of a stem xylem rib (Additional file 6: Figure S6). One trace diverges and extends up at the boundary between secondary xylem and cortex, and then another trace is initiated. Two leaf traces probably divide tangentially from the rib tip.
Stenokoleales of the Middle Devonian to Early Carboniferous represents a distinct order within the “radiate protoxylem” group comprising plants such as aneurophytes and some early spermatophytes . This order may have a close affinity with the seed plants . Stenokoleales includes Stenokoleos and Crossia known only from anatomy [41,42] and is characterized by a three-ribbed protostele with a single protoxylem strand at the stelar center and numerous protoxylem strands along the midplanes of the primary xylem ribs. Secondary xylem is sometimes present but only in small amounts. In Stenokoleos, successive pairs of traces are produced from the opposite xylem ribs of stem, suggesting that paired fronds are borne alternately . As to Crossia, three stelar ribs of the lower orders of axes divide to form six ribs where branch traces are emitted in pairs . However, Yiduxylon has protoxylem strands restricted near the periphery of three xylem ribs of stem, large amounts of secondary xylem, two leaf traces successively arising from a xylem rib, and helically arranged petioles.
The stem steles of early seed plants (Late Devonian to Carboniferous Buteoxylonales, Calamopityales and Lyginopteridales of seed ferns) may be divided into three types, i.e. ribbed protostele or actinostele, parenchymatized protostele and eustele with pith . Yiduxylon with protostele differs from the spermatophytes with parenchymatized protosteles, e.g., Buteoxylon , Galtiera , Heterangium [45,46], Rhetinangium [47-49], Schopfiastrum , Microspermopteris [51,52], some species of Calamopitys, e.g., C. saturni and C. annularis , and most species of Stenomyelon, e.g., S. muratum , S. bifasciculare , S. tuedianum [55,56]. Yiduxylon also differs from those with eusteles, e.g., Diichnia [11,12,16], Faironia , Lyginopitys , Lyginopteris , Trivena , Triichnia , and some species of Calamopitys, e.g., C. solmsii .
The spermatophytes with ribbed protosteles include Bostonia [60,61], Elkinsia , Kerryoxylon , Laceya [8,9], Stenomyelon primaevum [55,56], Tetrastichia [7,62,63], Triradioxylon , and Tristichia [7,65,66]. However, Tetrastichia and Kerryoxylon differ from Yiduxylon in having four- and six-ribbed primary xylem, respectively. The primary xylem of Tetrastichia is sometimes three- or five-ribbed, and a single protoxylem strand is present near the stelar center, or along the midplane of each primary xylem rib; the phyllotaxy of fronds is opposite decussate, 1/3 and 2/5. Leaf traces of Kerryoxylon are three-ribbed in the stem cortex.
Yiduxylon resembles Bostonia, Elkinsia, Laceya, Stenomyelon primaevum, Triradioxylon and Tristichia in the protosteles with three primary xylem ribs possessing peripheral protoxylem strands. Nevertheless, Yiduxylon is characterized by two leaf traces successively derived in tangential pattern from a single rib of stem primary xylem. Specifically, the primary xylem of Bostonia comprises three semi-discrete portions and a central portion; the protoxylem strands occur also in the stelar center; neither xylem ribs nor peripheral protoxylem strands are longitudinally continuous; the vascular supply of petioles is three-ribbed and derived from a pair of leaf traces . Protoxylem strands of Elkinsia are located also in the stelar center and sometimes along the midplane of xylem ribs; the peripheral protoxylem strand diverges into different numbers and shapes of leaf traces (one papillionoid, one C-shaped, two bilobed, four elliptical ones), although the frond rachis is vascularized by two C-shaped bundles . The leaf trace initiation of Laceya is caused by repeated divisions of primary xylem rib resulting in a tip with 6–8 united lobes; the U-shaped leaf trace remains undivided and its abaxial surface shows 6–8 protoxylem strands ; vascular supply at the petiole base is a U-/V-shaped bundle with 8–12 protoxylem strands on the convex abaxial surface . The primary xylem of Stenomyelon primaevum is separated from the secondary xylem by parenchymatous cells; protoxylem strands occur along the midplanes of xylem ribs and are often associated with a lacuna; pits appear only on radial walls of secondary xylem tracheids; there are eight vascular bundles in each petiole base . One or more protoxylem strands are also located in the stelar center of Triradioxylon, and the leaf traces are undivided and the vascular supply in the petiole is T-shaped . Concerning Tristichia, protoxylem strands sometimes occur also in the stelar center and along the xylem ribs, and the leaf traces are tetrarch and papillionoid . Sclerotic nests characteristic of the inner cortex of Elkinsia, Triradioxylon and Tristichia are absent in Yiduxylon.
As in Yiduxylon, the pinnae and pinnules of Late Devonian Kongshania  are alternately arranged. In contrast, the pinnules of Kongshania are laminate and wedge-tongue shaped; the poorly preserved frond rachis in description and diagram consists mainly of two bean-shaped vascular bundles surrounded by secondary xylem, which are however difficult to see in the photographs.
It is widely agreed that the seed plants originated from the aneurophyte progymnosperms . As Galtier  summarized, the early spermatophytes are characterized by both primitive aneurophyte and derived morphological and anatomical features. Primitive anatomical features include the protostelic primary vascular system, secondary xylem/phloem produced by a bifacial cambium, multiseriate and elliptical bordered pitting of tracheids, and outer cortex with longitudinally oriented plates of sclerenchyma cells. Derived features refer to such as bipartite fronds with dichotomous rachis, dorsiventral (adaxial/abaxial) identity of petioles, nonlaminate to entire pinnules, loss of protoxylem strands in stelar center, pits restricted to the radial walls of secondary xylem tracheids, and tangential divergence of leaf traces. In addition, the early seed plants often have their fronds borne helically on the stem . Yiduxylon possesses these characteristic vegetative morphology and stelar architecture except for unknown secondary phloem. Manoxylic secondary xylem is another important feature of the early seed plants but it is difficult to define  or may be described as having large tracheids (more than 150 μm in diameter) and rays (over 5 cells wide and up to 200 cells high), which contrasts to pycnoxylic woods with small tracheids (less than 50 μm in diameter) and rays (uniseriate and short) [68,69]. In this case, the size of secondary xylem tracheids (12–75 μm in diameter) and rays (2–6 cells wide and more than 120 cells high) of Yiduxylon is intermediate between pycnoxylic and manoxylic wood anatomy.
The Buteoxylonales has only two genera, i.e., Early Carboniferous Buteoxylon  and Triradioxylon , with the former also reported from the Latest Devonian . Calamopityales diversified in the Early Carboniferous and Lyginopteridales in the Carboniferous, but they (probably) occurred in the Late Devonian [1,20]. As noted by many workers [4,15,20,37,67], the Calamopityales and Lyginopteridales are difficult to define in that they share many characters such as helical phyllotaxis, protostele to eustele, cortex with sclerotic clusters and sclerenchyma cells (sparganum and dictyoxylon type). Their differentiation may depend on a combination of morphological (e.g., adventitious roots) and anatomical characters such as the ratio of primary vasculature diameter to stem diameter, leaf trace origination and vascular supply of frond rachises. Among them, the type of petiole vascular supply is crucial to define the Calamopityales and Lyginopteridales , although this character has been questioned (especially when it is independently used) because of considerable overlap of petiole morphology between the two orders [4,15,20].
According to Galtier  and Dunn et al. , adventitious roots are generally absent in the Calamopityales, the ratio of primary vasculature diameter to stem diameter is 1/5-1/10, the leaf trace origination involves multiple divisions and sometimes is double, the petiole is Kalymma type with four or more vascular bundles in the base of a frond rachis (multifascicular petiole), the total volume of these bundles exceeds the volume of cauline primary vasculature at the same level. The cortex of the calamopityaleans has been emphasized as remarkably broad [1,70]. In contrast, the Lyginopteridales is characterized by adventitious roots, the ratio of primary vasculature diameter to stem diameter is 1/2-1/4, the leaf trace usually remains undivided to produce a single petiolar vascular supply with several protoxylem strands, or it divides once into two closely associated bundles of U-, or V-, or W-shape (Lyginorachis-type petiole), the volume of the petiolar vascular supply never exceeds the stelar volume. There are however some exceptions to the characters of Lyginopteridales. For example, Laceya probably has no adventitious roots  and Heterangium may possess Kalymma-type petioles .
Yiduxylon cannot be assigned to the Buteoxylonales with their undivided leaf trace and T-shaped petiolar vascular supply. It differs from the Elkinsiales represented by Elkinsia mainly in the stelar architecture and leaf trace number/configurations (see Comparisons). Yiduxylon lacks adventitious roots, has a ratio of stelar diameter to stem diameter of 1/5, double leaf traces in origin, four leaf traces in the inner cortex, and a multifascicular petiole base with four discrete bundles that tend to further divide and exceed the volume of stem primary vasculature. These characters suggest anatomical similarities with the Calamopityales. However, the ratio of 1/5 is not a very low value and it results mainly from the small primary xylem and thick secondary xylem (i.e., the cortex is thin). Individual leaf traces are undivided in the cauline secondary tissue. Furthermore, as in some lyginopteridaleans, the four petiolar bundles of Yiduxylon are in two C-shaped traces that possess protoxylem strands on the abaxial surface. The origin of the leaf traces is unique because the two traces were produced from a stem primary xylem rib at different stages. Yiduxylon further exemplifies the anatomical similarities among early seed plants and indicates that their taxonomy depends primarily on fertile organs with attachment or association of stem/frond anatomy.
Stems of the Lyginopteridales and Calamopityales are generally less and more than 20 mm in diameter, respectively . As summarized by Dunn et al. , due to the presence of adventitious roots, narrow stems and large fronds, the lyginopteridaleans are probably more similar to lianas or vines and possess a scrambling or climbing habit; the calamopityaleans lacking adventitious roots are considered to be primarily upright plants. In addition, the wide angle of attachment of the fronds and Dictyoxylon-type outer cortex of the lyginopteridaleans are thought to be adaptations to the liana habit . Adventitious roots are absent in the specimens and stem sections of Yiduxylon, the outer cortex is Sparganum-type, and the angle of frond attachment is not so wide, whereas the stem diameter is generally less than 20 mm and the complex fronds consist of two orders of long pinnae with many large pinnules. Therefore, it is difficult to decide the growth habit of Yiduxylon, although it appears to have had an upright stem. Future biomechanical analyses such as those by Masselter et al.  may provide more accurate information on this subject.
Evolution of vegetative organs and protostele in seed plants
The aneurophyte progymnosperms of Middle to Late Devonian (Givetian-Frasnian) were widespread on the Laurussia continent and Gondwana continents. As the descendant of the aneurophytes, the spermatophytes were widespread in the Late Devonian (Famennian) of Laurussia. However, surprisingly, the aneurophytes have not been reported from South China [72,73]. There are now three genera of seed plants known from the Famennian of China or eastern Asia, i.e., Cosmosperma , Kongshania  and Yiduxylon (this paper). In Yiduxylon, the secondary pinnae and highly dissected pinnules are borne alternately. These vegetative characters support the hypothesis that Late Devonian seed plants generally possess pinnae in one plane and planate rather than laminate pinnules, in contrast to the three-dimensional branches and vegetative ultimate appendages of the aneurophytes .
Various stelar configurations occur in the early seed plants, ranging from simple protostele to eustele with sympodia and pith. The eustele is suggested to have evolved from the protostele (e.g., Stenomyelon primaevum) by gradual loss of the tracheidal tissue in the center of protostele; the transitional stelar form refers to parenchymatized protostele (e.g., Stenomyelon tuedianum and some species of Calamopitys), in which the stele has both parenchyma cells and tracheids [1,22,23,74]. Parenchymatized protostele and eustele were widespread in the Carboniferous Buteoxylonales, Calamopityales and Lyginopteridales.
Except for Buteoxylon gordonianum , where the stem primary vascular system with pith is unclear in detail, Late Devonian (Famennian) spermatophytes are primitive in having a protostele with three to six ribs. These plants are Elkinsia polymorpha , Kerryoxylon hexalobatum , Laceya hibernica [8,9], Tristichia sp. , cf. Tetrastichia bupatides  and Yiduxylon trilobum (this paper). Among them, Elkinsia polymorpha possesses a three-ribbed primary xylem with a single central protoxylem strand producing other strands along the ribs, which is very similar to the condition of the ancestral aneurophytes. Its frond rachises contain a Lyginorachis-like trace with abaxial protoxylem strands, which characterizes the early spermatophytes. This combination of stelar and petiolar architectures indicates the close evolutionary relationship between the aneurophytes and spermatophytes . Therefore, middle Famennian Elkinsia with its protostele is more primitive than other Famennian taxa. In the Latest Devonian seed plants from Ireland, the protoxylem strand occurs in/near the stelar center of Tristichia sp. and cf. Tetrastichia bupatides, or along the midplane of stelar ribs of Laceya hibernica, or only at the periphery of xylem rib of Kerryoxylon hexalobatum. Yiduxylon is probably younger than Elkinsia but older than the Irish taxa. If Yiduxylon had only peripheral protoxylem strands, it suggests that the protostele of early seed plants may have lost the protoxylem strands in the stelar center and along the stelar ribs by the Famennian. Ribbed protostele extends to the earliest Carboniferous (late Tournaisian) Triradioxylon primaevum , species of Tristichia  and Bostonia perplexa  with central protoxylem strands, Stenomyelon primaevum [55,56] and Tetrastichia bupatides [62,63] without such strands.
It is commonly accepted that the origin of seed plants is closely related to the aneurophyte gymnosperms. Accordingly, Yiduxylon provides transitional anatomical evidence linking these two plant groups. However, as stated before in this paper, typical aneurophytes have not yet been recognized from South China and thus need to be sought after in the Middle Devonian (Givetian) flora of this block. Alternatively, the seed plants may be nested within earlier representatives, e.g., Celatheca beckii with fertile structures putatively resembling cupulate ovules or pollen organs, which occurs in the Lower Devonian (Pragian) Posongchong Formation, Yunnan Province in South China [76-78].
At present, most of the earliest seed plants have been discovered from the Late Devonian of the Laurussian continent. Other coeval spermatophyte taxa come from South China which was an isolated block near the equator during the Devonian [79,80]. The Late Devonian flora of South China is well known for other lineages of vascular plants including many cosmopolitan and/or endemic elements. These lineages include the lycopsids, preferns, sphenophyllalean sphenopsids and archaeopterid progymnosperms. The rare record of Famennian spermatophytes in China may be related to the palaeogeographic position, or palaeoclimatic influence, limited dispersal, or insufficient collection in the past.
Yiduxylon is the third genus of seed plants or a taxon closely related to seed plants to have been reported from the Late Devonian of China or East Asia. Yiduxylon provides evidence for stem/petiole anatomy in this period. Its vegetative organs support the hypothesis that Late Devonian spermatophytes had evolved planate pinnae and pinnules. Yiduxylon, probably upright in habit, differs from other early seed plants mainly in the stem protostele with three-ribbed primary xylem of mesarch maturation, successive divergence of two leaf traces in tangential pattern from a primary xylem rib, four leaf traces in the cortex, and a petiolar base with four vascular bundles in two C-shaped groups. The difficulty in differentiating stelar architecture of the early seed plants indicates that they are anatomically similar and their taxonomy depends largely on fertile organs. The stems of all Late Devonian and some of the earliest Carboniferous seed plants possessed a ribbed protostele, which lacks or contains a central protoxylem strand as a character of the ancestral aneurophyte progymnosperms. Protostelic architecture and leaf trace formation of Yiduxylon suggest transitional traits in the evolution of early seed plants from aneurophytes.
The authors thank Professor David K. Ferguson, University of Vienna, for important discussion, and Jia Qiuyue and Ni Debao, Peking University, Beijing, for laboratory assistance. This work is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 41172007) and the National Basic Research Program of China (2012CB821900) of the Ministry of Science and Technology of China.
- Taylor TN, Taylor EL, Krings M. Paleobotany: the biology and evolution of fossil plants. 2nd ed. Burlington: Academic Press; 2009.Google Scholar
- Wang DM, Liu L, Meng MC, Xue JZ, Liu T, Guo Y. Cosmosperma polyloba gen. et sp. nov., a seed plant from the Upper Devonian of South China. Naturwissenschaften. 2014;101:615–22.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wang Y. Kongshania gen. nov. A new plant from the Wutung Formation (Upper Devonian) of Jiangning County, Jiangsu, China. Acta Palaeontol Sin. 2000;39:42–56.Google Scholar
- Decombeix AL, Galtier J, Meyer-Berthaud B. Faironia difasciculata, a new gymnosperm from the Early Carboniferous (Mississippian) of Montagne Noire, France. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 2006;142:79–92.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dunn MT. A review of permineralized seed fern stems of the Upper Paleozoic. J Torrey Bot Soc. 2006;133:20–32.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Matten LC, Lacey WS, May BI, Lucas RC. A megafossil flora from the Uppermost Devonian near Ballyheigue, Co. Kerry, Ireland. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 1980;29:241–51.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Matten LC, Tanner WR, Lacey WS. Additions to the silicified Upper Devonian/Lower Carboniferous flora from Ballyheigue, Ireland. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 1984;43:303–20.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- May BI, Matten LC. A probable pteridosperm from the uppermost Devonian near Ballyheigue, Co. Kerry, Ireland. Bot J Linn Soc. 1983;86:103–23.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Klavins SD, Matten LC. Reconstruction of the frond of Laceya hibernica, a lyginopterid pteridosperm from the uppermost Devonian of Ireland. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 1996;93:253–68.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Serbet R, Rothwell GW. Characterizing the most primitive seed ferns. I. A reconstruction of Elkinsia polymorpha. Int J Plant Sci. 1992;153:602–21.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Read CB. A Devonian flora from Kentucky. J Paleontol. 1936;10:213–27.Google Scholar
- Read CB. The flora of the New Albany Shale. Part 1. Diichnia kentuckiensis, a new representative of the Calamopityeae. US Geol Surv Prof Pap. 1936;185H:149–55.Google Scholar
- Read CB, Campbell G. Preliminary account of the New Albany Shale flora. Amer Midl Nat. 1939;21:435–53.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beck CB, Bailey RE. Plants of the New Albany Shale. III: Chapelia campbellii gen. n. Amer J Bot. 1967;54:998–1007.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beck CB, Stein WE. Galtiera bostonensis, gen. et sp. nov., a protostelic calamopityacean from the New Albany shale of Kentucky. Can J Bot. 1987;65:348–61.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beck CB, Galtier J, Stein WE. A reinvestigation of Diichnia Read from the New Albany Shale of Kentucky. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 1992;75:1–32.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sebby WS, Matten LC. Kalymma minuta (Read) comb. nov. from the New Albany Shale. Bull Torrey Bot Club. 1969;96:79–88.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Scott AC, Galtier J, Clayton G. Distribution of anatomically-preserved floras in the Lower Carboniferous in Western Europe. Trans Roy Soc Edinb. 1984;75:311–40.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Masselter T, Rowe N, Galtier J, Speck T. Secondary growth and deformation of stem tissues in the Lower Carboniferous seed fern Calamopitys. Int J Plant Sci. 2009;170:1228–39.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dunn MT, Rothwell GW, Mapes G. On Paleozoic plants from marine strata: Trivena arkansana (Lyginopteridaceae) gen. et sp. nov., a lyginopterid from the Fayetteville Formation (middle Chesterian/Upper Mississippian) of Arkansas, USA. Amer J Bot. 2003;90:1239–52.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Masselter T, Rowe NP, Speck T. Biomechanical reconstruction of the Carboniferous seed fern Lyginopteris oldhamia: implications for growth form reconstruction and habit. Int J Plant Sci. 2007;168:1177–89.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Namboodiri KK, Beck CB. A comparative study of the primary vascular system of conifers. III. Stelar evolution in gymnosperms. Amer J Bot. 1968;55:464–72.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beck CB. The appearance of gymnospermous structure. Biol Rev. 1970;45:379–400.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wang Q, Hao SG, Wang DM, Wang Y, Denk T. A Late Devonian arborescent lycopsid Sublepidodendron songziense Chen emend. (Sublepidodendraceae Kräusel et Weyland 1949) from China, with a revision of the genus Sublepidodendron (Nathorst) Hirmer 1927. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 2003;127:269–305.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Zhang RJ, Feng SN, Duan QF. Devonian. In: Wang XF, Chen XH, Zhang RJ, editors. Protection of precise geological remains in the Yangtze gorges area, China with the study of the Archean-Mesozoic multiple stratigraphic subdivision and sea-level change. Beijing: Geological Publishing House; 2002. p. 131–72.Google Scholar
- Wu JH, Niu ZJ, Wang JX, Yao HZ, Zhang RJ. On the geological age of Changyang Formation, western Hubei Province. Sci Tech Eng. 2011;11:1411–5.Google Scholar
- Devonian system and plant kingdom. In Biostratigraphy of the Yangtze Gorge area. Volume 3. Late Paleozoic era. Edited by Institute of Geology and Mineral Resources of Yichang. Beijing: Geological Publishing House; 1984: 6–31, 293–317Google Scholar
- Tan L, Li X, Sun YL. On age of the Changyang Formation of western Hubei. J Stratigr. 2011;35:8–18.Google Scholar
- Meng MC, Wang DM, Tian T. New insights on the megasporangiate strobilus of Sublepidodendron songziense from the Late Devonian of Hubei Province. Acta Palaeontol Sin. 2014;53:180–90.Google Scholar
- Wang GX, Jing YJ, Zhuang JL, Zhang CF, Hu WQ. Stratigraphical system of Devonian-Lower Carboniferous epoch of Xikuangshan area in the central region of Hunan. Hunan Geol. 1986;5:36–50.Google Scholar
- Gao LD. Miospore zones in the Devonian-Carboniferous boundary beds in Hunan and their stratigraphical significance. Geol Rev. 1990;36:58–68.Google Scholar
- Gao LD. Spore assemblages from the Wangjiadian Formation in Zhangxian County, Gansu and their age. Gansu Geol. 1990;11:1–12.Google Scholar
- Gao LD. Late Devonian and Early Carboniferous miospore zones from southeastern Guizhou and the boundary of the Devonian and Carboniferous. Geol Guizhou. 1991;8:59–69.Google Scholar
- Wang DM, Hao SG, Wang Q. Rotafolia songziensis gen. et sp. comb. nov., a sphenopsid from the Late Devonian of Hubei, China. Bot J Linn Soc. 2005;148:21–37.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wang DM, Hao SG, Wang Q, Xue JZ. Anatomy of the Late Devonian sphenopsid Rotafolia songziensis, with a discussion of stelar architecture of the Sphenophyllales. Int J Plant Sci. 2006;167:373–83.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beck CB, Wight DC. Progymnosperms. In: Beck CB, editor. Origin and evolution of gymnosperms. New York: Columbia University Press; 1988. p. 1–84.Google Scholar
- Galtier J. Morphology and phylogenetic relationships of early pteridosperms. In: Beck CB, editor. Origin and evolution of gymnosperms. New York: Columbia University Press; 1988. p. 135–76.Google Scholar
- Scheckler SE, Banks HP. Anatomy and relationships of some Devonian progymnosperms from New York. Amer J Bot. 1971;58:737–51.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Scheckler SE, Banks HP. Proteokalon, a new genus of progymnosperms from the Devonian of New York State and its bearing on phylogenetic trends in the group. Amer J Bot. 1971;58:874–84.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wight DC. Non-adaptive change in early land plant evolution. Paleobiology. 1987;13:208–14.Google Scholar
- Beck CB, Stein WE. Crossia virginiana gen. et sp. nov., a new member of the Stenokoleales from the Middle Devonian of southwestern Virginia. Palaeontogr Abt B. 1993;229:115–34.Google Scholar
- Matten LC. Studies on Devonian plants from New York State: Stenokoleos holmesii n. sp. from the Cairo flora (Givetian) with an alternative model for lyginopterid seed fern evolution. Cour Forsch Inst Senck. 1992;147:75–85.Google Scholar
- Matten LC, Banks HP. Stenokoleos bifidus sp. n. in the Upper Devonian of New York State. Amer J Bot. 1969;56:880–91.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Barnard PDW, Long AG. On the structure of a petrified stem and some associated seeds from the Lower Carboniferous rocks of East Lothian, Scotland. Trans Roy Soc Edinb. 1973;69:91–108.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Stidd BM. A new species of Heterangium from the Illinois basin of North America. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 1979;28:249–57.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pigg KB, Taylor TN, Stockey RA. Paleozoic seed ferns: Heterangium kentuckyensis sp. nov., from the Upper Carboniferous of North America. Amer J Bot. 1987;74:1184–204.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gordon WT. On Rhetinangium arberi, a new genus of Cycadofilices from the Calciferous Sandstone series. Trans Roy Soc Edinb. 1912;48:813–25.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Long AG. On the structure of some petioles associated with Rhetinangium Gordon. Trans Roy Soc Edinb. 1964;66:1–7.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dunn MT. The Fayetteville flora I: Upper Mississippian (middle Chesterian/lower Namurian A) plant assemblages of permineralized and compression remains from Arkansas, USA. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 2004;132:79–102.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Stidd BM, Phillips TL. The vegetative anatomy of Schopfiastrum decussatum from Middle Pennsylvanian of the Illinois Basin. Amer J Bot. 1973;60:463–74.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Taylor TN, Stockey RA. Studies of Paleozoic Seed Ferns: Anatomy and Morphology of Microspermopteris aphyllum. Amer J Bot. 1976;63:1302–10.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pigg KB, Stockey RA, Taylor TN. Studies of Paleozoic Seed Ferns: Additional Studies of Microspermopteris aphyllum Baxter. Bot Gaz. 1986;147:126–36.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Galtier J, Meyer-Berthaud B. Studies of the Early Carboniferous pteridosperm Calamopitys—A redescription of the type material from Saalfeld (GDR). Palaeontogr Abt B. 1989;213:1–36.Google Scholar
- Meyer-Berthaud B. Stenomyelon from the Upper Tournaisian of the Montagne Noire (France). Can J Bot. 1984;62:2297–307.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Long AG. Some specimens of Stenomyelon and Kalymma from the Calciferous Sandstone Series of Berwickshire. Trans Roy Soc Edinb. 1964;65:435–47.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Meyer-Berthaud B, Stein WE. A Reinvestigation of Stenomyelon from the Late Tournaisian of Scotland. Int J Plant Sci. 1995;156:863–95.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Galtier J. Recherches sur les végétaux à structure conservée du Carbonifère inférieur français. Paléobiol Continent. 1970;1:1–221.Google Scholar
- Tomescu AMF, Rothwell GW, Mapes G. Lyginopteris royalii sp. nov. from the Upper Mississippian of North America. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 2001;116:159–73.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Galtier J, Beck CB. Triichnia, a new eustelic calamopityacean from the Lower Carboniferous of France. Palaeontogr Abt B. 1992;224:1–16.Google Scholar
- Stein WE, Beck CB. Bostonia perplexa gen. et sp. nov., a calamopityan axis from New Albany Shale of Kentucky. Amer J Bot. 1978;65:459–65.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Stein WE, Beck CB. New information on Bostonia perplexa-an unusual member of the Calamopityaceae from North America. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 1992;72:73–102.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gordon WT. XII.—On Tetrastichia bupatides: A Carboniferous Pteridosperm from East Lothian. Trans Roy Soc Edinb. 1938;59:351–70.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dunn MT, Rothwell GW. Phenotypic plasticity of the hydrasperman seed fern Tetrastichia bupatides Gordon (Lyginopteridaceae). Int J Plant Sci. 2012;173:823–34.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Barnard PDW, Long AG. Triradioxylon—a new genus of Lower Carboniferous petrified stems and petioles together with a review of the classification of early Pterophytina. Trans Roy Soc Edinb. 1975;69:231–49.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Long AG. Tristichia ovensi gen. sp. nov., a protostelic Lower Carboniferous pteridosperm from Berwickshire and East Lothian, with an account of some associated seeds and cupules. Trans Roy Soc Edinb. 1961;64:477–89.Google Scholar
- Galtier J, Meyer-Berthaud B. The early seed plant Tristichia tiipos (Unger) comb. nov. from the Lower Carboniferous of Saalfeld, Thuringia. Rev Palaeobot Palynol. 1996;93:299–315.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Stewart WN, Rothwell GW. Paleobotany and the Evolution of Plants. 2nd ed. New York: Cambridge University Press; 1993.Google Scholar
- Galtier J. On the Earliest Arborescent Gymnosperms. Cour Forsch Inst Senckenb. 1992;147:119–25.Google Scholar
- Galtier J, Meyer-Berthaud B. The diversification of early arborescent seed ferns. J Torrey Bot Soc. 2006;133:7–19.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hotton CL, Stein WE. An ontogenetic model for the Mississippian seed plant family Calamopityaceae. Int J Plant Sci. 1994;155:119–42.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Shadle GL, Stidd BM. The frond of Heterangium. Amer J Bot. 1975;62:67–75.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Berry CM, Wang Y. Eocladoxylon (Protopteridium) minutum (Halle) Koidzumi from the Middle Devonian of Yunnan, China: an early Rhacophyton-like plant? Int J Plant Sci. 2006;167:551–66.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wang Y, Berry CM, Hao SG, Xu HH, Fu Q. The Xichong flora of Yunnan, China: diversity in late Mid Devonian plant assemblages. Geol J. 2007;42:339–50.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beck CB, Schmid R, Rothwell GW. Stelar morphology and the primary vascular system of seed plants. Bot Rev. 1982;48:691–815.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Rothwell GW, Erwin DM. Origin of Seed Plants: An aneurophyte/seed-fern link elaborated. Amer J Bot. 1987;74:970–3.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hao SG, Gensel PG. A new genus and species, Celatheca beckii, from the Siegenian (Early Devonian) of southeastern Yunnan, China. Int J Plant Sci. 1995;156:896–909.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hao SG, Xue JZ. The Early Devonian Posongchong flora of Yunnan—a contribution to an understanding of the evolution and early diversification of vascular plants. Beijing: Science Press; 2013.Google Scholar
- Hao SG, Xue JZ. Earliest record of megaphylls and leafy structures, and their initial diversification. Chin Sci Bull. 2013;58:2784–93.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hao SG, Gensel PG. The Posongchong floral assemblages of Southeast Yunnan, China-diversity and disparity in Early Devonian plant assemblages. In: Gensel PG, Edwards D, editors. Plants invade the land: evolutionary and environmental considerations. New York: Columbia University Press; 2001. p. 103–19.Google Scholar
- Chen X, Ruan YP, Boucot AJ. Paleozoic Climatological Evolution of China. Beijing: Science Press; 2001.Google Scholar
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.